7 ms·
> and 60 years hence we’ll have settled Mars, solved worldwide energy generation and storage, and invented AGI. Even evolution cannot overcome the cold, hard l
by paulryanrogers 6y ago
> and 60 years hence we’ll have settled Mars, solved worldwide energy generation and storage, and invented AGI.
Even evolution cannot overcome the cold, hard limitations of physics. Unless by settled Mars you mean some transplanted bacteria survive there, and solved energy we consumed every reasonably reachable drop of fossil fuel.
- zaroth 6y agoI’d say it’s pretty well certain that between solar and wind there’s abundant energy to be harvested. It’s just a matter of storing it cheaply, and lithium supply is rather extensive. At this point it’s “simply” a matter of scaling up the manufacturing base, which is one thing humans are astoundingly good at. Just look at silicon production scale over the last 40 years and extrapolate for lithium ion. Likewise, there’s no boundary in physics, technology or human physiology to stop us from establishing a human colony on Mars.
- paulryanrogers 6y ago> there’s no boundary in physics, technology or human physiology to stop us from establishing a human colony on Mars. There's no self sustaining settlement in Antarctica. Mars is much further away and less habitable.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoMars being farther away makes it a better candidate for a self sustaining settlement. Why try to make a self contained settlement on Antarctica when what you want the scientists there to spend their time on is research? I mean it would be cool but I can understand why it isn’t necessary there.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThat's true, but on the other hand, it's much, much, much simpler to have a self-sustaining colony in Antarctica than on Mars. And there's also nothing to be gained from Mars in any reasonable time frame other than research. I am extremely skeptical that we will even have a space station on Mars in the next 60 years. A self sustaining colony is laughably far off.
- ithkuil 6y agoNecessity is the mother of invention. Often this become necessary for no good reason, but once that are necessary they can be the only reason that matters.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThis argument could be applied to anything that is not completely impossible, right? It essentially pre-supposes that if something is theoretically possible, humanity can do it with today's engineering practices. I don't think this is a safe assumption.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoI think that’s taking it too far. We haven’t made Antarctica self sustaining because it hasn’t been necessary. But making Mars potentially self sustaining (at least in an emergency situation) is more important given the vast distance to Earth. And from an engineering and physics perspective it seems perfectly possible as long as humans can survive in low gravity for generations.
- tsimionescu 6y agoIt sounds like the scenario you are imagining is something like us building a colony on Mars dependent on the Earth, and some time after having a situation where the colony must become self-sustaining or go extinct. I would say that, unless the colony has a few more hundred years of contact with the Earth to prepare for this, it will go extinct with 100% certainty. The amount of resources and people that you would need for a colony on Mars to survive indefinitely without imports from Earth is staggering. You would need all of the highest tech industries from Earth (certainly chip fabs and robotics), large mining operations, smelters. You would need enough population to man all of these (or automation on a scale we are very far from, that could entirely handle factories and self-maintenance), and enough agriculture for this population. And you would have to do all of this with no access to fossil fuels - which also means no plastics and no access to many common lubricants. And of course, all of these things would have to be built underground, with huge tunnel boring operations required for any expansion. This may all seem possible from a physics perspective, but it is something that would have to be planned for generations in advance, well outside of our realistic civil engineering capabilities at least. And since doing all of this with the hundred million people that would be required with today's industrial practices would likely complicate things a lot more on Mars, you would need automation at a level that our robotics engineering is still very far from. It all seems possible to some extent, but definitely not something that could happen during a catastrophe, and absolutely not something that could happen without all of the bases being laid out from Earth (that is, it is impossible for a colony that was not designed and prepared from Earth to be fully self-sustaining to become self-sustaining once on Mars out of necessity).
- postingawayonhn 6y agoThere's not really any incentive to create one and the long dark winters aren't exactly ideal for food or energy production.
- WalterBright 6y agoSettlements in Antarctica are not practical because of the Antarctic Treaty System.
- abecedarius 6y agoWhich physical limit specifically? I don't see any relevant one; 60 years is a long time.
- refactor_master 6y agoRadiation, temperature and the lack of oxygen and gravity, for example? Tell me how many underwater and arctic settlements we have today. They should be unclaimed territories just teeming with possibility, in our own backyard. Yet they’re... not? You’d think that after space flight we’d have 8 metro lines in the Arctic by now, if it was all just a matter of waiting around. And you want to fly how far for something that supposedly is full of some untapped potential?
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoIdk about others but Elon’s stated goal for settling Mars is to keep a second seed for humanity if Earth is somehow destroyed. Elon isn’t going to Mars for its appeal as a habitat directly, but because it can serve as a backup for humanity. It also makes other exploration of the solar system more likely as the ships needed to support Mars can also bring humans to the Jovian system etc.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWhat do you think could possibly happen to the Earth that would make it as un-inhabitable as Mars? Even an asteroid strike in the middle of a nuclear war wouldn't come anywhere close.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoI’m not sure, but I don’t just mean physically destroyed but perhaps engaged in a new world war or ruled by autocrats. Either place could become that but if it happens to Earth it could set back human progress hundreds of years. It would be nice to have some more distant human thought, I think, with a broader view on existence than those of us here. I think there are benefits to an independent settlement beyond physical destruction. In any case I’m saying Musk isn’t going there because it’s full of resources as was suggested up thread. He’s going there for the long term benefits to humanity he believes it will achieve. If you want to get rich in space mine asteroids. Which will probably become more viable if Mars colony ships ever routinely travel between Earth and Mars.