6 ms·
Nonsense. A lot of people don't understand that for a composer of Beethoven's training and skill, physically hearing the music is essentially irrelevant. The im
by tomcam 6y ago
Nonsense. A lot of people don't understand that for a composer of Beethoven's training and skill, physically hearing the music is essentially irrelevant. The image we have in our heads of a composer sitting at the piano and noodling almost certainly doesn't apply to a Beethoven or a Bach or a Schumann. It would slow them down intolerably. They could read music and hear it as surely as you and I can see word pictures when we read a novel. They would compose and hear the music in their head and simply transcribe.
- jeofken 6y agoFor anyone interested in getting a hang out of this, here’s is one way. In computing we have massive amount of logic gates and wires into and out of the computer - from this we can create all kinds of things. In music, you have intervals between frequencies and you have time intervals between these, ie rhythm. Traditionally we divide the space between a sound frequency and the double of it into 12 notes, because it’s a great number to divide by. That means a middle A is 440Hz. 440Hzx2=880Hz. That interval is called “octave”. Middle C on a piano is thus at 261.6256Hz [0]. Of these 12 “raw” simple fractional divisions, you can select a number of notes that played make a certain mood. If you start at C on a piano and hit the white keys to the next C, you will have hit the 8 notes we group as the “C major” scale. In this group there are 8 frequencies selected. The 1st is middle C, 2nd is D, 3rd is E, and so forth. For this example I chose C major just because all the notes have easy names - so flats or sharps, but that’s just a side effect of the language we use to talk about tone frequencies. The interval “5th” sounds great. Hit a C and then G and thank God for creating you in a world of beauty. The frequency of G is 1.5x the frequency of C. The major 5th of A is thus 440Hzx1.5=660Hz. The major 3rd interval is also a beauty; hit C and then E. It’s all about fractions and multiples, and mathematical beauty. Each interval in each scale (1st, 2nd, etc) have a certain feel to it. The 7th makes you feel tension - almost home! The 5th inspires heavenly joy. You can try to find a song you know that contains the intervals. IIRC Norway’s pride Take On Me by A-Ha has a chorus beginning with a 7th and then one step - that would be C4-B5-C5. In Norwegian you’d write C4-H5-C5 though, since B is called H in “the Germanic tribes”, maybe so that you can play “B-A-C-H” on your instrument. Just like if you nerd out on assembly or binary code for a few years, you can read what a processor would do by just seeing a list of numbers, if you do music for a while you can learn to read music without having to have an instrument embody it for you. Enjoy music! [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piano_key_frequencies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piano_key_frequencies Ps I agree with the parent comment - as always when reading something from NYT about a topic I’m not unfamiliar with, I realise it’s a publication somewhat detached from reality.
- nerbert 6y agoThis is amazing. Thanks for taking us through it.
- petervm 6y agoThis is great! Any resource you'd recommend for someone who learned to play the guitar but has no idea what he's doing? I'd love to learn more about music theory and stop relying so much on memorization. I know there are a ton of resources out there but most of them seem to fall on the extremes – either too big a commitment or too superficial.
- cmrdsprklpny 6y agohttps://tobyrush.com/theorypages/pdf/en-us/the-whole-enchilada-set.pdf https://tobyrush.com/theorypages/pdf/en-us/the-whole-enchila... This covers most Classical theory in a pretty clear way, it’s cheesy but does a good job. We used this more than the textbook in a music theory class. Jazz and contemporary theory gets a little more fun, but this is a really good place to start.
- petervm 6y agoThis looks great! Thanks
- jeofken 6y agoThank you. I too was a guitar player of chords memorised for a long time, but took a gap year to study music. I’ll share how to level up so you don’t have to take a year off :). When I said the tones are divisions by 12 it was a small simplification. On your guitar you can see a physical representation of the difference in frequencies between tones - the first fret is very wide, but they narrow as you traverse the neck. Tell me, how much shorter is the 12th fret compared to the 1st? And after reading this whole reply, tell me how much shorter is the fret of the major 5th compared to the fret of its tonic? It’s fraction magick... A shorthand for remembering scales my teacher taught me is this. When building a scale we call the first one the tonic, and given the frequency of the tonic and knowing what scale (major, minor, lydian, etc), we can find the rest, like a simple algebra problem. To find a major scale, the shorthand is “2.5, 3.5”. That means first 2 whole steps, then a half step, then 3 whole steps, then a half step. A whole step is 2 frets on the guitar. A half step is one fret. That’s how you filter out 8 of the 12 frets to play a major scale on your guitar neck. So go to your guitar and let’s say we ‘let tonic = loose D string’. From there on, do a whole step, pluck, and one more time, then a half step, then whole+pluck, whole+pluck, whole+pluck, then half+pluck. You’ve just found the major D scale! The 4th tone in the major scale of E is A. The 4th of A major is D. Do you now see the pattern of why you tune the next string to fret 5 (I.e 2.5 whole steps)? The guitar is tuned in these 4ths, except for one string which is the B string which is a 3rd of its precious IIRC. Haven’t played guitar for ages.. From now on tune like a pro - start with a A of 440Hz and tune the other strings from there. Just temperament rocks equal temperament sucks ;p. By tuning like a pro and plucking two loose strings and tuning until you recognise “as, it’s a 4th!”, you learn to remember how that interval sounds. You can check by putting your finger on the previous strings 5th fret, but tune only one string (A) after an electronic tuner. Now you know how to from any tonic find its major scale with the shorthand 2.5,3.5. If you look up a minor scale, what would its shorthand be? Now you can find a minor scale always. What would the shorthand of the pentatonic (meaning 5-note scale) blues scale be? Now you don’t need sunglasses indoors to be cool anymore. Sadly much music theory online shy away from the math beauty and systematicness of music, because most people have trauma from government school maths class and say “I’m not good with maths”, but the truth is music is simple, fractional, and beautiful. Let’s learn how to construct chords now. You know how to find a major scale. Let’s say you wanna play a C major chord, something you may have memorised. On the A string, you put a finger on the 3rd fret. Wow! That’s also the tonic of the C major scale! On the next string you hit fret 2. After D comes D#, then E. wait, that’s the 3rd in C major scale!! Holy smokes. Then comes a G right? In C major scale, G is the heavenly, awe-inspiring, 1.5 frequency multiplying, major 5th! And so on. To make a chord, select the 1st (I.e tonic) of a scale, the 3rd, and the 5th. To make a 7th chord, add the 7th to the mix (for C major that’d be B in English I.e H in Germanic countries where I’m writing from). I’d love to have (or maybe to have written) a book “music for programmers”. My instrument tutor was a retired physics teacher, that was great... Ok one more practical tip: start a new instrument. You don’t have to buy but can rent for maybe $30-$40/month. For me it was such a habit to have the guitar and strum some cool chords, that switching to a new instrument where I was a beginner, and there were no websites of “1000 chord diagrams to make you a rock star” freed me to learn the basics. I suggest finding a tutor to meet once a week in a basement, pay $40 cash, and learn with sheet music and all. Homework is your friend here! Instruments I recommend are fiddle/cello (awesomely fun and really gets you thinking about frequencies and fractions as you don’t have the crutch of frets) or flute or clarinet, because they sing so beautifully. My biased choice is to start with the fiddle, and play European classical but also folk (American and European folk both use a lot of fiddle). American folk is so much fun. Good luck and feel free to reply with any question.
- tshaddox 6y agoI don’t know. I’m sure the masters can hear music in their heads extremely well, but from what I have read it seems that Beethoven was distressed about his deafness specifically as it related to his profession. I haven’t done my research on how legit these supposed quotes are, but they give that impression: > Ah, how could I possibly admit an infirmity in the one sense which ought to be more perfect in me than in others, a sense which I once possessed in the highest perfection > If I belonged to any other profession it would be easier, but in my profession it is a frightful state
- betenoire 6y agoBut I think being distressed is distinct from the ability to do what the grandparent describes. There is a lot of physical joy in experiencing music, and that was probably lost to him to an extent. I can imagine writing code with my eyes closed, I can even "see" the architecture and structure of it all in my mind's eye
- tshaddox 6y agoI doubt it’s just that. I can imagine code with my eyes closed too, but it would be a wild exaggeration to say that losing the ability to see wouldn’t make it more difficult to do professional software engineering.
- betenoire 6y agoright, doing it would be harder because our tools are all visually oriented. But you could still describe the process in great detail to someone who could type it for you, and your expertise is still there. When I play the piano, my hands naturally move to the notes I want to hear, before I hear physically hear them play the notes. My point is, you don't type code and then look to see if it is right, you type what you know you want. Likewise, he didn't play a note to check if it was the right one, he knew. (and of course, what do I actually know about beethoven's workflow, but if I can do it to an extent, I'm sure he could)
- 6y ago
- rectang 6y agoYou're so certain. :( I studied music theory and composition in college, so at one time I was at least somewhat practiced in reading and writing scores. My impression is that when you hear something aloud it's nearly always different to some degree from what you imagined in your head — and I don't think even someone like Beethoven escaped this entirely. I feel confident that he would have made minor adjustments to many of the late works he was never able to hear — he was known as a "reviser" in his working methods anyway. My best evidence for this is the weird harmonic rhythm of the second movement of Sonata #32. ("Harmonic rhythm" is a technical term having to do with where we perceive a move from chord to chord.) The harmonies change at odd points. I don't believe that the effect was entirely deliberate — I think he meant for the harmonic rhythm to be straightforward and merely to anticipate with some melodic gestures. He was probably experimenting, but when you do something unusual, that's when feedback is even more important. When I read that sonata, though, the harmonic rhythm I hear in my head doesn't seem off. The barlines provide a downbeat, and the apparent harmonies from the melodic gestures don't override it.
- tomcam 6y agoI am certain. I was a theory & comp major too. My girlfriend at the time was in medical school and I studied every bit as hard as she did, at least 6 hours a day not including practicing my instrument. > My impression is that when you hear something aloud it's nearly always different to some degree from what you imagined in your head For me and probably you, sure. For Beethoven, I seriously doubt they differed much at all. The piano sonatas are ridiculously challenging and I'm more than willing to go along with you, but we could be wrong. I like your analysis and never thought about it that way. In general though as a (below-average) composer yes, I'm very certain about hearing things in your head. If I can do it he could do it with infinitely greater depth and efficiency. About that particular piece, there's also the remote possibility of an editing or transcription disaster. He was not exactly thrilled with his publishers. More likely the former but I think you're right, the intent was probably there in his head.
- corin_ 6y agoI obviously can't speak to Beethoven, but I have witnessed a couple of very successful modern composers (of classical music) - just in passing now and then, I didn't sit down and study their methodology, but can definitely vouch for having seen extremely talented and successful composers sat at a keyboard instrument tapping out ideas. No doubt they, like Beethoven, would be much more able to compose some if not all in their heads than i would be, but it doesn't mean they don't still find useful, at least sometimes, basic stuff that amateur composers do.
- throwaway5752 6y agoThis is an interview with an actual working and deaf composer. Read the article for her actual words on the matter. She talks about things like "From the time I was a little girl, I have been fascinated with how deafness affected Beethoven. If you look at his piano sonatas, in that first one in F Minor, the hands are very close together and the physical choreographies of the left and right hands are not that dissimilar. As he gets older, the activity of the hands become more dissimilar in his piano work, and farther apart." and "I think it’s fascinating, too, that as Beethoven’s hands stretched for lower and higher notes, he demanded pianos with added notes, elongating the pitch range of the keyboard; he asked for physically heavier instruments that resonated with more vibration. More pitch distance and difference, and more vibration and resonance, create a recipe for happiness for a hearing-impaired person, trust me. A more dissonant and thick language, with clashing frequencies, also causes more vibration, so the language does get more physically visceral that way, too." It's a fascinating article and people should try actually reading it instead of jumping to conclusions about it.
- tomcam 6y agoSorry are you implying I didn't read the article? > As he gets older, the activity of the hands become more dissimilar in his piano work, and farther apart Well that can be said of many composers, even the ones we think of as "old school", like Bach. From the middle of Bach's life onward his music gets increasingly challenging and dissonant. Play some of the alto lines on a flute and it's indistinguishable from bebop to a layperson's ear. Seriously crazy shit. Also, even though Bach was a also string player (and probably an expert one, because he could play Bach pieces ;) some of the published works end up with errors that are hard or impossible to play. This can’t be attributed to deafness. As with Mozart, Bach and many other composers (maybe not Haydn), Beethoven seems to have got bored with his older styles and kept moving aggressively forward.
- throwaway5752 6y agoIt really wasn't possible to tell if you read the article or not from what you wrote, the author didn't seem make the point that you reacted to. Also, your post seemed to ignore the great pains Beethoven went through to "hear" through vibration after he lost his hearing. He clearly desired to hear and presumably it added value to whatever mental model of the piece he created. Nobody disagrees he did some of the most staggering compositions in history after he lost his hearing, so clearly you are correct about him composing music in his head. I don't have the knowledge to know if it was something in his deafness, the emotional trauma of losing his hearing, or something else entirely that's responsible. I agree artists of all media (written, visual, musical) seem to become more abstract as they age, and probably that boredom plays some part in it.
- mlang23 6y agoMozart is most famous for the ability you describe. I am not soooo sure about Beethoven, esp. since there are stories of him using a sort of bone-contact thing while playing piano.
- seamyb88 6y agoTo be able to write what Beethoven did, and the amount of it, I would say he had this ability too. Can't really say that wanting to hear better while he played is a sign that he didn't. What's a scientific understanding of music if you can't hear?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jancsika 6y ago> The image we have in our heads of a composer sitting at the piano and noodling almost certainly doesn't apply to a Beethoven or a Bach or a Schumann. There's a mountain of evidence of Beethoven literally sitting at a piano and noodling. He started his career and was widely known as a professional piano noodler! Furthermore, his early and mid-period music is dominated by the kinds of themes and figuration you'd expect from a professional piano noodler. Try singing op. 2 no. 1 piano sonata vs. fitting your hand to the keys. It actually took Beethoven a long time and a lot of work to become proficient at writing things like lyrical melodies and non-clunky, non-pianistic counterpoint (and I'd argue he gave up on the latter and just figured out the best contexts for clunky counterpoint to be most effective). Schumann also had some material in his symphonies that suspiciously fits the hands rather nicely on the piano. So it isn't so cut and dry as you make it out. Bach was a bit different. At least for quite a stretch he was writing weekly cantatas where he'd do a performance on Sunday, then on Monday start writing the cantata for the next week. When you factor in the logistics of copying all the parts, practicing with the choir, etc., it doesn't leave much time for composing an entire service of music for small orchestra and choir. And these are typically around 30 minutes of music, pieces full of sophisticated polyphony. Even if you memorized an entire cantata and time-traveled back to take his place I think you'd still be cutting it close just to copy it onto paper in the daylight you had available. And last I studied this, there was no evidence of a notepad or anything that he used to sketch out his ideas. Anyhow, Bach and Mozart are the only composers I know of for whom the evidence suggests "transcribing from the head." Edit: actually, even if the choir were one person to a part, Bach's cantatas are so full of fugal textures and virtuosic solos that it would still be challenging just to write everything down, copy the parts, and rehearse the music. I.e., it's not like writing 30 minutes of single-melody songs, scribbling some tab notation above it and letting the accompanists fill everything in accordingly. In fact, I might be downplaying it. In addition to what most people think of as baroque polyphony, the cantatas also have a more-or-less simple "chorale tune" flowing either on top of that, or possibly in the organ pedals. And Bach wrote out the organ part that I believe he would have been playing himself. So imagine a modern Church service with hymns and stuff, and paste that on top of what you think of as Bach's music to get a Bach cantata. :)
- tomcam 6y ago