4 ms·
Epic vs Apple is a matter of principle, even if the complaint is from a untrustworthy source. Walled gardens should be dismantled. They shouldn't have been all
by oblio 6y ago
Epic vs Apple is a matter of principle, even if the complaint is from a untrustworthy source.
Walled gardens should be dismantled. They shouldn't have been allowed to begin with, for Nintendo 64 or whatever it was.
- zepto 6y agoThere is no principle involved. ‘Wall garden’ isn’t a real category’. People should be able to choose to enter a walled garden if it suits them. When a corporation like Epic uses the law to take away people’s rights is rarely about principle. Epic vs Apple is about nothing except Epic profiting from Apple’s work, and removing a relatively safe place to buy software. At the very least if Epic and Tencent are in fact bad actors, we should be curious about why they are motivated in the case. It’s not out of altruism.
- Trill-I-Am 6y agoWould iPhone users be worse off if they gained the ability to use multiple different app stores?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zepto 6y agoYes. They would lose the option to use one trusted store, and be forced to use set of different stores of varying different trust levels.
- oblio 6y agoAre you sure about that? Chinese phones use Chine app stores because Google products are banned in China, but outside of China 99% of apps are installed through the Play Store. Why would iOS be any different?
- zepto 6y agoBecause iOS has a very profitable app ecosystem that deep pocketed competitors (such as Google, Facebook, and Amazon) would buy into. You can’t seriously imagine that at least these three plus TenCent/Epic wouldn’t create stores, likely within their existing Apps.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leppr 6y agoThat's right, but Epic is also in actively working against supporting Linux. Walled gardens are bad, but Epic is definitely not a company that will fight that fight. They just want the iOS userbase. There's no sense in supporting them.
- oblio 6y agoIsn't US law based on precedent? If Epics wins the lawsuit against Apple, doesn't that set a precedent that all walled garden vendors need to allow an alternative way to install applications?
- BuckRogers 6y agoWe’ll be worse off with multiple vendors. We chose this platform for all its advantages. Including top shelf support and security.
- leppr 6y agoSo you're asserting that the only reason developers would keep developing for the Apple App Store is if they have no other choice? Security guarantees are a sales-pitch, hard to get numbers on that but I bet I'm not the only one that avoids installing random proprietary apps out of fear for privacy violations. The recent move to showing "privacy promises" on the App store pages is an indication of that. If alternative stores can't give sufficient security guarantees, then users will prefer the official one. Android is doing well with its multiple app-stores, security-conscious users can limit themselves to F-droid, and the rest can keep using the PlayStore for proprietary apps. Granted Android still lacks an independent option for paid apps, but I think it will come.
- zepto 6y ago“If alternative stores can't give sufficient security guarantees, then users will prefer the official one.” Nope. Users will use the stores where the apps they want are. Players starting new stores will just pay for exclusives of popular apps, so that users are forced to install other stores, which will of course claim to support privacy and security in marketing terms that have no substance. Android is why it is clearly wrong to intervene in Apple’s secure store. If people want a choice of stores, Android is available and just as good as iPhone.