4 ms·
Agree. They’re not violating copyright via Twitter. They should have a voice via Twitter, no matter the accusation. Do accused murderers [as opposed to convi
by mc32 6y ago
Agree.
They’re not violating copyright via Twitter. They should have a voice via Twitter, no matter the accusation.
Do accused murderers [as opposed to convicted] get their Twitter suspended?
This is ridiculous.
- kennywinker 6y agoFor that matter, should convicted murderers get their accounts suspended? I think not solely on the grounds that they’ve committed murder - but maybe if they are using their platform to cause further harm.
- mc32 6y agoYeah I don’t know the ins and outs of that. I only made a difference because felons lose rights in the penitentiary, but then again most who can are able to commercialize their stories, though sometimes the state steps in and diverts proceeds to victims, etc.
- ardy42 6y ago> For that matter, should convicted murderers get their accounts suspended? I think not solely on the grounds that they’ve committed murder - but maybe if they are using their platform to cause further harm. On a related note, Facebook policy bans sex offenders from having accounts at all, regardless of what they do with them: https://www.facebook.com/help/210081519032737 https://www.facebook.com/help/210081519032737: > Convicted sex offenders aren't allowed to use Facebook. If you've seen an account that may belong to a convicted sex offender, please report it to us. Not sure about the other social media networks.
- kristofferR 6y agoThat's pretty messed up. You as a 14 year old send a nude picture to your 15 year old boyfriend and suddenly you're banned from Facebook from life? Frankly the whole situation in the US is messed up, punishment should be limited to whatever the court decides.
- skissane 6y agoEven more messed up is the fact that some jurisdictions will criminally prosecute 14 year olds for sending nude pictures of themselves. (I do think 14 year olds should be discouraged from taking and sending nude pictures of themselves – it is the sort of thing they could easily come to regret in a few more years – but I don't think criminal prosecution is an ethical way of providing that discouragement.)
- Fnoord 6y agoI don't know. Receiver could delete picture ASAP, and discourage behavior. If they keep, spread, or encourage they're complicit. Of course, there's a difference in severity between 1 nude of 1 person, or a myriad, or being an adult with a myriad. Sender getting prosecuted for spreading their own nude as minor might be weird, but also makes sense. Its not as if they'd be a registered sex offender as a minor. Put this way: what if it was an illegal firearm? We can't just turn a blind eye to youth breaking law, but we can't treat them like adults either. There's a solid middle ground: hold parents accountable till teenager, then both, and at age 16 the teenager but not with fully implemented adult law. Interestingly, that's approx how countries deal with it, or variants of that at least. TL;DR if properly nuanced, we can deal with issues like these, though we may disagree on these nuances, I'm quite sure we'll agree on the outliers.
- skissane 6y ago> Sender getting prosecuted for spreading their own nude as minor might be weird, but also makes sense. I think the Australian state of Victoria gets it more or less right – section 51M of the Crimes Act 1958 [0] makes it explicitly legal for children to produce, possess or distribute images of themselves. Adults (and in some cases other children) can still be prosecuted if they encourage/entice/assist/etc the child to do it, but the child themselves commits no crime. > Its not as if they'd be a registered sex offender as a minor. A number of American states do in fact put minors on the sex offender registry. For example, [1] describes how a woman was registered as a sex offender in Michigan after being convicted of "criminal sexual conduct" as a 10 year old > Put this way: what if it was an illegal firearm? A fifteen year old who takes a picture of themselves naked, the primary risk of harm is to themselves, and the harm they are risking is psychosocial rather than physical. By contrast, a fifteen year old with an illegal firearm easily poses a risk of death or serious physical injury, not just to themselves, but also to others. Hence, criminally prosecuting the later is far easier to morally justify than criminally prosecuting the former. The situations aren't really comparable. > We can't just turn a blind eye to youth breaking law Well, like Victoria has done, the law can be changed so that they aren't breaking it. [0] http://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/vic/consol_act/ca195882/s51m.html http://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/vic/consol_act/ca1958... [1] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/03/14/when-kids-are-accused-of-sex-crimes https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/03/14/when-kids-are-...
- sitzkrieg 6y agoat the end of the day twitter has the right to close whatever account they so choose
- mc32 6y agoLegally, yes. But given the prominence and importance it has with regards to disseminating news and opinion, I think it’s their responsibility to take their obligation seriously. The phones at one time we’re not “utilities”. Social media may become the next regulated utility given its importance.
- dragonwriter 6y agoPhones aren’t a utility merely because of their general importance, but because of the specific importance to the public interest of having a single, universal telephone network. I don’t think there is a great public interest in a single curated (algorithmically and/or manually) user-generated-content newsfeed system. In fact, insofar as such a category of product is desirable, I think that the public interest is in competition and freedom to differentiate, including in terms of content focus and preferences within the bounds of the law, just as is the case with, say, news outlets that aren’t driven by UGC.
- ballenf 6y agoYes, and people have to right to tell random strangers to fuck off and give kids the middle finger. Doesn't mean we can't try to talk someone out of doing that or discuss how such behavior makes society slightly worse.
- jjk166 6y agoThey also have the legal right to modify everyone's tweets to be quotes from mein kampf. That they have the right to do something doesn't mean they should do it nor that they should be immune to criticism for doing it.
- LevGoldstein 6y agoThat would be pretty easily proven as defamation/libel, and thus not legal.