4 ms·
The Tether situation is even more suspect when you consider that Tether and Bitfinex are operated by the same group of people. The two companies have tried to p
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
The Tether situation is even more suspect when you consider that Tether and Bitfinex are operated by the same group of people. The two companies have tried to publicly distance themselves from each other at times, but the Paradise Papers leak revealed that the two companies are, in fact, closely related ( https://news.bitcoin.com/paradise-papers-reveal-bitfinexs-devasini-and-potter-established-tether-already-back-in-2014/ https://news.bitcoin.com/paradise-papers-reveal-bitfinexs-de... )
Keep in mind that Bitfinex profits from trading activity. They benefit substantially from both increased prices and increased volume, both of which occur after each Tether-driven surge in Bitcoin. The concern is that the Bitfinex operators are using Tether as a convenient pump to drive the market into a frenzy, from which they profit greatly by skimming trading fees off of the top. If only a fraction of people ever try to withdraw Tether, it's entirely possible that they could cash out those few requests from trading profits, indirectly. If they can continue to pump the value of Bitcoin higher and higher, any potential fraud may never be exposed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- washedup 6y agoI think you don’t really understand how Tether works.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoCould you please elaborate rather than giving a drive-by dismissal? I'm explaining the fraud angle that everyone is concerned about. Of course, if Tether works exactly as the Tether corporation claims (but has yet to prove) then there's nothing to see here. Seems that they would be quick to try to prove this to regulators, though.
- atian 6y agoThis may be a similar strategy to Binance's BNB token, where Binance operates BNB in a way similar to Bitfinex's "bailout" LEO token by committing their exchange revenue to token buybacks, forcing the token value to go up.
- washedup 6y agoMy first reply was rather terse, so trying again, and I have a couple points: 1. Tether, even if fraudulent, has very little impact on bitcoin. How do I know this? There are currently 24 Billion dollars worth of tether in existence. The daily volume of bitcoin in dollars is almost three times that much. Even if tether wasn’t backed by dollars on a 1:1 basis, it would have a small impact on the current market cap of bitcoin. This is important because many people say tether is proof that bitcoin price is heavily manipulated and inflated. The reality is that selling $24 billion dollars worth of bitcoin won’t move that needle that much. 2. I have no reason to not trust tether. If it is one day revealed that there are no dollars backing the minting of tether, then so what? See point #1. People have been curious about Tether for years, and for good reason: it’s the first successful stablecoin (success in the sense that it actually gets used).
- floatingatoll 6y agoDo you have any conflicts of interest with respect to cryptocurrencies and/or stablecoins, such as personal investments in or employment in regards to them? Your comment history seems to indicate that since 2019 you’ve primarily commented at HN only to speak positively about cryptocoins, and so I’m curious if your financial welfare depends on them somehow.
- washedup 6y agoThanks for digging. Yes, of course I am invested. If I believed the things I say about them, it would be ridiculous not to be. Could you please instead address my response? What about my points do you disagree with? Edit: I have no exposure with Tether and honestly don’t care what happens with it. But it is not artificially propping up the value of bitcoin or other currencies.
- floatingatoll 6y agoI’m not well-versed enough in cryptocurrency to be able to reply otherwise to your comment, apologies.
- nwah1 6y agoThis all hinges on exchanges reporting USDT trades as if they are USD trades. This is only plausible if the spot price of Tether remains at $1. They will need to regularly inject money to keep the spot price of Tether at $1, but as you say the fees and ponzi can allow this as long as the number goes up. The problem would come if the number stops going up and there isn't enough money to cover all the people dumping the Tether IOUs simultaneously. I assume they cannot cover $25 billion dollars of worthless IOUs. Even more if their assets are also simply bitcoin, which in such a scenario would also be collapsing in price.
- Triv888 6y ago> If they can continue to pump the value of Bitcoin higher and higher, any potential fraud may never be exposed. https://marketinsider.net/why-tether-might-tank-the-crypto-market-on-jan-15th https://marketinsider.net/why-tether-might-tank-the-crypto-m... > Bitfinex and Tether have till the 15th of January to submit documents to the New York state attorney general about their financial relationship.