11 ms·
There is a relatively new theory saying that malignant, metastatic cancer cells behave like single cell organisms, and that cancer basically represents an unwan
by inglor_cz 6y ago
There is a relatively new theory saying that malignant, metastatic cancer cells behave like single cell organisms, and that cancer basically represents an unwanted return to our genetic roots; multicellular organisms used to be single cell organisms a billion years ago and the original genes might carry on within our DNA until today. But they should be switched off. Once they are switched on, the cells will stop cooperating with the rest of the tissue and start acting "selfishly", at others' expense.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5474827/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5474827/
This is known as "atavistic theory of cancer" and it is rather controversial, there are people who utterly hate it, not least because the original authors are not specialists in cancer treatment.
Part of this theory is that cancer cells "cannot help but switch to the previous single-celled metabolism, very inefficient compared to ours".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 6y ago> There is a relatively new theory saying that malignant, metastatic cancer cells behave like single cell organisms, This is the track they are on, but given how shortlived they are, they never get the chance to do much evolution. They only have time to learn a few tricks. Simple things like turning stuff of or up/downregulating existing systems. It's a strange step to "cannot help but switch to the previous single-celled metabolism, very inefficient compared to ours". Theory in article seems much more likely.
- jetrink 6y ago> given how shortlived they are, they never get the chance to do much evolution There is a very rare category of cancers for which this is not true, clonally transmissible cancers[1]. They can move from individual to individual like other pathogens. One example is the devil facial tumor disease[2] that has killed around 95% of Tasmanian devils. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clonally_transmissible_cancer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clonally_transmissible_cancer 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devil_facial_tumour_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devil_facial_tumour_disease
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoIt also has no scientific grounding whatsoever: https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2020/12/06/the-atavism-theory-of-cancer-is-bunk-again/ https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2020/12/06/the-atavi...
- inglor_cz 6y agoWell, that is why I linked to NIH rather than one scientist's blog. Myers is very outspoken in his rejection of the idea, but even as an amateur I can see rhetoric sleights of hand in his argumentation. An example: These “layers” don’t exist! When my car malfunctions, I don’t get a horse Bad comparison, a car did not evolve from a horse, there is no mechanism for it to have a previous "horse layer". Myers seems to hate the idea so much and return to it so often and with so many damnations and so few citations that it actually decreases his credibility in my eyes.
- benibela 6y agoWhen the escalator malfunctions, you get a staircase
- sjg007 6y agoWell I wouldn't say the multicellular system is reverting to a single older cell phase per say. Rather it needs NAD+ so it optimizes for that. The cells also lose adhesion and then migrate so clearly there's some "programming exception" not being caught. I view the cell as a bunch of copy paste code that's had some degree of refactoring applied so there are different programs and control systems in operation at any given time. Sometimes these get activated or not repressed erroneously, sometimes the source code gets scrambled.
- hobofan 6y agoYeah, there isn't really any science to back it up. > and the original genes might carry on within our DNA until today Luckily we don't need to resort to "might". Since the advent of genome sequencing we can just go ahead and take a look! E.g. yeast (your standard single-celled organism) posesses ~6000 genes of which ~23% (= 1380 genes) are similar in function to those of humans. Of those genes most of them have been severely mutated, on average sharing 32% sequence similarity, which is a world of difference in terms of protein functionality. The few highly preserved genes that remain are core parts of all eucaryotic life (ribosomes, proteins for amino acid metabolism, etc.) and are some of the most studied genes (regarding cancer and in general). Suggesting that there are some genes hiding in there and have been overlooked due to narrow-mindedness of the whole life science community is a bit naive.
- wittyreference 6y ago> There is a relatively new theory saying that malignant, metastatic cancer cells behave like single cell organisms, and that cancer basically represents an unwanted return to our genetic roots It's not close to even 'relatively' being new. I was giving cancer talks that made mention of it back when I worked in cancer bio, just about 16 years ago now. I didn't come up with it, and it wasn't new then. I used it in talks to laymen, to give a very abstract idea of how cancer worked. But it fell into the category of "lies we tell children," because it was only true in the most abstract way, and utterly incorrect once you dug into any details. The reason cancer bio people dislike it is because it's only true at the 10,000-foot, highly abstracted level. When you start digging into the granular level, its testable predictions rank between 'falsified' and 'irrelevant'. It doesn't produce any alternative lines for thinking about treatment, causality, etc. Especially given that the progress of a single cancer tends to be all about their interaction with the multicellular milieu - e.g., developing immune evasion, which isn't at all an "atavistic" trait, although it's one of the core hextad that defines malignant development. (On the contrary, it comes built-in for normal cells - they're now developing a novel immune evasion, to hide their newly altered antigens from the immune system). e.g., "Cannot help but switch to previous single-celled metabolism" doesn't follow in any meaningful way from the thesis of atavistic traits. In fact, it doesn't predict at all the relationship between tumor size, distance from vascular supply, and anaerobic metabolism. "Cells without controlled growth will outgrow their vascular supply, requiring a transition to anerobic metabolism" does, however, and predicted the relationships we see. It's not "cannot help but engage with less efficient metabolism", it's "transition to relying on the only metabolism afforded to a highly-dysregulated cell that is not responsive to environmental signals that normally trigger or withhold growth." Normal unicellular organisms are responsive to those signals. Yeah, I don't hate it - it's a cute metaphor. It's a nice way of thinking of cancer at the 10K-foot level. It's just also wrong at any closer level of inspection than that, which is why people whose job is to be elbow-deep in all of the nitty-gritty details of cancer can't help but look at it and go "please stop wasting my time."
- excannuck 6y agoSince you were a cancer researcher in a previous life, may I ask you a question I thought of commenting on another's comment? If cancer cells have high metabolic requirements, couldn't you attack them by: 1. lowering the caloric intake of the patient 2. Making the glucose the patient intakes mildly radioactive, say with a beta or an alpha emitter [1]. As the patient is strictly kept on a low caloric diet, the radioactive glucose is consumed and expelled quickly (i.e. doesn't accumulate in the adipose (?) tissue). Not so radioactive that the person is harmed but radioactive enough to pack an extra punch to the metabolically starved, and therefore stressed, cancer cells (who are drawing more of the glucose to themselves). That should target cancer more specifically, and I guess it can be done in tandem with other techniques. Is something similar done? I know that's how cancer is imaged, and the way I see it (I studied optics in a previous life) if you can image it, you should be able to destroy it. [1] Say replacing the hydrogens in glucose with tritium. Hydrogen hopping will ensure that the water produced by metabolizing the sugar is homogeneously mixed, and therefore expelled with all the water loss mechanisms. According to wikipedia, TO2 has a half life of 12 days. I'd imagine you can lower that by pumping fluids into the patient.
- majkinetor 6y agoCancer tumors as Metazoa 1.0: tapping genes of ancient ancestors. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Cancer-tumors-as-Metazoa-1.0%3A-tapping-genes-of-Davies-Lineweaver/1103275da73ed9d72e82f80399b0095417d14492 https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Cancer-tumors-as-Metaz...
- tasty_freeze 6y agoI'm no biologist, but I'd be surprised if this is true. Genes which are essential the the function of an organism are well conserved relative to silenced genes over long time spans. This is because mutations happen randomly, and mutations to essential genes in the germline tend to get weeded out, while mutations to silenced genes can get corrupted without affecting the fitness of the offspring. This theory, from the way you've stated it, would require preservation of inactive genes for hundreds of millions of years, only to spring back to action in cancer cells.
- lisper 6y agoYou're assuming that the set of genes that produce multicellular life are largely disjoint from those that produce unicellular life, and that is unlikely to be the case. Much more likely, multicellular life is an incremental set of changes layered on top of unicellular life, and so the only thing required to revert from multicellular back to unicellular is a breakdown in that higher-layer functionality. If you're not already familiar with them, you might want to look up HeLa cells: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HeLa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HeLa
- tasty_freeze 6y ago> You're assuming that the set of genes that produce multicellular life are largely disjoint from those that produce unicellular life, I assume no such thing. I've read (but can't cite) that roughly 90% of our genes are related to construction and maintenance of the cell itself, and only about 10% are related to higher order organization. Just as it has been said that something like humans and tomatoes have 50% of our genomes in common, there is a significant but smaller percent that we have in common with single-celled life forms. > HeLa I read the book years ago.
- lisper 6y ago> I assume no such thing. You certainly do: "This theory, from the way you've stated it, would require preservation of inactive genes for hundreds of millions of years, only to spring back to action in cancer cells." This is only true if the genes for being single-celled are inactive in multi-celled creatures and would need to be re-actived to revert to being single-celled. But this is not the case. Milti-cellularity is a functional layer built on top of single-cellularity, so to revert to being single-celled you have to deactivate currently active genes, not activate inactive ones.
- jrockway 6y agoSo someone left in a bunch of legacy code and nobody knows which combination of feature flags fully turns it off? At least if we cure cancer we can use whatever we learned to make programming a little easier.