8 ms·
Glossy vs matte screens: why the PC industry’s out of touch
- fourspace 16y agoIt seems to me that the reason for this shift is the same reason manufacturers ship their TVs set to overblown saturation and brightness: it looks good in the showroom. As someone who has no office and works every day either from home or from a coffee shop on a laptop, the glossy screen is pretty annoying. It's not impossible to work on it and you do get used to it, but my next MacBook Pro will be the matte finish. It's more annoying that a matte finish costs $50 more.
- mishmash 16y agoThe matte screen also comes with a grey bezel and not the sweet looking black one, FYI. Not a huge deal but it was a shock when I pulled it out of the box. edit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/inju/3184631310/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/inju/3184631310/
- drivebyacct2 16y agoI love it, the black/glass shows fingerprints like the devil. And it seems like it's of an impossibly small relevancy. I bought my MBP for the power, matte high-res screen and durability. The appearance of the bezel is probably the least important thing on the device.
- joejohnson 16y agoWhat year/model MacBook Pro is that?
- mishmash 16y agoMine is second to newest, officially the MacBook Pro (15-inch, Mid 2010) http://support.apple.com/kb/ht4132 http://support.apple.com/kb/ht4132
- antihero 16y agoIsn't it brilliant how the process of selling a product has such negative impacts on the product itself.
- mattgreenrocks 16y agoReminds me of the loudness wars...and then I become sad.
- mattberg 16y agoi think technically it is $150 more, since the only way to get the antiglare is with the hi-res option. definitely annoying.
- chromablue1978 16y agoAnnoying? Unsurprising is appropriate too. Remember the $100 'black' tax? "Same model, specs, just in black, for only $100 more!" Apple knows that their fans might moan a little, but in the end will hand over their credit card regardless.
- hexley 16y agoI don't remember that, and I owned a black MacBook.
- dotBen 16y agohi-res version is TOTALLY worth it, however. Best $150 I spent, seriously, was the matte+hires screen
- gst 16y agoI don't really care about the price, but the fact that you can't get the 13" version with the antiglare option. I have my laptop in the backback all the time and the 15" and 17" versions are just too large and too heavy.
- fourspace 16y agoIndeed. Even more annoying is that adding high-res, anti-glare makes it a custom order for the 15". Apple Stores only stock the overkill $2599 15" version with the high-res matte screen.
- elithrar 16y ago> Indeed. Even more annoying is that adding high-res, anti-glare makes it a custom order for the 15". Apple Stores only stock the overkill $2599 15" version with the high-res matte screen. Not true. Apple's retail stores often stock the high-end (high-res matte with the top-end i7) 15" model, so they can upsell. Not all stores will have it, and there's no guarantee (they typically only stock just a few at a time), but it's not online BTO only.
- KVFinn 16y agoAt least in the TV market, less glare is considered a feature. Modern plasmas are vastly better at toning down reflections that the old ones.
- johng 16y agoI hate glossy finishes :(
- kbatten 16y agoIt doesn't seem to be a PC problem, it seems to be a laptop problem. My lcds at home (and my TV) are all matte, its only my laptop (mac) that is glossy.
- uast23 16y agoIsn't laptop a PC? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_computer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_computer
- technomancy 16y agoBonus irony considering Apple basically mainstreamed the personal computer revolution. Now they're trying as hard as they can to distance themselves from the term.
- efsavage 16y agoMy last (windows) laptop purchase, in February 2011, was actually made easier by the fact that only two manufacturers (Dell and Lenovo) offered matte/anti-glare screens on high-end developer laptops. It was actually the default on the Lenovo W701DS I ended up buying.
- dimatura 16y agoYes, I had pretty much the same situation. I finally got a T510. Previously I had been using an antiglare filter, which works OK but is impossible to apply without leaving bubbles in.
- orangecat 16y agoSee also the almost complete takeover of 16:9 aspect ratios from 16:10 or 4:3, often with horrible 1366x768 resolution.
- pkamb 16y agoThis. It kills me that the new top-of-the-line Thinkpad ultraportables have the same vertical resolution as my x40 from 5+ years ago. Not much incentive to upgrade...
- jrockway 16y agoThis is because Lenovo has some obsession with buying the worst LCD panels available. Something about them not liking Korea or Japan suppliers, since the Chinese government is their largest shareholder. I ordered a T61 back in the day, expecting a 1920x1200 LCD as specified. After decades of delay, I got my laptop, and they substituted a shitty 1440x900 screen instead. Not as ordered. Thinkpads are still my favorite model of laptop for a variety of reasons, but their shitty fulfillment system and their shitty displays make a new Thinkpad purchase very unlikely. (In retrospect, they were just as bad when IBM owned them. Remember how the DVI ports couldn't do more than 1280x1024 because that is the maximum resolution that DVI is spec'd to handle. SIGH.)
- jamesbritt 16y agoI poked around and found a W500 thinkpad on the lenovo outlet site earlier this year. Too used to 16:10, 1920x1200 and do not to lug around a 17" laptop. Kills me that business tools are being spec'ed for entertainment consumption.
- hcurtiss 16y agoYes. Why will nobody listen to these complaints? Reiterating the point I made above, this is a big issue for me. Lawyers don't need horizontal resolution. They need vertical resolution. Hell, almost every lawyer in my office (a few hundred attorneys) has dual 4:3 screens ROTATED 90 DEGREES (3:4). 16:9 is going in exactly the wrong direction.
- scott_s 16y agoI don't think PC Pro readers count as an accurate sampling of people who buy PCs. And I must be in the minority that I like glossy screens. Colors are more vibrant, and it's not hard for me to avoid situations which cause glare.
- dotBen 16y agoVideo and computer games arguably look better on a glossy screen. A lot of people play games on their computers. Even in the mac world, I can see why Apple have gone glossy even though for the HN-type crowd matte makes more sense.
- chromic 16y agoI play FPSs very often, and a glossy screen really has no merits unless you are playing in the dark with no other light sources to reflect. I'd much prefer a matte display with good color reproduction.
- gst 16y agoThe only valid argument that I'd find for glossy screens is that you can build them more robust than matte screens. For example, it's much easier to clean the glass on the new Macbooks compared to a matte screen, which you wouldn't clean with a normal towel. Another example is Lenovo's new X1 laptop that uses Gorilla Glass which should be even much more robust than Apple's screens. Still, I prefer matte screens, as the reflections on glossy screens are too much of a distraction for me. Speaking of "out of touch" another issue with new screens is the format: On my old IBM/Lenovo X41 and X61s laptops the 4:3 screen format was perfect for the 12" screen. Although the screen was small I used the X41 as my main laptop for about half a year (without an external monitor). On my current X201 the 16:10 format is much worse: I'm a programmer, I don't need horizontal space, but vertical space. Even for non-programmers I guess that for reading web pages or other documents vertical space is also more important than horizontal space. With Lenovo's new X210 they've introduced a further step in the wrong direction by switching from 16:10 to 16:9.
- uast23 16y agoI did not understand seriously what kind of robustness you are talking about? Do glossy screens last longer than the matte ones? At least from the look of it, matte looks less fragile compared to glossy, although I am not sure if either of them is less fragile than other. Looking at matte is much easier to eyes. And as far as cleaning goes, cleaning the glossy one with towel will leave scratch everywhere! Isn't it?
- chromic 16y agoIt depends on the screen. A cheap glossy screen might scratch easy, but something like a macbook screen probably has a pretty good anti-scratch layer. Glossy screens tend to get dirty easier, but also clean a bit easier with readily available materials (e.g. paper towel + water).
- ugh 16y agoIt’s glass – not easy to scratch, at least compared to plastic. That’s at least true for all of Apple’s laptops except the Air.
- adestefan 16y agoAm I the only person here who doesn't care? I've used both a ThinkPad T61p (matte) and 15" MBP (glossy) regularly in the past 5 years. The only time I've had an issue with the glossy screen on my MBP is in full on sunshine. Even a matte screen would have been terribly washed out in that situation.
- Devilboy 16y agoIt's really not a big deal to most consumers. Most people don't even notice and will never use a laptop in direct sunlight.
- ChuckMcM 16y agoIt is sad they didn't ask the manufacturers why they do that. One reason is that 'glossy' screens have higher contrast than 'matte' screens because off-axis light is reflected mostly off screen, but on a matte finish off axis light adds a 'glow' to the screen (which is a diffuse reflection rather than a specular reflection) and that glow gets counted against the 'black level' and the contrast. Glossy screens in a darkened room perform demonstrably better in terms of contrast than matte screens. Matte films are easy to come by and I'm rather surprised that given this sort of market research there isn't someone out there selling them by the boat load.
- po 16y agoI've looked into getting one but all of the matte films I have seen have a 'shimmery' appearance to them. It looks like the surface grain of the film is not fine enough. Does anyone know of a good brand of film to use?
- ChuckMcM 16y agoI used some 3M anti-glare film which I believe was this: http://solutions.3m.com/wps/portal/3M/en_US/Vikuiti1/BrandProducts/main/marketsweserve/displayaftermarket/antireflectionfilms/ http://solutions.3m.com/wps/portal/3M/en_US/Vikuiti1/BrandPr... On a 44" LCD television. I got it through a window tinting contractor who had a relationship with 3M (they bought their window tinting film from them).
- aidenn0 16y agoTVs have much larger pixel sizes than laptops, so it may not work on a laptop.
- po 16y agoas aidenn0 mentions, I don't think a film that works well with a TV would necessarily work well with a laptop. The pixel sizes are different but also the viewing distance is much greater. This 3M product says: Anti-glare film, for example, incorporates a special roughened surface. When external light is reflected on this surface light is scattered across many different angles, giving the appearance of reduced reflection. Anti-reflection film takes a different approach and actually reduce the magnitude of the reflection by passing the light through specially engineered thin layers that reduce the amount of reflection, not just scatter it. I'm not sure that makes any sense but it sounds like it's the right direction. I assume they mean they reduce the reflected light by absorbing it? Anyway, thanks for the pointer.
- beatpanda 16y agoI don't know about y'all but I got the glossy screen on purpose, it's damn near impossible to use a laptop in sunlight with a matte screen.
- djcapelis 16y agoPCPro is out of touch that their readers are not the average computer buyer.
- jrockway 16y agoWho is a more important market? 5 people that buy a laptop every 5 years, or 1 person that buys 1 laptop a year? The person that goes to Best Buy to buy an "ultra value" laptop is not the same person that buys a $2000 laptop. And my guess is that $2000 laptops are more profitable to make than $100 laptops.
- djcapelis 16y agoIndividual enthusiast consumers are an incredibly small portion of the people who buy computers. You're lucky if you can interest a computer manufacturer with the concerns of the consumer market as a whole, much less the tiny fraction known as enthusiasts. Most companies in hardware make their money on selling to people who buy a lot more than one machine at a time.
- calpaterson 16y agoPeople always assume this and I can't help but wonder why? Just because the price is higher doesn't really say anything about the value of the spread between cost and price
- aneth 16y agoI've used both on a Mac. When Apple started offering both, I agonized but finally opted for glossy and haven't looked back. My preference on most things is matte - I always opted for matte when people printed photos from something called "film." Here's why glossy screens are better, for me anyway: 1) It's better in sunlight. Counterintuitive I know, but it's far, far better. Matte screens diffract light and render the screen unreadable. Glossy screens can be made visible either passively (in very strong light) or actively if the screen is bright enough (as many now are.) 2) Glare is controllable and not diffused on a glossy screen. With a matte screen, glare manifests as blobs, and spread across the screen. With a glossy screen, glare is localized and easily defeated by repositioning the screen. 3) Matte makes screens less bright. It's a translucent filter, so of course it reflects and absorbs light. 4) Matte filters can be added, but a matte screen can't be made glossy. The real solution: get rid of awful overhead florescent lighting. Ok, not that easy for most of you, but I think Steve Jobs probably wants those gone as much as he wants Flash gone. Any word on lighting at Apple?
- keen 16y agoIt's better in sunlight. I was initially skeptical; after using an iPad outdoors I found it hard to believe matte could be worse! But some quick research seems to confirm your point. Does anyone know of a solution to using screens outdoors? I hear the Kindle is good, but I'm thinking color screen.
- akgerber 16y agohttp://www.mirasoldisplays.com/ http://www.mirasoldisplays.com/ Interferometric Modulator MEMS screens are about to enter mass production.
- jankassens 16y agoA related patent: sun-lit screens: http://www.crunchgear.com/2010/03/25/apple-patent-watch-sun-lit-displays/ http://www.crunchgear.com/2010/03/25/apple-patent-watch-sun-...
- ender7 16y agoMy friend recently got a Sunbook, which he loves to use outdoors: http://www.cloversystems.com/SunBook.htm http://www.cloversystems.com/SunBook.htm (their website is horrific, but the product is decent). It's essentially a netbook with a special screen that can can work in both daylight and indoor light. In the sun, most of the colors wash away and it becomes a mostly black&white screen. But you can read it perfectly easily (similar to eink, but I don't think it actually uses eink, despite what their PR claims).
- waqf 16y agoBased on the title, I was hoping to learn from this article why the PC industry was out of touch, but I only learned that it was, which I already knew.
- Locke1689 16y agoApparently PC Pro has a little trouble with the term "selection bias."
- S_A_P 16y agoI dunno i really like the glass screen on my macbook pro. I dont mind the gloss at all. I would say I prefer it even. Offering a choice would be nice though.
- rawsyntax 16y agoI would prefer a choice for the same price, no matte surcharge
- aurynn 16y agoPersonally, I much prefer glossy screens, both the glass-covered screen on my Macbook Pro as well as the polished LCD on my old Aspire netbook. In general, the higher contrast and more vibrant colours are a net win, and I find my eyes less strained looking at the display.
- ScottBurson 16y agoWhat I don't get is, on a display like an iMac where the front surface of the display is glass, why doesn't Apple offer an optical coating (i.e., anti-reflection coating) option? Optical coating used to be standard on high-end CRT monitors. It seems like the right solution here as well. I wouldn't miss the matte finish nearly so much if I could get the glossy screen coated.
- Truxe 16y agoI think that the visceral reaction to the terms "glossy" and "matte" could be a factor here. Glossy, by itself, is associated with cheap and shiny. Matte sounds understated and elegant. If the survey had been done with a picture of a glossy screen, and a matte screen, and readers would have been asked to choose, I suspect the results could have been closer.
- qohen 16y agoI was looking at an HP laptop online last night and saw it has a "Brightview" screen. This description of it, apparently from the company that makes the screens, suggests that, while glossy, it is also anti-reflective. Does anyone know if that means it is more like a matte screen than a regular glossy screen or not really? http://www.screentekinc.com/hp-compaq-brightview-lcd-screens.shtml http://www.screentekinc.com/hp-compaq-brightview-lcd-screens...