4 ms·

Happy Elixir user here. At work we have a use case that isn't covered by José's high-level overview of the domains Elixir's used in: we run a massive multiplaye

by s3cur3 6y ago

Happy Elixir user here. At work we have a use case that isn't covered by José's high-level overview of the domains Elixir's used in: we run a massive multiplayer game server on it. This is actually a really good fit. (It kind of rhymes with the original use of Erlang, being telecoms infrastructure.) We get outstanding concurrency support, high reliability, and really efficient development times. I can't imagine shipping this feature with a server written in C++ (the language I'm most comfortable in), and I can't imagine scaling it the way we need to if we'd gone for a traditional web language like Node, PHP, etc. If you're interested, you can see the RakNet (game networking protocol) implementation we use on the server here: https://github.com/X-Plane/elixir-raknet https://github.com/X-Plane/elixir-raknet The README gives a good overview of the full MMO server's architecture, too: each client connection is a stateful Elixir process (not to be confused with a heavy-weight OS process!), acting asynchronously on a client state struct; clients then asynchronously schedule themselves to send updates back to the user.

AlchemistCamp 6y ago
I'd love to learn more about this! Have you been involved in the project from the start?
- s3cur3 6y ago
  Yep! I was actually the sole dev working on it, both server- and client-side. I'm working on a post for our public dev blog talking about why I chose Elixir and what my experience has been. It'll eventually be available here: https://developer.x-plane.com/blog/ https://developer.x-plane.com/blog/
stevbov 6y ago
Do you use it for server side game logic too? It's not as ambitious as an MMO, but I like to use MUDs to learn new languages. I've been (slowly) working on one to learn Elixir and I'm actually finding the concurrency model somewhat difficult to use for the MUD - especially the single world that every player connects to. I ended up writing my own kind of software transactional memory library to help me out: https://github.com/stevbov/stm_agent https://github.com/stevbov/stm_agent But altogether my design feels fairly un-Elixir-like. It seems like the language would shine more in a problem space with more process isolation. When it comes to the game world, pretty much any process could potentially depend upon any other process. Especially once you get into scripting NPCs.
- QuinnWilton 6y ago
  You'd likely be interested in the work done by Eric Oestrich in building MUDs with Elixir. Kalevala: a world building toolkit for text based games, written in Elixir [0] ExVenture: a text based MMO server written in Elixir [1] Grapevine: a MUD chat network [2] [0] https://github.com/oestrich/kalevala https://github.com/oestrich/kalevala [1] https://github.com/oestrich/ex_venture https://github.com/oestrich/ex_venture [2] https://github.com/oestrich/grapevine https://github.com/oestrich/grapevine
  - deleted 6y ago
    [deleted]
  - stevbov 6y ago
    I took a look at ExVenture when I first started working on this. A lot seems to have changed since then, but from what I could tell at the time there were some potential races. For example, movement processing seemed like it allowed for the possibility of players to seemingly move through doors that were closed (at least, from the players' point of view). I could easily have been wrong though since I'm new to Elixir. That said, a requirement for scripting I have is the ability to chain together arbitrary actions in an atomic fashion without any races or deadlocks. Content creators can create really complex scripts that involve arbitrary locations and actions. I wasn't sure how I would achieve this goal with ExVenture.
- iudqnolq 6y ago
  If concurrency doesn't help, you can always just not use it. You don't need to run logically separate modules in different processes. What if you put the entire state in a single GenServer? You can still delegate modifying different parts of the state to different modules, just call functions in those modules from a single server process.
  - deleted 6y ago
    [deleted]
  - stevbov 6y ago

by s3cur3 6y ago

AlchemistCamp 6y ago

I'd love to learn more about this! Have you been involved in the project from the start?

s3cur3 6y ago
Yep! I was actually the sole dev working on it, both server- and client-side. I'm working on a post for our public dev blog talking about why I chose Elixir and what my experience has been. It'll eventually be available here: https://developer.x-plane.com/blog/ https://developer.x-plane.com/blog/

stevbov 6y ago

Do you use it for server side game logic too? It's not as ambitious as an MMO, but I like to use MUDs to learn new languages. I've been (slowly) working on one to learn Elixir and I'm actually finding the concurrency model somewhat difficult to use for the MUD - especially the single world that every player connects to. I ended up writing my own kind of software transactional memory library to help me out: https://github.com/stevbov/stm_agent https://github.com/stevbov/stm_agent But altogether my design feels fairly un-Elixir-like. It seems like the language would shine more in a problem space with more process isolation. When it comes to the game world, pretty much any process could potentially depend upon any other process. Especially once you get into scripting NPCs.

QuinnWilton 6y ago
You'd likely be interested in the work done by Eric Oestrich in building MUDs with Elixir. Kalevala: a world building toolkit for text based games, written in Elixir [0] ExVenture: a text based MMO server written in Elixir [1] Grapevine: a MUD chat network [2] [0] https://github.com/oestrich/kalevala https://github.com/oestrich/kalevala [1] https://github.com/oestrich/ex_venture https://github.com/oestrich/ex_venture [2] https://github.com/oestrich/grapevine https://github.com/oestrich/grapevine
- deleted 6y ago
  [deleted]
- stevbov 6y ago
  I took a look at ExVenture when I first started working on this. A lot seems to have changed since then, but from what I could tell at the time there were some potential races. For example, movement processing seemed like it allowed for the possibility of players to seemingly move through doors that were closed (at least, from the players' point of view). I could easily have been wrong though since I'm new to Elixir. That said, a requirement for scripting I have is the ability to chain together arbitrary actions in an atomic fashion without any races or deadlocks. Content creators can create really complex scripts that involve arbitrary locations and actions. I wasn't sure how I would achieve this goal with ExVenture.
iudqnolq 6y ago
If concurrency doesn't help, you can always just not use it. You don't need to run logically separate modules in different processes. What if you put the entire state in a single GenServer? You can still delegate modifying different parts of the state to different modules, just call functions in those modules from a single server process.
- deleted 6y ago
  [deleted]
- stevbov 6y ago