4 ms·
Reuters says six sources inside Apple said it was the FBI. My sources inside Apple tell me that there was at least a partial implementation for doing e2e backu
by sneak 6y ago
Reuters says six sources inside Apple said it was the FBI.
My sources inside Apple tell me that there was at least a partial implementation for doing e2e backups safely, including a system for using friends/family to certify recovery in the event of password loss (presumably something like secret sharing).
The FBI and Apple actively collaborated to prevent this from coming to pass.
> One former FBI official who was not involved with these talks told Reuters that Apple was won over by the agency. “It’s because Apple was convinced,” said the source.
Your claim directly contradicts the article.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoSix sources confirmed the FBI contacted Apple, they can't fully prove that that contact caused the decision. I'd bet it at least played a role, but the article is not as clear cut as you make it out to be.
- t0mmyb0y 6y agoThis is correct. Apple works with FBI while publicly saying they don't.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> including a system for using friends/family to certify recovery in the event of password loss Having friends and family take ownership of partial secret keys is a non-starter. Few people would actually go to the lengths of distributing fractional secrets to their friends and family. Even fewer people would do a good job of not losing them over the years. Outside of techie circles, account recovery is a relatively frequent occurrence. The majority of general public customers would prefer being able to recover their account even if it means a vanishingly small chance that the FBI would be able to access it in the even of an investigation.
- admax88q 6y ago> Few people would actually go to the lengths of distributing fractional secrets to their friends and family. Even fewer people would do a good job of not losing them over the years. I feel like this is all a solvable UX problem. The secrets could be automatically distributed and stored on friends/family devices, could be integrated into iMessage directly. "Choose friends you trust to help you recover data." If N of your M designated friends and family still have access to their phone when you need to recover your backup then you can get access, maybe by presenting a QR code on each device you can scan, or a notification you can interact with after confirming identity via a phone call or something. The secrets wouldn't require any actions to keep intact, they could always be synced into iMessage and included in your own backups. Kind of like you're operating a RAID array across your friends and family, N+X redundancy, so long as no more than X of your group needs recovery at the same time you're good. Kind if an interesting approach actually, would be neat to build this into Matrix as an experiment.
- fomine3 6y agoThis approach is really exciting if Apple successfully implemented in Apple's way.
- Brian_K_White 6y agoThere was a recent HN about a better way to protect bitcoin wallets that was like this. I think the idea was, we already have multisig, where it takes M of N parties to perform a transaction. But that's no good for individuals everyday transactions. But why can't M of N just be used to perform one special kind of transaction, which is "reset my password"? And it doesn't have to actually be other people. If you don't have any friends you want to trust, the other M of N parts could all be other things of your own. Other devices, thumb drives, hardware keys, printed qr codes, memorized phrases, etc. Maybe some inconvenient to access but they exist if things get bad enough. It seems perfectly doable, and the only reason the Apples and Googles of the world aren't doing it, or at least working on it, is because they're choosing not to. Another comment actually said that Apple were working on this and eve had it largely worked out, and it was actively killed. There seems to be no fundamental technical or user problem making good user security impossible. Simply too many powerful entities for their different reasons don't want most people to have it.
- admax88q 6y agoAs usual on HN, Apple is always given the benefit of the doubt, where any article is interpreted in the strongest possible way in favour of Apple. Compare this to any article about Google, where anything they do is interpreted in the worst possible way for Google. AMP was my favourite example. You could interpret AMP as Google ensuring a better experience for users, or as Google highjacking the web into a closed ecosystem to squeeze out competitors. HN threads about AMP almost always concluded that it was a terrible overreach by Google, anti-competitive, and bad for everyone. But an article suggesting that Apple maybe put the FBI ahead of users in this instance? Dismissed because OP is "inclined to believe."
- random5634 6y agoAMP so obviously was better than ginormous ad filled sites that jank and jump like crazy it wasn't even funny. The idea that there was no user benefit was just a HN view - out in the real world plenty of people learned the lightening icon meant both faster and usually much cleaner and easier to browse. I think in part a fair number of HN folks maybe do web dev work, and having google restrict the junk they can dump on users was annoying to them. A fair bit of the anti-trust rhetoric is not coming from consumers or consumer advocates but other businesses - some of which have just horribly seedy business models (the recommendation engine searching sites with all the auto-generated fake reviews complaining of de-prioritizations etc).