3 ms·
> Honestly don’t see how you can protect against even moderate level spearphishing reasonably. WebAuthn. The article author dismisses it as basically too incon
by tialaramex 6y ago
> Honestly don’t see how you can protect against even moderate level spearphishing reasonably.
WebAuthn. The article author dismisses it as basically too inconvenient (they apparently keep their Security Key somewhere out of reach and they struggle to remember the complicated user interaction of... pressing a button)
But WebAuthn is completely effective against phishing.
The closest to plausible attacks are: The bad guys take over the target servers (no reason to phish you); The bad guys persuade you to physically send them your authentication device (truly not everybody can be helped...); The bad guys persuade you to install software under their control on a general purpose PC (this won't work on a Phone) and then you follow their bad instructions to "use" your authenticator with their software to get them in.
Mutually authenticated TLS is in principle viable, and I have used it in machine-to-machine systems, but the UX is atrocious and it has grave privacy problems.
- guenthert 6y agoI think the conundrum is that such a device uses either a simple UI (like pressing the button), which then is unable to convey to the user which transaction is to be signed off on (the desktop/laptop/phone might be compromised) or the device has its own display and multiple-choice input that'll be too expensive and cumbersome for all to carry around all the time, everywhere.