3 ms·
Ouch, that’s one of those painfully bad ideas that makes it obvious most people lack a basic understanding of physics. Creating enough mass from energy to hit
by Retric 6y ago
Ouch, that’s one of those painfully bad ideas that makes it obvious most people lack a basic understanding of physics.
Creating enough mass from energy to hit ~2/3 earths total mass is several orders of magnitude larger than the Death Stars main weapon. And as you point out if basically anything fails all that energy gets released on Mars.
- elihu 6y agoIt's a minor detail of the setting of a story. I doesn't matter if it's practical in real life, it just has to be not be in contradiction with the fictional world of the story. Kind of like Star Trek allowing faster-than-light travel due to imagined discoveries in the fields of physics. I like hard science fiction that's based in known physics, but I can still enjoy science fiction that's not totally realistic as long as it's at least consistent with itself and doesn't contradict known physics out of pure laziness or ignorance. I think it's a better solution than just saying "Mars is at full gravity because of magic we won't explain."
- Retric 6y agoThe advantage of saying magic we can’t explain is you have fewer uses of other magic we can’t explain. Having that much mass moving near light speed requires absurdly strong materials etc. You need a silly energy source, etc etc. Similarly, you get a lot of knock on effects from the other hand waves.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoit's ok, the engineers learned enough from the previous 3 failures to make sure it really doesn't happen again with this one :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- croon 6y ago> Ouch, that’s one of those painfully bad ideas that makes it obvious most people lack a basic understanding of physics. I disagree. That's the fun thing about scifi. As long as your idea could theoretically work (which you seem to agree), you can decide whether the theoretical risks manifest or not, or handwave uninvented solutions to those. Scifi is about dreaming within our universe beyond our current knowledge or limitations. At least that's my two cents. Edit: Not familiar with this specific book, but just in general terms.
- Retric 6y ago> Which you seem to agree Well no their are a host of issues beyond safety and energy requirements. You’re not going to be able to contain that much virtual mass moving at near light speed. We also don’t know if virtual mass produces gravity, etc etc.
- ars 6y ago> We also don’t know if virtual mass produces gravity Yes we do. It does. Gravity is produced by energy, of which mass is only one type.
- Retric 6y agoLast I checked there was zero experimental support for this. Unless you have a citation?
- ars 6y agoSee my other post here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25793668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25793668 Basically any other answer would be a violation of a whole bunch of conservation laws. In short: It's easy to convert velocity energy to rest energy, rest energy obviously has gravity, so velocity energy must as well.
- Retric 6y agoThe issue as I understand it is neutron stars would form black holes in some reference frames. It really breaks relativity for all forms of energy to produce gravity. Which is completely ok as long as there is some experimental support.
- ars 6y agoThat's a flaw of the theories of black holes, not relativity. > It really breaks relativity for all forms of energy to produce gravity. It does not, quite the opposite: It's a fundamental feature of it. > Which is completely ok as long as there is some experimental support. There is no experimental support for black holes either, it breaks physics far less for black holes not to exist. (Note black holes are not the same as super massive objects, which do have experimental support. An event horizon has never been observed, just assumed.)