3 ms·
It is an interesting perspective. I disagree with Dr. Devereaux in his take, but agree with his proscriptions. His analogy has strengths and weaknesses. Dealin
by roenxi 6y ago
It is an interesting perspective. I disagree with Dr. Devereaux in his take, but agree with his proscriptions.
His analogy has strengths and weaknesses. Dealing with the main weaknesses: ancient Athens is not modern America. In a Greek city state, most of everyone would have in the city so having the power to size the public spaces while your opposition was in them would have been equivalent to breaking their military - citizens and military were largely equivalent. A modern insurrection and and ancient insurrection play out very differently.
Dealing with the main strength - yeah, the animating spirit of the mob and the ancient insurrections would have been somewhere between similar and identical. A large mob of people will sometimes attempt to do something and will try to make it happen until they meet resistance or go to bed. That is a general risk that large groups of people transition to mobs, and that is why modern states, by and large, need some sort of military and policing power.
But the issue here is that the punitive measures are being escalated to right-wing political leadership without any sense of perspective to (1) a rather extended series of "peaceful" left-wing protest in 2020 that went violent in 5-10% of cases with enormous community costs and (2) Republican leadership, including Trump, are fighting ... using the court, which is a perfectly acceptable avenue and the three tries of "Peisistratos" is now called "having an election every couple of years" - also an accepted avenue. There is manifest evidence that most of the mob did not intended to be violent the morning of - violent protestors would come prepared with guns. It escalated on the day as protests are known to do sometimes. The police were underprepared.
It isn't acceptable, a lot of people need to be arrested, changes are needed to police tactics if nothing else. But the retaliation including an internet purge of right-wing aligned personalities and businesses (and impeaching Trump without taking the time to draw breath) is much more damaging than the ghostly ember of a mob. The knee-jerk overreaction is a low-thought decision making response that has far more in common with mob mentality than the thoughtful approach to governance and discourse which work in the long-term. The hazard posed by this mob - as in, the part inherent to it without considering the government response - was arguably not worst the States has seen in this decade. Even if it got further into the Capitol than most.
- watwut 6y ago> There is manifest evidence that most of the mob did not intended to be violent the morning of - violent protestors would come prepared with guns. And part of did intended exactly that. They had zip ties ready, there were pipe bombs in RNC the same day. Video of meeting where they talk about plans leaked. The messages they used for communication leaked debates about plans. Politicians complained about their panic buttons disappearing from offices that day.
- krapp 6y agoI don't know if it was planned, but it was brilliant PR. The "public" face of the riots are some bumbling clowns putting their feet up on Pelosi's desk and taking selfies for social media that the movement can point to the claim the entire thing was just harmless shenanigans if the serious stuff happening elsewhere doesn't go off as planned. And then there's the question of complicity by Capitol police, by other Republican staff, stories going back since last year of Trump placing loyalist extremists in certain positions of power. All these signs something bigger was supposed to happen, but all Trump supporters have to do is point to that schmuck in a buffalo hat and say "come on, that was never serious."
- 082349872349872 6y agoI disagree that the hazard posed by this mob was not the worst the States has seen (even this century), as resorting to violence as a putative alternative to elections is not a good place for a nominal democracy.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoHe specifically mentions that Greeks are a better comparison than Romans because their citizens were less militarized.
- roenxi 6y agoIf you are referring to the paragraph with "fall of the Roman Republic was so heavily influenced by the involvement of the Roman Army" that isn't what he is saying. He is saying that Roman insurrections involved the military, so this riot isn't a close parallel to a Roman insurrection. US insurrections will involve the army too - that is what weakens the comparison with ancient Greece. The Romans (and US) have professional, geographically dispersed militaries and the Greeks by and large didn't. That completely changes the dynamic of how revolts happen.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoHe insists on the militarization of Romans in his other writings too, specifically the October one : > In no small part, that success seems to have been motivated by the avowed need of elite patricians for the support of the plebeian commons in order to campaign, since the plebeians made up most of the army [of the Roman Republic]. So, no the Roman Republic did not have a professional army. (Neither, AFAIK did the Roman Empire : they went from mandatory draft to mercenaries ?) But good point, and I don't know enough about the Greek republics, maybe they were pretty close to the Roman one for this question ?
- roenxi 6y agoPlebeian-equivalent people make up the bulk of the US army. I don't see a link between that quote and the question of professionalism.