3 ms·
That’s not really how patents are supposed to work. If you give someone enough constraints almost any patent will seem obvious. The point of patents is when a
by Retric 6y ago
That’s not really how patents are supposed to work. If you give someone enough constraints almost any patent will seem obvious. The point of patents is when an entire industry is solving a given problem doing X, and someone comes up with a better option then you want that industry to use the better method.
To get that swap you need public disclosure in some industries, and to get public disclosure you need incentives. For widely available products that disclosure may consist of the actual object without any patents. But, for say oil refineries people don’t just get to walk around and see what’s what.
Having said that the parent system could be changed in a vast number of ways with many tradeoffs. Just consider the wider implications beyond just software or mass produced items.
- newsclues 6y agoNon obvious test? If the patent was never invented and filed, would a child be able to come up with and communicate the idea patented? If one click to buy didn’t exist today, how many children would be able to simply state the obvious solution of one click purchasing?
- TheDong 6y agoThe actual non-obvious test is not a child, but "a person skilled in the art" (of software in this case). You also are talking about the idea, not the invention. The idea was not patented, the technical invention (effectively flow-charts for how to have a button click trigger an auth cookie check, have databases retrieve credit card numbers, etc), which is not obvious to a child. But, I would argue, the details of the invention would be clear enough to someone skilled in the art, another competent programmer.
- jkrems 6y ago> If give someone enough constraints almost any patent will seem obvious. That seems like a strawperson. The parent said that just given the very rough idea or (I would add) even just the term "1 click buy", somebody could have created a comparable experience without any reference to the patent. That's not "give someone enough constraints". That's "let somebody overhear a customer mention the feature in passing". Suggesting that Amazon wouldn't have invented 1-click buy without patents seems incompatible with good business practices. All my conversations with other developers mentioned a single reason for patenting "random" features at this point: As a way to defend against other people's patents. The only reason _not_ to create a novel feature was that it may be too close to something patented and a lucky lawyer may have argued that it was too close. If anything, software patents actively discourage innovation. I've never heard of anybody implementing a feature by using a patent. I've never heard of somebody developing a novel feature to get a patent. Which means as "patents", they are useless.
- Retric 6y agoThe actual patent isn’t the same as disclosure. Take RSA encryption for example. People don’t implement it from the patent, but independent invention was extremely rare. People’s implementations generally trace the idea back to Ron Rivest, Adi Shamir, and Leonard Adleman, who publicly described the algorithm in 1977. Yet, overhear the idea in passing and it’s implementation is obvious. Actual secure crypto is much harder than a simple implementation though. RSA is interesting because an equivalent algorithm was independently discovered in 1973 at GCHQ the British signals intelligence agency, and only declassified in 1997. So in effect it’s disclosure not invention that shaped public crypto. I am not saying patents are a great fit for software, but I am saying disclosure in one form or another is.
- MikeUt 6y ago> If give someone enough constraints almost any patent will seem obvious. In the one-click case, it's like getting a patent on the idea of conversion of heat to mechanical motion, then demanding payment from James Watt for his steam engine.