2 ms·
And i don't disagree that we should always be seeking. There may be new methods that we don't yet know, new threats, new risks. Science is after all not Math, a
by bawolff 6y ago
And i don't disagree that we should always be seeking. There may be new methods that we don't yet know, new threats, new risks. Science is after all not Math, and does not have the type of rigorous 100% proven answers that math enjoys, nothing is ever 100% settled.
But we still live in the real world, and have to take action based on imperfect knowledge. The line between "this appears safe, we should make consumer products out of it" and "this appears questionable, we should hold off on it" has to be drawn somewhere. In my view the anti-5g crowd seems to be holding 5g to a different standard than pretty much everything else in the world. If they claimed that 5g lacked sufficient safety data, and foreswore 5g along with everything else that had a similar level of safety data, i would be able to respect that. But that generally does not seem to be the case.
As you say, in a very technical sense, this is not a question of science. Science can help us place bounds on the risk and inform the decision making. The actual decision making is a normative question. It is a question of values: what level of risk is appropriate? Science can't tell you what you should do, just at most what is likely to happen for a given choice. Fundamentally my objection to the anti-5g crowd is it seems to want to take a significantly lower risk tolerance for 5g relative to pretty much anything else, without a compelling argument for why a different standard should be in place for just this technology.