5 ms·
> Our head of HR has taken personal accountability and resigned from GitHub yesterday morning, Saturday, January 16th. You don't normally see consequences for
by pjc50 6y ago
> Our head of HR has taken personal accountability and resigned from GitHub yesterday morning, Saturday, January 16th.
You don't normally see consequences for senior officers for this kind of mistake. I would be curious to know who this person was and if they had any odd political affiliations.
- rodgerd 6y agoSeems to me that the head of HR got thrown under the bus to protect other members of the exec.
- bmiller2 6y ago> Earlier this week, the company hosted an “empathy circle” to “build understanding with members of the team on things that affect us.” It did not go over well with employees. Maybe they got fired for this terrible idea
- emphatizer2000 6y agoIsn't that standard fare for workplaces everywhere in the world now? Not that I like it much, but it seems to be the normal approach.
- morganw 6y agoI work at a company going hard on diversity and inclusion and they haven't gone even a baby step towards asking us to empathize with the grievances of people who feel fascism is the only thing that can help them. Empathy isn't the same as tolerance, but I'd expect they'd either know the optics would be terrible or don't see the difference themselves.
- emphatizer2000 6y agoNot sure how you arrive at that interpretation of "people who feel fascism is the only thing that can help them". Maybe it is about people who don't want to be called fascists, for example. But interesting to know that the empathy training is only for diverse and identity people. OK, not really surprising, but glad you admit it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- babelfish 6y agoWhen you fire a Jewish employee for (rightfully) calling out that Nazis were present at last weeks insurrection, but not folks who make jokes like “Hitler gave the Jews free healthcare” (per the Verge article another commenter posted), there better be consequences at the VP level
- tshtf 6y agoHacker News in 2021: The above comment is grey.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoYeah, Github sure sounds like a lovely company to work for, and tone is set at the top.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- akrulino 6y agoHacker News in 2021: The above comment is grey.
- 458aperta 6y agoClearly they have priorities straight or this is a case of "the fish rots from the head". It's okay to post anti-semetic memes but not calling out actual Nazis that were present? Then its okay to downvote and censor all the comments on HN that calls out the absurdity of it all? Just what is happening to HN? What is going on with the US? We are not breaking any rules yet we are all getting flagged and downvoted for expressing shock. What happened to free speech or does HN folks no longer believe in America?
- ben_w 6y agoSo far as I’m concerned, how people and organisations react to their mistakes when they are revealed matters a lot more than the fact that they make mistakes. Everyone makes mistakes, improving in response to them is what matters.
- loeg 6y agoIt's weird to me that this was the head of HR's mistake (sort of implied) and not a more junior manager (both in reality, and in who usually gets the blame even if it's a senior manager's fuck-up). There is some unnamed VP of engineering who may have kicked off the process with HR. I don't know. I'm glad GH (1) took another look at the firing, (2) realized they were mistaken, and (3) mea culpa'd publicly.
- LiquidSky 6y agoBut this is how it should work, the person in charge taking responsibility for what happens under them instead of foisting it on an underling, regardless of who made the actual decision. The buck ultimately stops at the top. More leaders should be like this.
- otterley 6y agoA good leader is supposed to take responsibility for the actions taken by his or her team. Failure of a unit implies failure of the leadership. In my view, the right outcome happened here.
- loeg 6y ago> A good leader is supposed to take responsibility for the actions taken by his or her team. Failure of a unit implies failure of the leadership. I've heard the same "leadership principles seppuku" and sure, this would be consistent with that ethos. (In my experience, that kind of buck-stops-here ownership happens less often than not.) But this isn't the part of your comment I want to argue. > In my view, the right outcome happened here. I disagree (if it was a subordinate). If the responsible party was a more junior member of HR, I'd like to see the blowback land on the actually culpable party. (That could be in addition, or alternative, to the leader's resignation.)
- watwut 6y agoIf a junior member of HR was able to fire employee without review by other people and proper plausibly lookimg documentation, then the responsibility is 100% on whoever invented such process. Which is the lead. Because really, that would put the company not just at risk of what is going on now, but also at risk of very expensive lawsuits.
- geofft 6y agoThe head of HR was Carrie Olesen, who doesn't seem like she had any odd political affiliations: https://profilemagazine.com/2020/carrie-olesen-github/ https://profilemagazine.com/2020/carrie-olesen-github/ https://github.blog/author/carrieoleson/ https://github.blog/author/carrieoleson/ However, it's worth noting that the statement says "resigned from GitHub," and she was at Microsoft before the acquisition and moved to GitHub. I wonder if it means she's still with Microsoft. Maybe I'm reading too much into it.
- smeyer 6y agoHer political donations also look completely unremarkable: Obama, Biden, The Lincoln Project, etc.. I'm not sure what the previous commentator is wondering about possible political affiliations, but she certainly doesn't seem to stand out. https://www.fec.gov/data/receipts/individual-contributions/?contributor_name=carrie+olesen&max_date=12%2F31%2F2020 https://www.fec.gov/data/receipts/individual-contributions/?...