2 ms·
My main complaint about Signal is its reliance on SS7/PSTN and ordinary phone numbers to identify a user. In an era of SS7 hijacks and social-engineering of mo
by walrus01 6y ago
My main complaint about Signal is its reliance on SS7/PSTN and ordinary phone numbers to identify a user.
In an era of SS7 hijacks and social-engineering of mobile phone network customer service reps into SIM-hijacking a target's phone service, by no means should we ever rely upon a phone number as a guaranteed method of identifying an end point device's identity.
These are basically the same reasons why other services' "2FA" by SMS is questionable at best.
- ehutch79 6y agoDoesn't the protocol detect device changes?
- walrus01 6y agoIt does, and it warns the other users chatting with the person whose device has changed, but given the tendency of non technical users to click "yes/accept/okay" buttons in the GUI to bypass any error messages that come up on their mobile phone screens, I question how much value it has. Two experiences: Among highly technical users in my peer group, when somebody upgrades or replaces their phone, if we're chatting with somebody who has a new signal device private key, I'll chat with them a bit by voice to confirm it really is them using a new phone. We've had a number of discussions about how it's apparently impossible to manually move ones' own signal private keys from disk storage on an android device onto a new android device. This works among people I know closely and recognize the sound of their voice. Among non technical users, they'll just click the equivalent of "okay" and continue chatting without even thinking about what the error message means.
- snthd 6y agoThere's a "registration lock" feature for exactly this problem. Turn it on and you need your pin to re-register. (It expires after 7 days). Not perfect by any means, but it seems like a well balanced compromise, given the decision to use phone numbers in the first place.