3 ms·
Do not take my words as an endorsement of the stupid and shortsightedly evil insurrection. I do not endorse it. But I cannot completely agree with the article a
by inglor_cz 6y ago
Do not take my words as an endorsement of the stupid and shortsightedly evil insurrection. I do not endorse it. But I cannot completely agree with the article and given that the comments on site are turned off (understandable), this might be the place to raise objections.
I think there is an obvious flaw in the comparison. The larger the entity you want to have under your control, the less likely is that you succeed just by occupying one concrete location. An ancient city-state was tiny compared to even modern Greece, much less so than modern and fairly decentralized USA.
By storming an important government building, you can do some damage (esp. reputational one), kill certain people, but overthrow of a political system in a huge country is much harder to pull off. In modern history, such primitive actions usually fell flat on their face after mere hours. Which is precisely what happened here.
I would be more worried about a potential "rebellion in the provinces", which is basically what Francesco Franco did. That would have a potential to spin into a full fledged civil war or violent secession. This is something that was effective in certain cases.
- watwut 6y agoI think that this is the risk the article see for future: > we’ll see a shift to a campaign of domestic terror (something like The Troubles, in terms of the violence committed), or if, as with the Nazis after the failure of the Beer Hall Putsch, the folks who supported this insurrection will focus on trying to use the democratic process to abolish the democratic process.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>if, as with the Nazis after the failure of the Beer Hall Putsch, the folks who supported this insurrection will focus on trying to use the democratic process to abolish the democratic process. I think the Reichstag (sp?) fire is the better comparison there. The Nazis didn't really do much to get rid of democratic institutions and civil liberties until after they were in power (and the fire was their excuse to do so).
- watwut 6y agoWhy is Reichstag better comparison? It was not started by Nazi although they used the fire for their advantage. > The Nazis didn't really do much to get rid of democratic institutions and civil liberties until after they were in power. I think that is what "focus on trying to use the democratic process to abolish the democratic process" is meant to mean. Although Nazi did engage in quite a lot of elections related violence and suppression before they were in power. Intimidating or attacking people who came to vote, trying to discourage unfavorable demographic by harassment on streets near voting places, spreading rumors about marked ballots and subsequent retaliation of you vote wrong.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoI've seen the Reichstag fire consequences as being used by Trumpists as a comparison to what happened with Twitter/Parler...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> By storming an important government building, you can do some damage (esp. reputational one), kill certain people, but overthrow of a political system in a huge country is much harder to pull off. In modern history, such primitive actions usually fell flat on their face after mere hours. Which is precisely what happened here. I don't think that occupation as the route to success was ever intended. The intent was that a combination of intimidation a d violence by the mob would combine with the actions by ideologically allied legislators to result in a key governing action (the electoral vote count) being resolved in a way which would leave the figure promoted by the mob in power. The timing was critical. > I would be more worried about a potential "rebellion in the provinces", which is basically what Francesco Franco did. That would have a potential to spin into a full fledged civil war or violent secession. This is something that was effective in certain cases. That's pretty much what the propaganda framework has been being laid for with the narrative about Trump voters being “silenced” by adherence to legal process, and the combat-orriented narrative (whether deliberately or incidental to efforts to build support for sharp events like the 1/6 insurrection and the violent actions planned for next week.) If it's deliberate, that bodes ill, but even if it's not short of a direct and strong repudiation by sufficient figures influential to the factions that have been radicalized, there's still an enormous danger of it spinning out of control. While I think the insurrection-focussed impeachment trial is an opportunity for that, I'm not convinced that even of Republicans in the Senate seize that opportunity that are collectively influential enough with the radicalized for that to significantly mitigate the radicalization rather than being widely seen as a stab in the back.
- getlawgdon 6y agoI think you're missing the points: 1 modern velocity of (dis)information scales faster than geography and has more than made up the difference and 2 that coups are the result of a sequence of coups attempts.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoYeah, after all nation-states only started to show up after the invention of printing, so the current USA is already the size it is because it can be controlled with modern means of information and warfare.