5 ms·
This is a mid-length essay revolving around the works, mind and books of Ursula K. LeGuin. If you are interested in Fantasy as a genre, that writer in particul
by mistrial9 6y ago
This is a mid-length essay revolving around the works, mind and books of Ursula K. LeGuin. If you are interested in Fantasy as a genre, that writer in particular, and "sexual politics and identity" this essay is for you. I wonder why it is on HNews, but heck, here it is. I clicked because I am an amateur Jung scholar, too.
I read Left Hand in Darkness and most of those Earthsea books as a schoolkid when they were new. I like Dungeons and Dragons. I am wide-eyed and run away from the seemingly endless amount of personal effort people put into 'alternate sexual identities' .. similar to a cancer, to me.. an endless and unsolveable and ultimately unresolvable morass, foisted into almost every Wikipedia article and FOSS post these days. Why cant we keep Pandora's Box closed? an intelligent reader might ask.
If this is an interesting essay, then there is one more interesting essay in this world. Super. Why does this website track my mouse movements while I read then? To present an ad at just the right moment, apparently.
As many commentors here have pointed out, 'rage inducing headlines' get more quick views. Similarly to my mind, 'alternate sexual identity' as fundementally unsolveable also would get endless views on the web. I dont care to participate. Choose for yourself.
- jessaustin 6y agoWhy does this website track my mouse movements while I read then? To present an ad at just the right moment, apparently. Please improve your life: https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/ https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/
- klyrs 6y agoAh, yes. LGBT folks as a cancer. Why do we keep talking about them? Wasn't it more convenient when men were men, women weren't people, and any proof to the contrary was dead or in prison? Keep Pandora's box closed, by all means! New rule, you get to pick my gender and sexuality, provided you'll accept my choices for you. If by "intelligent" you mean people who are closed-minded and can't accept that their understanding of the world is incomplete, then yes, an intelligent reader might ask that.
- icefrakker 6y agoI wish people like you wouldn't try and shame shut up people you disagree with particularly when you don't seem to understand what the person you're disagreeing with is actually saying.
- bloqs 6y agoHis words were not adequately sensitive but he is not suggesting that. He is suggesting that the process of adding more complex alternatives to the already saturated pronouns area is like a cancerous growth that never stops.
- klyrs 6y agoWho said "pronouns"? You did. You're missing the key part of calling something cancer: it's a value judgement. That this is harmful. What harms are pronouns causing? Are they enough to kill the host language? Also, nothing in their text indicated the author's pronoun preference. Why do you presume "his" is the correct answer?
- caconym_ 6y agoIt’s entirely your choice whether to recognize people’s right to define themselves how they want, or to wring your hands in “intelligent” consternation at something you don’t seem to have put much effort into understanding and likely doesn’t affect you in any significant way. No doubt it’s become an ideological battleground that regularly sees real ugliness from all sides, but, again, it’s your choice whether to let those people define the issues for you. All that aside, I think it’s a big mistake to equate Le Guin’s work (even Left Hand itself) with either a) brainless SFF lit with nothing more to say about being human than the average D&D campaign, or b) an expression of the modern left’s identity politics doctrine, or something like it. Maybe you should give her bibliography another look.
- wizzwizz4 6y ago> foisted into almost every Wikipedia article and FOSS post these days. I am sincerely sorry that I exist, and am involved in FOSS. I shall try my best never to do anything worthy of mention in a Wikipedia article – though no promises there; it's possible I might get involved in a scandal, or contribute to a project that gets popular faster than I can rebase my name out of the commit history.
- MikeUt 6y ago> I am sincerely sorry that I exist, So when someone touts how important their white race is to their identity, or how proud they are of it, and people object, that it's the wrong thing to focus on, you think they're objecting to the existence of white people?
- watwut 6y agoHave you read while comment your parent responds to? Cause that comments did not take issue with people being too proud of "alternative sexual identity". Instead, it calls them cancer and wish that "Pandora box" would be closed.
- MikeUt 6y ago> the seemingly endless amount of personal effort people put into 'alternate sexual identities' .. similar to a cancer It reads to me like the poster is calling the effort cancer, not the identities themselves. The HN guidelines ask us to take the most charitable interpretation. If it's unclear, the least we could do would be to ask for clarification, instead of using their poor wording as a means to score cheap rhetorical points.
- klyrs 6y ago"Wide eyed and run away"... "like a cancer, to me"... "keep pandora's box closed"... no. OC was very consistent throughout that paragraph. The intention was made very clear through repetition, and demanding a "charitable" interpretation of calling discussion of race, sex, and gender identities a "cancer" is disingenuous.