3 ms·
Why would it matter to improve the valve design, if it's being covered? The best valves filtered particles very well without any mitigation. If there was a sta
by maxerickson 6y ago
Why would it matter to improve the valve design, if it's being covered?
The best valves filtered particles very well without any mitigation. If there was a standard there might not be anything to talk about (they could all be better than other masks).
I think the statement about improving them is sort of misplaced in the flow (it's related to the containing paragraph and previous 2 paragraphs).
- ricardobeat 6y ago> The best valves filtered particles very well without any mitigation That's not supported by the study: 17% max penetration for surgical masks vs 55% for valved masks without any 'mitigation'. They only perform similarly for inwards flow, which is expected when both have an N95 rating.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe first paragraph of the conclusions: Based on a sample size of 13 models, this study found that unmitigated FFRs with an exhalation valve that were tested in an outward position(with particles traveling in the direction of exhalation) have a wide range of penetration, emitting between <1% and 55%. Further testing could measure greater particle penetration. See where it says "between <1%"? And Figure 5 shows the variation between the models.
- ricardobeat 6y agoThe range doesn't tell the true story. In Figure 5, the majority of models are worse than surgical masks, above 20%, vs "Particle penetration through the surgical mask ranged from 2% to 17%". Only 3/13 performed better, and 1% is just the lower quantile for a single one of them.
- maxerickson 6y agoRight, and the ones that perform the best? Presumably if the goal was to standardize on good valve performance, the performance would align with the best models rather than the majority.
- incrudible 6y agoYou are still conflating the mask cloth with the cloth mask. It is not plausible that a loosely worn cloth mask performs nearly as well as the cloth itself.