4 ms·
>Great to hear a couple iterations ago they restored the keyboard. Magic Keyboard was only introduced in mid 2020. And they are still not as good as MBP 2015 i
by ksec 6y ago
>Great to hear a couple iterations ago they restored the keyboard.
Magic Keyboard was only introduced in mid 2020. And they are still not as good as MBP 2015 in terms of typing experience.
Magic Keyboard Key Travel - 1mm
MacBook 2015 Key Travel - 1.3mm
Key Spacing as well. They are tiny in Magic Keyboard Layout and it is harder to "sense" the keys apart.
>Took them 5 years to go back and restore the old school.
TrackPad, being too large in Post 2015 models causing much higher false positives ( touching the trackpad and moving the cursor )
On the Good side at least they are listening.
- simonmales 6y agoAh, I thought the whole bringing back of the Scissor mechanism had brought the glory back. Reminds me of a blog post (via HN of course) that discussed how Apple is hurting itself by being obsessed with making devices smaller (Ugh, can't find the link). A friend was grilling his boss who was fan boying over a particular iPhone release. Where the device was 10% thinner. In the real world it was a 1mm difference.
- yoz-y 6y ago1mm for a phone is quite a bit though. Pursuing thinness (and thus lightness) makes a lot of sense for a device you lug everywhere with you.
- toomanybeersies 6y agoExcept that they make them thin at the expense of sturdiness, so everybody needs to get a case for their iPhone to avoid breaking the thing if they drop it more than a couple of feet.
- yoz-y 6y agoHm, I was under the impression that the sturdiness was mostly tied to materials, mainly usage of glass instead of plastic. A lighter phone should at least in theory be less breakable. Bendiness is another thing though.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoI personally prefer the 2020 keyboard over my previous 2013 one. Just feels nicer to type on, for me personally. I really hated all of the butterfly keyboards.
- nhoughto 6y agoHad 2015, have 2020 (sold a 2019) thought you can’t beat a 2015 but I like the 2020 better actually! 2015 feels spongey in comparison.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoSpongey is a good description, that's my take as well.
- LarvaFX 6y agoI love the 2020 keyboard!
- ksec 6y ago> spongey That is exactly what I like about it. Typing Feedback!
- jacobolus 6y ago> key travel 2019 1mm vs. 2015 1.3mm The comparative overall height of the keyboard modules is more than 0.3mm different, and the new computers are dramatically thinner and lighter than the previous ones. The overall effect is a substantial improvement. I don't use the touchbar too much, but it is a moderate improvement over F keys for me (I appreciate the return of a physical escape key). Subjectively these two keyboards are pretty similar (I slightly prefer the previous ones). Scissor switches are all pretty mediocre; the shape to fit in a laptop just forces very sharp compromises on the design. I also think making the key tops larger was a mistake, but it is also a relatively marginal difference in practice. Part of the goal may have been to increase the space available for international legends. (That's why IBM and every other vendor increased desktop-keyboard keytop size and switched from a spherical to cylindrical shape in the 1980s.) In terms of typing experience alone, I like the Apple laptop keyboards from circa 2002 better than any of the laptop keyboards since. And the Mac Portable keyboard from 1989 is way better. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh_Portable https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh_Portable * * * Edit: in response to: > TrackPad, being too large in Post 2015 models causing much higher false positives Let me highly recommend getting a Japanese language keyboard, which looks like this: http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/da70b0140c8a29b34cad7c28ef8b3f95 http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/da70b0140c8a29... ... and then remapping the letter keys to be wider separated, along the lines of: http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/a578960e19e2c95654e4f79b9bbe6501 http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/a578960e19e2c9... Moving your left hand slightly left and your right hand substantially to the right relative to a typical US-ANSI keyboard will keep you from accidentally palm-swiping the trackpad.
- funcDropShadow 6y agoFor someone who has worked as a travelling consultant for almost ten years, I couldn't care less about thinness. Obviously I don't want to carry any bricks around. But the thickness of 2013 models was totally fine for me. It allows for even more battery packs and room for cooling, as well as an Ethernet port. Shocking. There used to be laptops that actually included Ethernet ports, without any Thunderbolt dongles, that become finicky if you plug and unplug them everyday. /sarcasm off
- turtlebits 6y agoBarring the reliability issues, the butterfly keyboard is my favorite, even over the 2015. That said, they are all good and don’t matter enough to sway what machine to buy.
- ksec 6y ago>the butterfly keyboard is my favorite, even over the 2015. That said, they are all good and don’t matter enough to sway what machine to buy. That is exactly the problem! There are people who love the butterfly, they seems to prefer the mushy key typing experience. That is fine, but those same people dont hate scissors either. But there are enough people hate the butterfly keyboard. To the point of hoarding 2015 MacBook Pro. You dont need any Internet forum to judge, we can judge the market by 2nd hand MacBook Pro pricing. There are demand for good quality 2015 MacBook Pro simply because of the keyboard. The same goes with Trackpad, some people love larger trackpad, but they wont go mad with a smaller one. And then there are people who have palms that couldn't even use the new MacBook Pro. Basically both of these are the wrong trade offs and compromise. And both of these design decisions were all post Steve Jobs' making.