4 ms·
Any analysis that says that Intel's death is being precipitated by AMD and Apple rather than by TSMC is pretty much worth ignoring. The fact that they're almos
by monocasa 6y ago
Any analysis that says that Intel's death is being precipitated by AMD and Apple rather than by TSMC is pretty much worth ignoring.
The fact that they're almost equivalent to those two at 5nm when Intel is at 14nm+++++++++ shows how killer the RTL and tape out folk are at Intel.
The real fight has always been at the fab layer.
- mardiyah 6y agoAnyone know who pars TSMC?
- monocasa 6y agoWhat do you mean by "pars TSMC"?
- mardiyah 6y agoOn par with it as client fab
- monocasa 6y agoThey are the leading edge currently with no competitors that don't come with their own performance compromises.
- posguy 6y agoSamsung has 8nm, but Nvidia has had a bit of a rocky ride on it as it was not tuned for large die area chips, but rather small Exynos SoCs.
- monocasa 6y agoSure, but that's only a cute hack due to Apple bidding to eat up literally all of the TSMC 5nm capacity. I'm sure Nvidia would prefer TSMC 5nm to Samsung 8nm if they could put their hands on it.
- posguy 6y agoNvidia bit the hand that fed them (TSMC) hence not using TSMC 7nm or 5nm. Turns out complaining publicly about your manufacturing partner year after year causes them to allocate their wafer starts to your competition (AMD, Apple, etc).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dathinab 6y agoIt also shows that you can't compare nm measurements which measure slightly different thinks and are missing out a lot of factors ;=)
- monocasa 6y agoHaha, sure, but there's only a node or so difference. 10nm Intel is about 7nm TSMC density wise (with a lot of caveats in either direction, one has denser logic, the other has denser SRAM, etc).
- trhway 6y ago>The fact that they're almost equivalent to those two at 5nm when Intel is at 14nm+++++++++ Only when it comes to single core. And even then Intel has to spend 2x silicon - Zen 3 CCD at 7nm with a die size of 80.7 mm² while Intel's 10th gen 8C die is 170mm2. Of course it isn't silicon itself which is costly, it is the processing of each wafer what is the cost here, and getting 2x less cores per wafer is bound to affect the margin/profit/etc. And of course Intel has no chances of putting out 16C chip into normal desktop like AMD does with 3950x and 5950x (those chips successfully go into the territory of 2x Xeon workstations costing arm and leg)
- ChrisIsTaken 6y agoI'd reckon per unit area, Intel's cost on 14nm wafers are going to run to less than 25% of TSMC's ask price at 7nm. Do keep in mind that a fair amount of a desktop chip is pad space, IO hasn't shrunk since 22nm nodes, DUV steppers are dirt cheap, Intel's foundries are fully amortized, and yields at 14nm are going to be approaching 100%.
- passive 6y agoYeah, exactly this. Intel has really stumbled on fabrication the last 2-3 years, but the idea that they won't correct that ignores decades of precedent. I'm an AMD fanboy from the K6 days, and I love what Lisa Su has been able to deliver for them, but if it wasn't for Intel's stumbles, they would still be single digits at best in most markets. Look at their progress from Pentium 4 to Core 2 Duo (makes me feel real old to see that was 15 years ago). We probably won't see quite as dramatic an improvement over the next 3 years, but I'll be stunned if AMD still has the performance lead at that point. Apple's a wildcard, but they aren't going to sell their chips, and they represent a fairly small part of the PC market. No other non-x86 chips have made even a tiny dent in the PC market, and even in the datacenter, it's still mostly x86. The absolute worst I can imagine happening to Intel over the next decade is that they no longer define the CPU market. But that's a long, long, way from dying, and will probably be good for the market and good for Intel in the long run.
- systemvoltage 6y agoCurious, why were you a fanboy? Is it like rooting for team red and all the fun that goes into it? Honestly wondering since I have no feelings for any company even if their products are amazing.
- calvano915 6y agoI've been a fan for much the same time period yet never owned an AMD powered device, except maybe a game console? AMD has been useful to keep Intel on top of their game, but Intel has been on top for most of the last 15 years give or take.
- systemvoltage 6y agoThat's awesome. I want some of the old school Intel memorabilia and souveniers like this one. Intel had such a great brand back in the 90's: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-1997-Intel-Inside-MMX-Bunny-People-Plush-Spaceman-Lavender-Metallic-8/333746429567 https://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-1997-Intel-Inside-MMX-Bunny... You guys remember the blue man group? Good days. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tH0PYQl65LU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tH0PYQl65LU
- ChrisIsTaken 6y agoApple did poach a few of Intel's better architects and killed Intel's smartphone ambitions. But the damage occured two decades before that. Intel is dying because they should have entered the foundry business in the early 90's. Process was always their forte, they were never good at the CPU architecture design anyway as iAPX/i860/Itanium amply demonstrated. Instead they blew $100B getting into antivirus, network security, mobileye, infineon, and a dozen other failed businesses, $50B in illegal kickbacks keeping AMD out of the unprofitable low end laptop market, and another $50B of "contra revenue" subsidizing their inferior me-too products against mobile SOCs they should have been fabbing in the first place.
- usefulcat 6y agoI'm curious about how Apple "killed Intel's smartphone ambitions"? Otellini on the iPhone: "We ended up not winning it or passing on it, depending on how you want to view it." "At the end of the day, there was a chip that they were interested in that they wanted to pay a certain price for and not a nickel more and that price was below our forecasted cost. I couldn't see it. It wasn't one of these things you can make up on volume. And in hindsight, the forecasted cost was wrong and the volume was 100x what anyone thought."
- AtlasBarfed 6y ago"And in hindsight, the forecasted cost was wrong and the volume was 100x what anyone thought." And in hindsight, he was a moron, unqualified to lead an engineering company. When people point to MBAs ruining Intel. Point to that statement. You could invest in emerging markets. Or rearrange financial statements deck chairs to hit your stock options and roll your eyes at the nerds.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 6y agoIt's easy in hindsight, nobody knew iphone would take off so strongly. Did you sell the house and load up on Apple stock at the time?
- jabl 6y agoThe rise of TSMC, or more generally the merchant fab model, is really the big semiconductor story of the past few decades. Traditional wisdom used to be that if you wanted cutting edge performance, you really needed your own cutting edge in-house fab. The vertical integration advantages of tuning your ASIC design to your process were unassailable. If you couldn't afford your own foundry, tough luck, you suffered a severe penalty in performance and/or cost. But the merchant foundries, first and foremost TSMC, have really turned that traditional wisdom around. Both in terms of matching, and then surpassing Intel on deploying the latest process nodes, but also in terms of making it possible for 3rd party ASIC developers to use that process as efficiently as an in-house design team would be able to.
- TheBigSalad 6y agoI'm out of my league here, but I get the impression that Intel can't take their same design and pass it off to TSMC to print up chips at 5nm. I think it's more than that, but correct me if I'm wrong.