3 ms·
This is true in general but I've seen it mostly commonly in Java and done by people who are certain that you aren't doing Java right if you don't. That's why I
by acdha 6y ago
This is true in general but I've seen it mostly commonly in Java and done by people who are certain that you aren't doing Java right if you don't. That's why I said “Java community” — there are definitely people pushing for less gratuitous complexity but they don't appear to be a majority. I've seen people be told that they might not be smart enough to be programmers if they didn't immediately grasp the wisdom of a small project needing a hugely complex stack, and once you get the filtering mechanism of that attitude going it takes active effort to recover.
- pjmlp 6y agoThe Java JEE community was created by former C++ CORBA and DCOM developers. Everything that people complain about Java culture has its roots in 90's C++ and Smalltalk enterprise development platforms. Even J2EE initial version, hated by so many Java bashers, was originally written in Objective-C as part of the collaboration effort between NeXT and Sun, in the context of OpenSTEP support for Solaris. Which ended up Sun coming up with J2EE after they decided Java was the way forward and not Objective-C, while Apple post NeXT acquisition when Java still had parity with Objective-C, used the same ideas to port WebObjects into Java as well.
- acdha 6y agoYes – if I was writing a longer comment C++ would have been my first choice for a contender in the competition of which language has been worse served by complexity fetishists. My point to the original poster was that it was too simplistic to criticize people for not using Java or the JVM without acknowledging the many legitimate reasons which motivated people to adopt alternatives, and many of the recent features the language has acquired were added because they’d been popular elsewhere. I consider that healthy since competition benefits everyone and especially in programming languages many partisans are loathe to admit that different people have different sweet spots because not everyone does the same work.
- WClayFerguson 6y agoEverybody on this thread took literally my wish of "one language" but I never would've said C++ would be replaced by Java, for example. So I really meant "one language" in each category. Obviously there has to be a language to generate machine code, and then another higher-level language on top of that, and so forth. The world is better off with fewer rather than more languages for obvious reasons. I never really considered the industry to be a fragmented mess until "Go" and "Rust" came along. That was the straw on the camels back for me where I just said: "Ok please stop, you aren't helping."
- rottc0dd 6y agoI have just used one language professionally, but do you think having just one language can solve the problem? But, I agree if a language has all the features you need, and is mainstream, you are well off using that than jumping in for another language for the heck of it and reinventing wheel is not helping anybody. I am repeating myself, but different people might have different working style. And have different communities have different taste and ways of doing stuff. Language is not the only barrier in communication. It is just one parameter. I honestly think, different languages allows different ways of doing things (not better), with different tradeoffs. My preference to some language is not just about language I know, but also with respect to what I want to do. And how I want to do solve the problem at hand. Even if a language, supports all possible styles of programming, will that result in a coherent language? Then, might the language be language not get very big that different people working in different styles resulting either in monstrosity of code base or fragmentation in language community. Else, the language itself might not represent the problems succinctly as the user wants. Features are not the only issue here. If the language is just needles and redundant, there is not going to be difference in its absence. Yet, I have seen people who have very strong opinions on how to organize code, OOP or not OOP, and of course tabs vs spaces. The fragmentation is inevitable and going to exist as long as strong opinions exist.
- WClayFerguson 6y agoThe best analogy I can think of to make the point of how important the 'single language syntax' goal should be is "mathematics". Imagine if everyone "doing" math did it their own way, using their own sets of symbols, and syntax. Even Einstein got his Special Theory of Relativity transform directly from Lorentz. Most innovations are built on top of other innovations, and the ability to share depends on common language.