4 ms·
I'm pro-immigration, in the classic "the more the merrier" tradition of those with confidence in both markets and human innovation. But to be intellectually ho
by gojomo 18y ago
I'm pro-immigration, in the classic "the more the merrier" tradition of those with confidence in both markets and human innovation.
But to be intellectually honest, we have to acknowledge that immigrants of different languages, cultures, and economic backgrounds will bring many 'average' statistics of education (and health, etc.) down. This is even true if the immigration is a net-benefit to both natives and newcomers.
With that in mind, the massive downvoting of the parent comment (at -9 at one point) is a dishonest enforcement of political correctness.
Even if you disagree with the conclusions of the linked article, and the other views of that article's author, the comment here is factual and relevant to the topic at hand, and the linked article includes other useful facts about Finland.
If the submission question "What makes Finnish kids so smart?" is legitimate at all -- the study of why one country has different results than others -- discussion has to be free to consider major things that make that country different from others. In Finland's case, that includes its traditional and apparently legally-enforced homogeneity.
I would not want to live in such a place, but I don't want my understanding of such places crippled by a long list of "things you can't say".
- mynameishere 18y agolegally-enforced homogeneity Honest question: Would you want to live in a country with legally-enforced diversity? (Because that's where you're living.)
- gojomo 18y agoThe question is too vague to answer. What kind of 'diversity' and how is it 'enforced'? I haven't emigrated, and I prefer more open immigration than either Finland or the U.S. allow.
- dgabriel 18y agoYes.
- mynameishere 18y agoYour neighborhood or mine? Is it okay if the good and decent men of congress choose your neighbors? Or should nationalist groups like La Raza be in charge of determining the country's composition? That's what I mean by "legally-enforced diversity": Powerful people, deciding for other people, whether they are acceptable, or whether they should be numerically marginalized.
- dgabriel 18y agoIf you are asking if enforced diversity as it exists in this country today is ok, as in one cannot be discriminated against based on nationality, color, creed, or sexual orientation, then yes. I prefer that to a nation where tiny city states can determine whether or not they want their neighbors to be all white, or bosses can decide if they only want to hire men. That's totally fine with me, even if it needs to be legally enforced. La Raza is not a nationalist group, but an organization to help disadvantaged Latinos. Do you know La Raza members?
- astine 18y agoHow about freedom of association? I heard that they tried that once. Seems like a good idea.
- Alex3917 18y ago"the massive downvoting of the parent comment is a dishonest enforcement of political correctness." I don't read Sailer's blog, but from what I understand it's mainly devoted to proving that African-Americans have lower IQs because of inferior genetics. Now you might say, well if this really is true, then wouldn't denying it be intellectually dishonest? Here's the thing though. The black-white IQ gap has been almost entirely explained by controlling for SES and other factors. Anyone who spends all day quibbling over the last two or three points clearly just has an axe to grind for other reasons.
- lexlibra 18y agoThe black-white IQ gap has been almost entirely explained by controlling for SES and other factors. I used to think the same thing. But when I actually spent some time reading and evaluating the evidence, it turns out that is far from the case. The official scientific consensus is that the jury is still out. But there is certainly a strong case for the genetic basis - see this article in Slate for example: http://www.slate.com/id/2178122/entry/2178123/ http://www.slate.com/id/2178122/entry/2178123/
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- rkts 18y ago> it's mainly devoted to proving that African-Americans have lower IQs because of inferior genetics No, it isn't.
- gojomo 18y agoSailer's other writings are no good reason to downvote the factual, relevant excerpt above from user 'occam'. And regarding those other writings, do you think you can give a fair summary, and a convincing refutation, when you haven't read them?
- Alex3917 18y agoI've read some of them, and I followed his spat with Gladwell. I also didn't vote down his comment. My point was more that Steve Sailer in general has never struck me as the model of intellectual integrity.
- gruseom 18y agoI downvoted it, not because of political correctness, but because it seemed like linkbait. The account was only hours old and the post expressed no view of its own. Also, the reference to "Third World" immigrants struck me as gratuitous, and suggestive in a negative way.
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoI agree with most of what you say. But I also think homogenity is not the whole story. How many non spanish speaking kids are there in a typical Mexican classroom? I know Mexico does have an indigenous population, but I think the share of Mexicans who don't speak proper spanish is very low. Probably even lower than that of native swedish or russian speakers in Finland. My conclusion is that economic and teaching related causes are probably more significant than ethnic ones. I think you would find that mixed language elite schools anywhere in the world rank higher than the average Finnish school. Sadly, it's a poignant feature of most european immigrant populations that they are poor and uneducated. They don't just speak different languages, they don't speak any language particularly well. It's just averaging of course but that's what the PISA test does.