4 ms·
Matrix comes up a lot but even Signal is often called not polished enough. And for matrix onboarding is hard for techies and I've had zero chance for the genera
by godelski 6y ago
Matrix comes up a lot but even Signal is often called not polished enough. And for matrix onboarding is hard for techies and I've had zero chance for the general public. Fine to push it towards techies, but my grandma can't figure it out but she can Signal. Push matrix when it's more polished but right now it just feels silly to push it.
- lucb1e 6y agoUnfortunately very true, so although I'm not a big fan of Signal's centralization and USA-based metadata processing (I'm not from the USA), I'll probably end up moving my family from (now) Telegram to Signal. Alternatives would be Threema and Wire, but Wire has the same main issues as Signal and Threema doesn't have video calls nor a desktop client and an unusable web client (deal breaker for me: you need to navigate two menus on your phone to reconnect every time your phone connects to another wifi or you suspend your laptop or anything).
- godelski 6y ago> USA-based metadata processing Do you mean that they have servers in the US? US based company? They don't leak metadata, that's the difference between Signal and Telegram/WhatsApp. If the encryption is good it shouldn't matter what country the company or servers is in. That's kinda the point of encryption...
- lucb1e 6y agoYou connect to AWS when you connect to Signal. That means the USA is the government with the most influence on Amazon to have taps placed or connection logs handed over. They can do sealed sender stuff all they like, but when 10.0.1.1 sends a 17-byte message and the server then sends a 17-byte message to 10.0.2.1, and a minute later 10.0.2.1 submits something to the server of 48 bytes and then 48 bytes are forwarded to 10.0.1.1... traffic analysis based on a tap of a Signal server isn't rocket science. Still, it's the best we've got for non-techies. Better than handing over more metadata to Facebook. Even if the jurisdiction is the same, the company (Signal Foundation) is better and is known to collect almost nothing historical by themselves. Other than, say, your real-life-identity-tied user ID of course. (In many countries, phone numbers are given out only after passport/ID verification.)
- godelski 6y ago> You connect to AWS when you connect to Signal. That means the USA is the government with the most influence on Amazon to have taps placed or connection logs handed over. I'm not an networking guy but can you explain this more? I'm actually curious and what better place to get actual info than HN? If you have a sealed sender then shouldn't this be impossible? Shouldn't the size of the message be sealed as well and when the message is received you'd see that 1) it is signed by a different key and 2) the message size doesn't match? Shouldn't this be rejected? 3) Shouldn't this also apply to any app because traffic is going to bounce through some US based (or US company owned) server? My understanding is that sending data from San Francisco to Berkeley can route through Seattle or Tokyo depending on optimal routing, server configurations, and loads. > Other than, say, your real-life-identity-tied user ID of course. This is why I'm excited for the usernames. They are promising them this year.
- lucb1e 6y agoAgreed about being optimistic about usernames. I'm hoping it'll be what we expect, I hear different things from different people but frankly I also have been too lazy to actually look into it (I feel like I'm always the one doing the digging). > Shouldn't the size of the message be sealed as well To hide the volume of data being sent, you need to limit how much data you can send. How would you hide from the relaying server how much data you're sending without adding dummy data? And if you add 0-500 bytes of dummy data every 5 minutes, then whenever you send >500 bytes or send a message more often than once per 5 minutes, the server still knows that it was an actual message and its size, and you can start to do traffic analysis. > Shouldn't this also apply to any app because traffic is going to bounce through some US based (or US company owned) server? Um, when I message my friend whose Matrix homeserver I'm using, the traffic involved is: 1. DNS lookup of a .de domain (does not reveal message size or anything else, even if I were to use Google DNS and reveal my home server to a USA company) 2. TCP connection to a German server 3. More traffic to his German server And same on the receiving side. Unless one of us travels to the Americas, it's not likely to ever pass through the USA. That isn't to say that American agencies might not collaborate with European agencies or even tap European land-based connections, but it's harder and would not be an option available to criminal (or civil, for that matter) investigations due to the disproportionality of the method. > can you explain this more? I'm not quite sure what's unclear about it, but I'll give it another general shot. Imagine you see this traffic log, where A/B/C/D are different IP addresses. You see various people sending data of various sizes (you don't know who's who, but everyone connects from their own IP address, or in networking terms, a TCP tuple). Since the server is just pushing messages from one contact to another, like if Alice messages Bob, it will always forward a message as soon as possible. 00:00 A -> server: [17 encrypted bytes] 00:00 C -> server: [29 encrypted bytes] 00:00 server -> D: [17 encrypted bytes] 00:00 server -> B: [29 encrypted bytes] 00:01 D -> server: [48 encrypted bytes] 00:01 server -> A: [48 encrypted bytes] From this, I would assume (without knowing any contents or anything else) that the subscriber behind IP address "A" is talking to the subscriber behind IP address "D", and that "C" is talking to "B". Now you can start building a social graph, which according to a paper I recently read (I could maybe dig it up again) needs only a few nodes before they can tell who you are, or they just ask the ISP (or in the case of the Netherlands, query the CIOT database[1]). If you think that a "sealed sender" might hide your IP address, the answer is no because the packets somehow need to make it across the network to the right devices (or to the server for that matter) and then the receiver decrypts it. [1] https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIOT https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIOT only available in Dutch. TL;DR central mapping system of IP addr -> subscriber info, available at the police's discretion, updated daily.
- shafyy 6y agoExactly. I'm for decentralization, but the reality is that if "we" (we techies) tried to push Element on everyone today they would just fall back to WhatsApp. So better to go for Signal today and then switch everyone over to a Matrix (or similar) client in a couple of years. As the past week demonstrated, it's possible to switch masses out of a closed, network-effect-dominated system.
- lucb1e 6y agoI wish the person that downvoted you would give an explanation. I'd love to know how to avoid the middle step of switching family to Signal before, once it's more usable, switching to Element. (Or perhaps they meant that decentralization isn't better and Signal is the final destination. Guess we'll never know.)
- ahmedalsudani 6y agolol don’t dwell on the downvotes. We crucified Jesus some time ago for delivering a message. Downvotes for no reason are to be expected.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Avi0n 6y agoElement clients are very close to finishing their SSO implementations which will help immensely with the on boarding process. Here’s the iOS pull request for example: https://github.com/vector-im/element-ios/pull/3890 https://github.com/vector-im/element-ios/pull/3890
- godelski 6y agoOne thing that would really help is basically making the server installs a few clicks. Granted it has been about 6 months since I tried but I remember the instructions not being great and I know that'd be zero hope for less technical people.
- feanaro 6y agoYou don't have to host your own server to use it though. It's also not something recommended for an average user. However, if you want a server, installing it using Synapse's docker image is very easy. You literally have to run two commands.
- BeetleB 6y agoWould that not be even a better reason to donate to them...? (Not a Matrix user, BTW - looked into it some months ago and ran away)