4 ms·
Nothing about SLS makes sense to me economically. F9 Launch Cost (without reuse): $65mm FH Launch Cost (without reuse): $150mm SLS Launch Cost: >$2,000mm
by bob1029 6y ago
Nothing about SLS makes sense to me economically.
F9 Launch Cost (without reuse): $65mm
FH Launch Cost (without reuse): $150mm
SLS Launch Cost: >$2,000mm
How does anyone square this arrangement? What saving graces does SLS have (from an engineering perspective) compared to the SpaceX programs? There are certainly a lot of downsides and I would be really disappointed to learn that there are no upsides.
- markus_zhang 6y agoYou gotta take care of your brothers and sisters, and you ex-colleuages too, and that's a lot of money bro. The real upside I think is that people finally figured out there are more economical choices other than the big boys alliance.
- imglorp 6y agoIt's all about Congress, the native American criminal class. They're already $14 billion in. https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2019/10/nasa-buying-ten-sls-rocket-launches-through-2035-in-a-show-of-washington-corruption.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2019/10/nasa-buying-ten-sls-ro... I'd like to point out the development process appears to be waterfall. Instead of many cheap iterations, blowing stuff up and continually improving, they want few, complete, expensive articles: that means many tests like OP article is going to need spin as a "failure" and not a learning cycle.
- BurningFrog 6y agoIt fits with the OP theory of "an expensive jobs program for Alabama, Texas and Florida." If you think of that as the actual purpose, this is a successful project.
- dmix 6y agoTaking useful rocket scientists, engineers, programmers, etc, plus all of their blue collar support staff from away from productive industry sounds like the worst possible "jobs" program in the world. Calling it a success simply because the money was spent without considering opportunity costs [1] is just bad money management. It's how you end up with these blackhole gov programs in the first place. Extremely wasteful space programs at least typically get justified as also a) 'inspiring' kids into STEM + b) providing national pride. But when all you get in return is decades of doing nothing interesting I doubt many kids will be inspired. And after so many years and getting blown by competitively by private industry turns it into a national embarrassment (even things exploding is more interesting than what they've produced the last few decades with this program). When you factor in the opportunity cost, aka the alternative ares NOT getting "jobs programs", or rather the capital investment, like infrastructure or healthcare or a hundred other possibilities. Things which can employ plenty of blue collar rust-belt workers into jobs that directly support the needs of modern industry who funds these tax paid adventures (ie, transit/railways, electric grid, broadband, etc). Stuff that supports and underpins the new 'knowledge based economy' instead of drawing resources away from it. Not to mention providing a stopgap to a 'lost generation' of former typically-unionized industrial workers who couldn't compete globally after the 1980s when they could have been provided some critical time while their kids adapt and get education/skills needed for the new self-sustaining, productive, and heavily automated/software driven industries that the developed world has transitioned too. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/opportunitycost.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/opportunitycost.asp
- BurningFrog 6y agoTo be clear, I agree with you. My point is that the people who created this project didn't have the same goals as you or I would have, and their goals have probably been accomplished.
- izend 6y agoNotice the use solid rocket fuel in the SLS and the mandate from Congress to retain the skills and experience. What else uses solid fuel? The US ICBM arsenal.
- blackrock 6y agoCan Falcon Heavy launch payloads with a wider diameter? I assume they’d have to build an additional adapter to handler wider payloads.
- pfdietz 6y agoDo we need payloads with wide diameter?
- jariel 6y agoWell could it be the F9 etc. are targeted at a very well established commercial class with tons of buyers, economic outputs, stable market, opportunity for re-use. Whereas SLS is more like big fantasy science missions, much less frequent and nobody willing to really pay for it but government? As a very, very crude way of looking at it?
- nickik 6y agoIts actually much worse then that. These are not the 'cost' for F9/FH, that is the price. The cost of these launch is like 1/2 to 1/3. Part of the price is also amortizing past development cost. In the SLS launch non of that is included. If you take into account the full development cost and amortize them over all the launches (and calculate the interest on government debt) the price is actually way higher then what you have listed. - SLS is more powerful then FH but not by as much as people think. - SLS is human-rated and FH is not, but that is mostly because there is no reason to human-rate the FH. - SLS has the potential to be extend significantly to outperform FH by a much larger margin but that will cost another X billion and another Y years. - SLS was supposed to be cheap by using lots of legacy technology. So in reality Falcon series are actually pretty much newer and more modern in pretty much every design aspect. Of course when SLS was designed Falcon was 'unproven' and the parts of the SLS were 'proven'. However of course this has totally reversed by now. SLS rocket is simply a bad design. It was the outcome of a bad process partly pushed by congress on NASA and partly by NASA engineers own failure to analyse the situation properly. A large part of this is the believe to reuse 'proven' technologies and more importantly to reuse that same workforce. Because it used Cost+ contracting the contractors have no intensive what so ever to perform well. The keep getting their bonus payments for good performance even, something that independent government reviews has pointed out multiple times. So to sum up, there is very little to almost nothing that is gained by SLS. Its a huge part of the NASA budget every year that could be invested in amazing developments. You could fully fund the lunar lander program AND do other preparation for moon bases for example. Edit: This talk form 2011 is quite interesting. I often call it the SpaceX antithesis talk. He even mentions SpaceX a couple of times and references them without naming them. He quite literally says 'if we can't make this affordable they will from in future just let SpaceX do it' and he made it clear their main design goal is affordability and having a program that could meet milestones. Well, that didn't work out so much. See: - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IweLWCBHpUE?t=0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IweLWCBHpUE?t=0