4 ms·
You're probably thinking of the Mountain Pass, CA rare earths mine. Molycorp finally got the process clean enough that even the Sierra Club approved. Then China
by Animats 6y ago
You're probably thinking of the Mountain Pass, CA rare earths mine. Molycorp finally got the process clean enough that even the Sierra Club approved. Then China cut the price on rare earths and Molycorp went bankrupt. Then China raised the price on rare earths.
The Mountain Pass mine is operating again, but it's not clear who owns it now. Names involved are JHL Capital Group, QVT Financial, Shenghe Resources Holding Co. Ltd., and Fortress Value Acquisition Corp.
The output has to go to China for processing because the plan to build US extraction facilities at Mountain Pass has slipped from 2020 to 2022.
- southerntofu 6y ago> Molycorp finally got the process clean enough that even the Sierra Club approved. Being praised by a big NGO is in no way a marker of being "clean enough". Sierra Club (like Greenpeace) is well-known in ecologist circles to be eco-hostile and business-friendly.
- jjoonathan 6y agoI want to (and do) spend money to lessen our impact on the environment, and I want to do more, but I've met environmentalists who unironically wish that humanity would cease to exist. I am not interested in appeasing them. I am doubly uninterested in environmental policy that encourages bad options over much-better-but-still-imperfect options.
- caymanjim 6y agoAnti-nuclear environmentalists are directly responsible for our continued over-reliance on fossil fuels. Add anti-damming and anti-windfarm environmentalists into the mix, and the environmental movement is anything but.
- southerntofu 6y agoFossil fuel are terrible, but nuclear energy is arguably just as terrible. Also, nuclear energy (like most pretend-green energies) does not work without considerable amounts of fossil fuels, from extraction to actual energy production. If only that, building a nuclear facility is going to take a lot of fossil fuel to power the machines, and use a lot of concrete, which requires even more fossil fuel to produce and bring over. Water and wind turbines are a little different. Their ecological impact depends on their size. The problem here is most countries insist on urbanization which concentrates energy production and therefore tends to centralize energy production away from usage, in big power stations. Producing a little electricity with turbines has a quasi-null environmental impact, and is good for local usage for a small village. You'll find that people on the countryside are opposing industry's project not because they're new and ugly, but because they have actual concerns about the damage produced by such installations. How much resources does it take to build a wind turbine? How many tons of concrete does it take to anchor so many tons of steel? How does this considerable of concrete affect the local ecosystem? People are not entirely stupid. They protest the nuclear industry and windfarms because they've seen the damage, and they understand these proposals do not bring required change. We need momentum to reduce energy/resources usage, not to produce ever more energy. If you want to understand why many people from here (France) strongly oppose nuclear power, i recommend you do some reading on Areva's many failures (engineering-wise) and on Françafrique, the french neocolonial system which ensures uranium supplies.
- caymanjim 6y agoYou've demonstrated my point. You're pointing out some valid concerns. They're insignificant in comparison to the fossil fuel alternative. Environmentalists make perfect the enemy of good every time.
- southerntofu 6y ago> They're insignificant in comparison to the fossil fuel alternative. Weighing options is a good stance, but i'm pretty sure "insignificant" is not the word to describe problems caused by the nuclear industry. I don't want to sound judgy, but feel free to do some reading on the topic. Also, you seem to dismiss my central point that nuclear doesn't work without considerable amounts of fossil fuel. Even if that were the case, what is it powering? Almost all these electric devices use lithium which also takes a lot of fossil fuel to extract and refine. It would be interesting to read a full study on the requirements on fossil fuel to produce an electric car and feed it over its lifetime (accounting for the short life of electric batteries), depending on how energy is produced. I'm not entirely sure, but it may be just as bad as a combustion car. For hybrids, it's not even a debate as they get the environmental downsides of both worlds.
- hoseja 6y agoDams are pretty awful for the landscape.
- southerntofu 6y ago> environmentalists who unironically wish that humanity would cease to exist Sure these people exist, but they are a tiny minority. This is just a sick form of neo-malthusianism which fails to understand climate change as a symptom of industrial capitalism. Aiming to destroy humanity is the logical conclusion of analyzing our era as "anthropocene", not "capitalocene". > I want to (and do) spend money to lessen our impact on the environment Unfortunately, environmental damage cannot be fixed with money. We need to address the root problems causing the damage. Use less resources, build more durable items and reuse them as long as possible, and only employ somewhat-recyclable materials. Planned obsolescence is a crime against nature and humanity. Beyond every day items, urbanization a great factor of environmental damage. Concrete is a huge problem and so-called "developed" countries keep on using more every year, but for what benefit to humanity? There's already millions of empty housing units, we don't need more buildings: we need social change. > I am doubly uninterested in environmental policy that encourages bad options over much-better-but-still-imperfect options. Agreed, it's interesting to explore these imperfect options. But government policies around the globe concerning climate are not "imperfect options", they're actively contributing to the problem by refusing to stop infinite growth, and trying to reconcile greed and common good through green capitalism, the green new deal and what not. Looking at the whole lifecycle of a solar panel (with the current technology), how could someone call them green. Same goes for electric cars. If the industry used less materials, less-harmful materials, and recyclable materials, the situation would be less terrible than it is today. We are currently paying for them to poison us and destroy the land. In most countries rivers are now considered undrinkable according to safety standards. The system is broken.
- jiggawatts 6y ago> Then China cut the price on rare earths and Molycorp went bankrupt. Then China raised the price on rare earths. Speaking of which, China loves projection. They recently accused Australia of dumping products such as wine in order to bankrupt the local Chinese vineyards. As you can imagine, the many independent Australia wine exporters were rather perplexed by this, because they are not centrally state-controlled. In fact, such price-fixing collusion would be illegal here. Any time China accuses another country of some sort of misdeed, just assume they're thinking that everyone acts the same way they themselves do.
- philipkglass 6y agoAny time China accuses another country of some sort of misdeed, just assume they're thinking that everyone acts the same way they themselves do. You can fill in "pretty much any country" for "China" when it comes to trade disputes like this. The vast majority of between-nation dumping accusations seem to be unfounded or extremely thinly founded -- e.g. US accusing China of solar "dumping" when solar equipment manufacturers get state support by tax credits or low interest loans. US states pay to attract manufacturing too [1]. China can make t-shirts and tea cups cheaper than western producers. This has been known since before China joined the WTO. Objections to China also producing sophisticated goods cheaper seem to be mostly post-hoc regret. They weren't supposed to climb the value chain like that. Our countries were supposed to keep the sophisticated production while they just make trinkets! I actually think that it is a problem that the western world has lost so much domestic productive capacity, but countering that with hollow accusations of dumping is dishonest. Countries should formally alter trade obligations to reinvigorate domestic production instead of fabricating rationalizations to match the text of old treaties. [1] https://www.npr.org/2020/01/14/796344782/wisconsin-foxconn-and-the-lure-of-state-tax-incentives https://www.npr.org/2020/01/14/796344782/wisconsin-foxconn-a...