3 ms·
The AUS government passed a law aimed at a making a specific search engine pay other private entities for including links to them among its results. Seems nuts!
by onion2k 6y ago
The AUS government passed a law aimed at a making a specific search engine pay other private entities for including links to them among its results. Seems nuts!
I believe what the law actually says is that Google should to pay news providers when it displays content from their websites in search listings - eg when you search for a topic in the news and Google highlights some articles in the "Top Stories" section at the top of the results. The contention is that those links provide very little value to the news site and a heap of value to Google. If that is really the case then there's no reason why Google should get to access and display that data for free.
The point of search engines being able to index a site and display the link alongside adverts has always been that it's a mutually beneficial relationship - the site gets traffic, and Google gets sites to show ads next to. If people are no longer using Google to go to websites then that value proposition changes, and having your website in Google's index is no longer a benefit. If that's true then it's not unreasonable for site owners to suggest they should be paid for the 'raw materials' that Google makes money from. There is an argument that news sites could put up a robots.txt site to block Google, but that's a bit like saying burglary is OK if a house owner hasn't locked their doors...
- avsteele 6y agoThanks for the additional info. Can't agree with your analogy though, that just isn't how the web functions. Seems like a pretty clear business-to-business issue that should in no way involve the gov.
- PeterisP 6y agoIf the news sites honestly assert "that those links provide very little value to the news site and a heap of value to Google" then they can't really object if Google and Facebook stops providing these links. As they are objecting, then it seems that this assertion wasn't really true and that their bluff got called.
- stephen_g 6y agoExactly, and the fact that they hadn’t exercised their power by blocking Google with robots.txt to try and bring them to the table was a huge indicator that maybe they weren’t being honest. What they were saying was absolutely ludicrous. Somebody from News Ltd. said with a straight face that Google probably owes them $1bn a year - a full quarter of all Google’s Australian revenue across all their products! Either they’re crazy liars, or seriously extremely deluded as to how important their news results are to Google’s revenue...
- whatsmyusername 6y agoThey have the option to not be displayed in google search listings then. Google follows robots.txt.
- rognjen 6y ago> I believe what the law actually says is that Google should to pay news providers when it displays content from their websites in search listings As far as I remember the more ludicrous part is that the code mandates that Google must include news results. That means that Google must pay for all news links. It couldn't, for example, decide to partner with some news orgs and not others. It also couldn't just remove news altogether. The penalties proposed are also insane. Billions if I recall. Which then leaves them with either effectively being held hostage to pulling search entirely as described here.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoAfaik, they're allowed to omit news as long as they also omit all news. They cannot simply omit Australian news and include international news. Therefore, the Australian google would not contain links to Washington Post or NYT. This is probably to the advantage of the existing large players, since a new smaller player would find it much harder to get traction. We all know the domain name to Mr Murdoch's news websites, but we do not necessarily know the domain name to new media news websites. And we probably won't head off to NYT expecting to get decent coverage of Australian news for natural reasons. The result is probably going to be a disaster, with fake news spreading as images on Facebook, which will be somewhat trusted since everyone knows you can't find the source in Google and you can't link to it on Facebook, so the fact that you can't confirm it doesn't mean you can call it refuted.