4 ms·
You should have noticed by now that there is widespread, emphatic agreement that Facebook should protect users' data from third parties. This is why what Cambr
by skybrian 6y ago
You should have noticed by now that there is widespread, emphatic agreement that Facebook should protect users' data from third parties.
This is why what Cambridge Analytics did was bad, right?
- CivBase 6y agoI don't understand this, though. It seems to be driven by a misunderstanding of how the data is being collected in the first place. It isn't some security vulnerability with Facebook. And Facebook isn't distributing the data to a third party. It's just sharing the data with users, who are then passing it off to the third party (intentionally or otherwise). It's like expecting keyboard manufacturers to sue developers of keylogging software.
- wp381640 6y agoExactly. A lot of people think this is hypocrisy but this is exactly what you want Facebook doing. It seems like a week doesn't pass that there isn't news of yet another scraping/dark-adtech firm exposing hundreds of millions of these types of records[0] If you think Facebook are bad, these companies are an order of magnitude more evil, and you're never going to hold any of them accountable because they don't care for regulations. edit: The threat model here is really concerning. To build user databases legitimately takes a lot of effort and funding. To do it via extensions and scraping requires finding browser extensions that have a lot of users and loose permissions (usually https://*/\ https://*/\*) and acquiring them for cheap, pushing an update and then just watching the data roll in. The only recourse is further lockdown of browser extension capabilities (which also punishes good apps like uBlock Origin), purging extension stores (which also usually traps innocent players) and/or taking legal action as Facebook are doing [0] https://www.safetydetectives.com/blog/socialarks-leak-report/ https://www.safetydetectives.com/blog/socialarks-leak-report...
- 4638383474 6y agoI think you're overthinking the point. If someone's position is that company or industry x is inherently bad then they're going to see any protective behaviors by those companies as also bad because all those protections are doing is prolonging the existence of the root problem.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]