8 ms·
Native Americans say U.S. does not own land it is about to give to Rio Tinto
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoI wish I could find the court case, but the gist of it was that there was an enormous amount of "public land" in Oklahoma (I think) that a court ruled was actually owned by a Native American tribe and the deed/land was given to them. Access to the public was immediately revoked and multiple casinos were built on the part of the land near a lake and closest to the highway that ran through the land. Is this a similar case? Also if anyone has a recollection of what I'm referring to, that would be awesome. My search skills are failing me.
- dbg31415 6y agoSupreme Court Rules That About Half Of Oklahoma Is Native American Land : NPR || https://www.npr.org/2020/07/09/889562040/supreme-court-rules-that-about-half-of-oklahoma-is-indian-land https://www.npr.org/2020/07/09/889562040/supreme-court-rules... Supreme Court recognizes Native sovereignty in much of Oklahoma || https://www.pri.org/stories/2020-10-12/supreme-court-recognizes-native-sovereignty-much-oklahoma https://www.pri.org/stories/2020-10-12/supreme-court-recogni...
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoThanks! Yeah this is it. I'm still trying to find the other details about the case
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lozaning 6y agoMcGIRT v. OKLAHOMA maybe? https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-9526_9okb.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-9526_9okb.pdf Half of oklahoma was ruled to be on a reservation somewhat recently. Never heard any casino new related to this ruling though.
- beerandt 6y agoAlso, the court was pretty clear about not making any drastic interpretation of their ruling, beyond the criminal jurisdiction matter that was at hand. However, the fact that the court validated the continued legality of the treaty at all was a pretty big deal.
- teawrecks 6y agoIf you google "court declares oklahoma belongs to native americans" you'll get dozens of articles about it from 6mo ago.
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoThanks yeah, that's definitely the case. I'm trying to find the other details regarding the issue of revoking the public access and developing areas around some public-access lake that was on the land.
- resoluteteeth 6y agoI don't think McGirt v. Oklahoma actually gave ownership of the land to Native Americans. It might seem that being on reservation land would mean that but apparently it doesn't.
- User23 6y agoI wonder if anyone has tried not paying their US jurisdiction property taxes that lives on supposedly Indian land now.
- TeaDrunk 6y agoUsually what ends up happening is that various treaties will be set up such that the Oklahoma state government and the relevant indigenous nation would collaborate on the governance of the area.
- bluGill 6y agofor the most part states and the reservations within them are on good enough terms these days for such a thing to happen. It benefits both sides to take care of these issues. Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of "misunderstandings". However it isn't like 150 years ago when states believed "the only good Indian is a dead Indian."
- 6y ago
- magicalist 6y ago> Access to the public was immediately revoked and multiple casinos were built on the part of the land near a lake and closest to the highway that ran through the land. Now that you've been pointed to the story and found this is not at all what happened, it would be nice if you could edit your post to say so (or at least post a follow up saying the same if it's too late to edit).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- KingMachiavelli 6y ago> Tribal members have also filed a lawsuit seeking to block the study’s publication. Hmm, that's kind of a weird step in the process to block via a lawsuit. The environmental study really doesn't have anything to do with who owns the land. If anything, I would think it would be of the Apache's benefit to have the study published. If the environment effects of a copper mine are damning which is a likely case, then the mine might face significant hurdles anyway.
- leetcrew 6y agoapparently the land can't change hands until the study is published. it's just a delaying tactic while they seek a favorable judgement.
- beauzero 6y agoThis is how pretty much all of this stuff goes for natural resource extraction in western US. Same thing happens for timber extraction/runoff/roads, etc. out west. If you want to stop it you throw speed bumps in its way and hope that administrations change. It is very likely that under Biden the EPA/Forest Service/BLM/BIA may have different priorities.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoAlso infrastructure projects. Environmental lawsuits are used to drive up the time and monetary costs until it no longer becomes viable.
- smt88 6y agoDo you expect that the behavior of the Forest Service, BLM, and BIA will be drastically different under Biden? Are those orgs that under the sway of political appointees rather than career civil servants? My limited experience with Forest Service is that they were much the same org under Trump, but could not always say so publicly. Maybe that's wrong though.
- beerandt 6y ago
- sesuximo 6y agoCouldn’t the govt just use eminent domain?
- wavefunction 6y agoOn what is a National Forest but apparently legally Apache land? That's a fair number of hoops to jump through and personally not something I think the US Government should be undertaking for a foreign extractive company like Rio Tinto with such a checkered record and horrendous reputation.
- 1over137 6y agoDoes it being a "foreign" company really matter at all?
- advisedwang 6y agoNative american claims on land are stronger than regular property rights. There are treaty provisions and sovereignty too. IANAL and perhaps it is possible to override these with eminent domain, but it's surely legally and politically harder to eminent domain this land than a private owner's.
- User23 6y agoIt depends. Homestead act properties have land patents, which are legally perpetual to the assignee and their heirs and subject to no superior landlord, which means immune to liens, property taxes, and basically everything else (not sure on eminent domain). In practice though the US federal government is just as happy to ignore its promises to Americans as it is those to the sovereign tribes.
- seniorsassycat 6y agoEminent domain would require payment for the land right? The optics would also be worse - tho not much worse than the articles current headlines.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- GauntletWizard 6y agoI believe the right approach is for the US to apply for squatter’s rights. The land was not otherwise in use, and the US has been occupying it for years.
- anonAndOn 6y agoIsn't that like trying to apply squatter's rights on a piece of Canada or Mexico? AFAIK, Apache land is sovereign and only managed (not owned) by the US.
- dragonwriter 6y agoIt is “owned” (in the sovereign, not title-holding, sense) by the US as well, which is a superior sovereign, but the Apache role in that land can only be diminished by Congress, not the executive.
- staplers 6y agoThe land was not otherwise in use If by "not otherwise in use" you mean not directly creating profit for US businesses then sure. A lot of things "use" the Earth that aren't human.
- denkmoon 6y agoRio Tinto have a poor track record for handling indigenous lands too. Just 6 months ago they demolished indigenous australian heritage sites, for apparently very little gain. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-05-26/rio-tinto-blast-destroys-area-with-ancient-aboriginal-heritage/12286652 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-05-26/rio-tinto-blast-destr...
- jakecopp 6y agoYep, they blew up the "only inland site in Australia showing human occupation continuing through the last Ice Age" [1]. "Even going through and doing excavations in those areas; to find the plaited hair and the artefacts and how they have been dated back to over 46,000 years — it's something we will always remember." [2] 40,000 years is a long long time, 40,000 years still on my mind. [3] [1]: https://theconversation.com/rio-tinto-just-blasted-away-an-ancient-aboriginal-site-heres-why-that-was-allowed-139466 https://theconversation.com/rio-tinto-just-blasted-away-an-a... [2]: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-05-26/rio-tinto-blast-destroys-area-with-ancient-aboriginal-heritage/12286652 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-05-26/rio-tinto-blast-destr... [3]: https://neighbourhoodpaper.com/culture/40000-years-is-long-long-time-restoring-redferns-famous-mural/ https://neighbourhoodpaper.com/culture/40000-years-is-long-l...
- roenxi 6y agotheconversation.com is speaking loosely - it is the only known inland site. That is different from being the only inland site. The Pilbara is very large and the Aboriginals have visited a lot of it over the last 46,000 years. It will be riddled with ancient sites, which nobody cares about. The only reason they even bothered to look was because it was in an ore-rich area.
- spodek 6y agoWhile Native American rights seem more than enough reason to deny the government granting the land, it is a travesty that it's our last line of defense against the inevitable destruction Rio Tinto would bring.
- AniseAbyss 6y ago
- random5634 6y agoThe US, through congressional action, can ultimately do what it wants including an eminent domain type taking. These used to be policy with the termination acts. That's stopped and now federally there is support of self governance, but that could of course change in the future.
- ashtonkem 6y agoCan it do that for tribal land though? Tribes are sometimes legally semi-sovereign, and congress’ power in them is complicated.
- random5634 6y agoSure - it can and has. https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/STATUTE-71/STATUTE-71-Pg283-2 https://www.govinfo.gov/app/details/STATUTE-71/STATUTE-71-Pg... is an example. Currently however congress has tried to improve / make up for prior poor treatment of native americans - but the power is ultimately in congresses hands (with some small limits). Trump was active in this more recently https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/mar/31/trump-administration-revokes-mashpee-wampanoag-tribe-reservation-status https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/mar/31/trump-admini...
- ashtonkem 6y agoWasn’t there just a SCOTUS case where they actually stopped the federal government from doing something because it would violate an old treaty? If so, it seems like the government’s ability to do whatever it wants in this area might get clipped.
- random5634 6y agoThe SCOTUS cases covered two situations - a guy convicted of murder and another (the one that was deceided) was related to child sex abuse. The decision was that congress had not disestablished the reservation as part of the Oklahoma Enabling Act of 1906, and so they could not be convicted in Oklahoma courts. This emphasizes, not diminishes, congresses role in deciding what reservations are established or not.
- zdragnar 6y agoI know it is the original title, but would it make sense to change it to "Apache" or "San Carlos Apache" instead of "Native Americans"? The term "Native American" is no more specific than "white europeans", given the diversity of tribes the term is supposed to encompass.
- kypro 6y agoSomething I guess I've never understood is why the US still value indigenous claims to pieces of land? I acknowledge that Europeans shouldn't have taken the land for themselves centuries ago, but why are there still people today who believe they have an ancestral right to a piece of land? Why can't these populations just integrate into the US instead of trying to preserve their cultures from migration? Why is this kind of ethnocentric thinking still acceptable in the 21st century America? The reason I ask is because I see a lot of European nationalists here in Europe asking for similar treatment to native peoples and it's hard to say their arguments are not genuine when you guys in America are tolerating nationalism from other non-European groups. What exactly do you say to a British nationalist who wants claim a piece of land in Britain to protect his "people" and culture from non-British arrivals like native Americans? Is this a backwards, racist concern, or a genuine one? I should note I am highly autistic. I'm not trying to be cruel here. I've just always found the concern for indigenous cultures and land highly contradictory and want to understand the US perspective better.
- erik_seaberg 6y agoIt’s because they negotiated a formal treaty (often to end a state of war) which was signed by the president and ratified by 2/3 of the senate. That is supposed to have the same force as any federal law, but over time these were neglected. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_treaties#U.S.%E2%80%93Native_American_treaties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_treaties...
- beerandt 6y ago1) One key fact often overlooked though, is that the tribal treaties (most, anyway) not only gave the US ultimate sovereignty, but also transferred ownership/title of the lands into federally administered trusts, held on behalf of the tribe's members. So anytime a tribe wants to do anything with tribal land, it's got to get signed off on by someone at the Dept of the Interior, or whoever is holding their trust. But not the Dept of State. Which I'm assuming is part of what's going on in the situation in TFA. Govt action requires Govt study. 2) The 2/3 vote is to ratify a treaty, but withdrawl is always easier; it's often accomplished unilaterally, and for the US, it's basically at the Presidents sole discretion, if not at his pleasure. Of course tribal treaties are different things than foreign ones- even if that wasn't the original intent. And politically, leaving any such treaty is an idea DOA.
- mrtweetyhack 6y agoTo the winner goes the spoils. All Native Americans need to do is fight and win.
- 8bitsrule 6y agotldr: "An 1852 treaty between U.S. officials and the tribe that is still in force set aside the land for the Apaches’ use." Answers that question. At least, for those with little idea of how seriously the US takes the treaties it scammed a hundred tribes with (or how it usually got their signatures).