3 ms·
> Traditionally two kinds of private industries have been deemed to be “clothed in the public interest.” One consists of “common carriers,” the other “public ac
by SV_BubbleTime 6y ago
> Traditionally two kinds of private industries have been deemed to be “clothed in the public interest.” One consists of “common carriers,” the other “public accommodations.” A common carrier like a railroad cannot refuse service to passengers or cargo, with narrow exceptions. And a public accommodation like a hotel or a restaurant or a grocery store cannot reject paying customers, with narrow exceptions.
Written in regards to SCOTUS precedent of instructions for private companies, it’s hard to see how the tech monopolies are not “common carrier” if not also a “public accommodation” depending on how you want to look at it.
> The result is our present situation, in which some of the indispensable industries in the U.S. economy, social life, the media and politics are allowed to make their own rules, in the form of ever-changing “terms of service” that nobody reads;
Either way... it seems like this can (should) not continue this way. Like everything hyper-partisan now; I expect we only see a reaction when the pendulum swings and for a brief moment “both sides” can agree something is wrong, until “the other side” switches there position and this is OK now.
- dantheman 6y agoThese are neither of these things, if anything they're publishers - like booksellers or newspapers; on the web anyone can be a publisher in minutes at almost zero cost. common carriers and public accommodations have to do with limited access in the physical world - none of those constrains apply to the digital one.
- AlexTWithBeard 6y ago> on the web anyone can be a publisher in minutes at almost zero cost. But in case of common carriers, everyone can also carry their stuff from one location to another.
- howlgarnish 6y agoThe top HN story earlier today was a tale of how Google can effectively cripple a company that doesn't even use any of its services: https://gomox.medium.com/google-safe-browsing-can-kill-your-startup-7d73c474b98d https://gomox.medium.com/google-safe-browsing-can-kill-your-...