3 ms·
There's good public data on George W. Bush's intelligence. https://vdare.com/articles/this-just-in-kerry-s-iq-likely-lower-than-bush-s https://vdare.com/articl
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
There's good public data on George W. Bush's intelligence.
https://vdare.com/articles/this-just-in-kerry-s-iq-likely-lower-than-bush-s https://vdare.com/articles/this-just-in-kerry-s-iq-likely-lo...
> According to a 1999 article in The New Yorker, he had a 566 Verbal - 640 Math, for a 1206 total (which would be about 1280 today [in 2004]).
>> "I recently converted Bush's SAT score to an IQ using the high school norms available for his age cohort. Educational Testing Service happened to have done a study of representative high school students within a year or so of when he took the test. I derived an IQ of 125, which is the 95th percentile."
>> "I think you're safe in saying that Dubya's IQ, based on his SAT score, is in excess of 120, which puts him in the top 10 percent of the distribution, but I wouldn't try to be more precise than that."
> The standardization report by Miller and Valentine says that the "officer population" that provided the percentile scores was about one standard deviation better than the average 12th grade male on the Verbal subtest and about two standard deviations better on the Quantitative test. This suggests that the 50th percentile among the norm group of Air Force Academy applicants had an IQ of about 123, thus putting Bush in the 125-130 range—a little better than his SAT score would imply.
Are students at Stanford Business School really so far below the 95th percentile nationally?
- flukus 6y agoWasn't there a lot of drinking and drugs between his SAT scores and becoming president? Enough of that can create some cognitive impairment, but I don't know if he indulged to that degree.
- torginus 6y agoI'm not American, so I don't really know about the SAT, but I've seen SAT scores matched up to IQ scores many, many times. I would think the SAT (or any entrance test) measures how well a given student mastered the high-school curriculum. For me this can mean 2 things: - The SAT indeed measures studiousness + intelligence, in which case, deriving IQ scores directly from it is highly misleading. - The SAT is a decent proxy for IQ, which would indicate that universities have a very dim view on secondary education, and basically your intellectually gifted slacker can walk into a SAT exam, and easily outdo their less gifted, but hardworking peers.
- ForHackernews 6y agoThe first interpretation is mistaken. The SAT very explicitly does not test knowledge of high school curriculum. Importantly, the United States does not have any standardized national curriculum, so there is no way to write a national test of material all students are expected to know. Originally, SAT was short for "Scholastic Aptitude Test" and it was designed to measure "aptitude", not mastery of specific material. Many lawsuits later and SAT is now a meaningless initialism that stands for nothing. > your intellectually gifted slacker can walk into a SAT exam, and easily outdo their less gifted, but hardworking peers. Is accurate and true of many of my lazy-but-smart secondary school classmates.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The first interpretation is mistaken. The SAT very explicitly does not test knowledge of high school curriculum. This is correct, but it's not really relevant. The SAT subject tests (SAT IIs) explicitly do test knowledge of the high school curriculum, but they are psychometrically equivalent to the SAT I. That is to say, someone's SAT II scores do contain the same information that their SAT I scores do, and don't contain additional information (such as studiousness). The reason that SAT II scores don't get confounded by studiousness is that taking SAT IIs is opt-in -- if someone takes the test at all, then they've been educated in the subject, and the residual is an IQ test just like the SAT. (Counterfactually, if everyone had to take the SAT II Latin, then stupid people with Latin training would often outscore smart people with no Latin training. But that's not the system we have; smart people with no Latin training, in reality, don't take the SAT II Latin.)
- jura12 6y ago> Are students at Stanford Business School really so far below the 95th percentile nationally? In my previous big bank company we had some tests for our internal business school. Tests were mostly IQ type so the result was that, in the first few years, school was filled mostly with IT people. Later they changed tests (e.g. live case study test) so more business people did manage to go to the business school. So I guess, the answer would be yes :)
- 8note 6y agoDubya could have easily cheated, given the wealth and power his family has.