15 ms·
The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about technology and democracy
- typenil 6y agoAfter WWII when the Soviets took control of nations like Poland, they didn't flat out ban free speech. But they did make sure only the communist-aligned outlets had unlimited access to paper. Like so many censorship-happy people today, the USSR could also say that the government wasn't censoring speech. They were only controlling paper.
- ABeeSea 6y agoWhat did the government do here?
- rhino369 6y agoCongress has been investigating big tech for "allowing" violence, hate speech, election interference, etc. Its might not be a coincidence that they all started heightened moderation only after it was clear Trump was cruising to a loss. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/09/18/facebook-google-twitter-face-fresh-heat-congress-harmful-online-content/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/09/18/faceboo...
- typenil 6y agoI care about the reality of free speech, not the abstract concept. It matters to me not one bit who the censors are if the end result is the same. A handful of companies control the vast majority of discourse in the world - and there's no competition in their moderation styles. It's either time to split them up or to regulate them.
- koolk3ychain 6y agoSomeone really needs to give the New Yorker some serious credit for publishing what can genuinely be described as a thoughtful, well written, and objective article on social media and big tech. Bravo. I'm honestly convinced that at some point this kind of big tech social media witch burning will eventually lead to private lawsuits aimed at non-combatants like Signal and Wickr. Please leave a comment if you disagree - down votes don't help sow discussion.
- fortran77 6y agoThe best sources of news seem to be the ones I pay for: New Yorker, New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post
- flyinglizard 6y agoDo these newspapers provide thought provoking articles, or just fuel confirmation bias for their readers? I was a subscriber of NYT for a few years, and the one time there was a dissenting opinion - that of Tom Cotton - it led to editors being fired. WSJ seems better, maybe because business reporting tends to be somewhat less opinionated.
- tedunangst 6y agoPretty sure NY Times has published more than one dissenting opinion over the years.
- theplague42 6y agoWas the editor fired because of a "dissenting opinion" or because Cotton was effectively calling for martial law against protestors? The NYTimes op-ed section has plenty of dissenting opinions and/or conservatives... just not ones calling for violence.
- flyinglizard 6y agoThere was absolutely nothing outrageous in Cotton's op-ed. Mind, the same National Guard that Cotton was calling for was now sent to the Capitol, and I don't think NYT was up in arms. That aside, he's a public representative of the highest order (a Senator). He needs to be heard whether we like it or not. I've not seen any public representative being censored in the country I'm from, that including opinion pieces from extremist parliament members on both sides. This is clearly a US thing.
- d1zzy 6y ago
- chaostheory 6y agoWho would have predicted 20 years ago that we should be more wary of Little Sister (big tech) instead of Big Brother? I like to call them Little Sister because of how they name their seemingly innocuous digital assistants.
- kweinber 6y agoIs anyone seriously more worried about the independent players of big tech than an oligarch who has roused the firepower and hatred of domestic terrorists across the country? The rhetoric is really overblown.... these companies waited years and until the heads of state were fully under attack before they did much of anything. This isn’t even about free speech. People can still say what they want.... they just don’t have an absolute right to broadcast it on every major platform.
- chaostheory 6y agoIt may be great right now, but what happens when Little Sister's ideals and motivations are no longer aligned with ours?
- rdiddly 6y agoraises hand
- baumy 6y agoIt is perfectly possible to be worried about both, which is where I'm currently at. The amount of influence a handful of individual companies (run by unaccountable BDFLs) have over our entire social discourse should make everyone uneasy. If I had to pick though, yes I would say I'm more worried about people who think the state of affairs this article is discussing is completely fine, as opposed to idiots acting out after being cooped up at home for a year. The latter is a concerning problem but one much more easily dealt with, if for no other reason than that a large majority of people agree that it is actually a problem.
- amanaplanacanal 6y ago
- xpe 6y agoI almost lost interest in the article's stream-of-consciousness style rambling until its discussion of Section 230: > In the United States, online speech is governed by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, a piece of legislation passed in 1996 that grants Internet companies immunity from liability for user-generated content. Most public argument about moderation elides the fact that Section 230 was intended to encourage tech companies to cull and restrict content. But moderation is complex and costly, and it is inherently political. Most companies have developed policies that are reactive rather than proactive. Many of the largest digital platforms have terms-of-service agreements that are constantly evolving and content policies that are enforced unevenly and in self-contradictory ways. I highly recommend reading from this point forward.
- xpe 6y agoIn my view, understanding all sides of the following question is central for anyone who wants to understand the implications of modern social technology. > To cut a politician and affiliated organizations off from payment processors, Web-hosting services, and e-mail providers is to halt them at the level of infrastructure. It is a different game than the moderation of user-generated content, and raises different questions. Advocates for net neutrality have long argued that Internet service providers should not determine who their users are, within the bounds of legality; in this view, Internet service providers are akin to public utilities. For Trump, arguably, it’s as though the electric company has permanently turned off the lights.
- kiwidrew 6y agoYeah, to me this is the key point in the whole debate: to what extent are the private internet "giants" providing infrastructure and/or operating as a public utility? I was concerned when Twitter and Facebook and other social media platforms started the mass deactivation of accounts they no longer wanted to host, but in the end I don't think these actions are wholly unjustified: nobody should be entitled to a megaphone for their speech. And as many have said, "if you don't like it go start your own social network" is an acceptable response. The real issue is at the next layer down, the service providers which collectively operate what we know as "the Internet": what if you can't go start your own social network because none of the server hosts or domain registrars will provide their services to you? But do we really want to mandate (and regulate) that hosting providers must provide service to anyone that asks, no matter how undesirable or troublesome they might be? Should there be a "provider of last resort" for those that are unable to find a willing host? I'd like to see more discussion and debate on this topic.
- diggernet 6y agoUndesirable or troublesome to whom? If you say something on the Internet that angers a mob, you are no more directly harming your ISP than you are directly harming your electric company. Why should one of them be able to cut you off on a whim, and the other cannot? If it is because one of them is more indirectly harmed, such as by the mob attacking them, then why do tolerate such attacks on one but not the other? Fundamentally, I think that a service provider, of any service, should be expected to provide their service to anyone willing to pay for it, as long as that customer does not actively and directly harm the service provider. Mob actions against the provider are a separate matter, and should be opposed, whether they are calling for all ISPs to disconnect the offender or for all grocers to stop selling them food. Further, I think that even at the platform level, permabans should not be allowed (unless perhaps with a court judgement after multiple offenses). Temporary suspension for TOS violations? Sure! But there should always be a clear and accessible process for appeal, and for the offender to redeem themselves. Considering what a large and important part of society communication platforms have become, a lifetime ban without trial or recourse is unacceptable and unconscionable.
- xpe 6y ago> We may see the emergence of new business structures for communications and media platforms, or an increase in collective actions taken by tech workers. In all likelihood, this past weekend was a turning point not only for Trump and Trumpism, but for the American technology industry. I'd like to hear about some testable predictions from the HN community. What do you think will happen and with what odds? And, to put a finer point on it, how much would you be willing to wager on your prediction if you were given $1,000 in credits for a prediction market (this is hypothetical, but pretend like it is real money if you can).
- paganel 6y ago> or an increase in collective actions taken by tech workers. I don't see this happening anytime soon, worker-related collective action has been pretty much dead in the West for at least the past 15-20 years, even much so in an industry like ours with deep ideological roots in libertarianism. Even if we were to pass over the ingrained ideological biases, the money is too good for us to risk it. > the emergence of new business structures for communications and media platforms, Not sure what the author means by that. Will there be a new Trump-loving Twitter or FB? Probably not, at least not at that scale, and it will be all for the best, because we need to see behemoths like Twitter and FB perish (in Schumpeter's "creative destruction"-sense, before anyone starts flagging this post for inciting violence) and it's time we went back to the forum-like internet communities popular until the late 2000s (of which this website is one of the last active survivors).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrchang523 6y agoMy primary prediction is that the main US platforms will fall behind homegrown alternatives in India over the next 1-2 decades, >80% likelihood.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beefee 6y agoAre there any companies or organizations working to protect Internet freedom?
- loceng 6y agoThat want to allow inciting of violence on platforms? Serious question. Edit to add: anyone going to answer or just downvote and ignore the question?
- typenil 6y agoLet's sweep all the dirt under the rug and then act surprised when we find it's so much grosser than the rest of the floor.
- loceng 6y agoWhat?!
- cousin_it 6y agoI think people who want to talk to each other should be able to do it without my listening or interfering, even if they're planning violence against me. Don't get me wrong, I do want to be defended from violence! But not at all costs. I don't want people to be tortured in the name of defending me, and I don't want every conversation on the internet to be monitored and censored in the name of defending me. That's too much.
- loceng 6y agoThey could still do that - just not on platforms who don't want to support people rallying violence against others; it's not smart to build a palace on potential "enemy" territory - or on land of those that may not agree with you - although understandable if they do out of ease, when there's technological convenience to do so.
- loceng 6y ago
- u678u 6y agoIts tough making these decisions for the USA. However there are over 100 countries with democracies or at least elections and in other languages and different cultures, how can social media platforms police content globally? Its a mess.
- tonetheman 6y agoWhile there are consequences and secondary effects to banning Trump off of all the things... There was a moment when the body count started adding up and anyone with common sense can see it is his fault. It was Trump that caused this, he in effect killed those people at the capital. Had it gone worse someone would have been killed or hung on live TV. All of that is on him. Maybe all the platforms did all call each other, but there is a moment where you just have to take action. And that action was to stop him from killing more people. Stop him from destroying more things. It is not free speech ... it is at a cost. Those lives. He is a monster and does not need a platform. This is not a slippery slope. He had to be stopped. Maybe it leads to more choices and actions and discussions as to why he had a voice on those platforms at all. In either case the right choice was made. Stop him.
- peytn 6y agoMaybe, I don’t watch TV, and it’s probably not a good source of common sense. The government has plenty of tools. I’m frankly not going to be convinced they need me to abandon my principles in order to stay in power. If the president is doing bad stuff, I know there exists a process that doesn’t have me in the loop that can fix it.
- darig 6y agoNone of the questions are hard. Not even building your own platform is hard. The only thing that is hard for the author, and the majority of their readers, is admitting to themselves that they are unwilling or unable to execute and provide for themselves.
- d0100 6y agoBig Tech platforms are more and more functioning as utilities, and I believe they should be regulated as such. Actually, any digital platform with user-generated content should be regulated in such a way that frees platforms from pressures from the government (Section 230) and from social justice (ban bad guy that's not convicted and will have no recourse or penalty expiry)
- mullingitover 6y ago> in such a way that frees platforms from pressures from the government (Section 230) Section 230 does free platforms from pressure from the government. A service provider that is responsible for the content posted by users would have much greater exposure and would be far more likely to censor. People don't understand that 230 is mostly enabling free speech, not stifling it. The anti-230 crowd is like a dog chasing a car. It's all fun and games to chase that car, but what do you think is going to happen when you get what you're chasing?
- d0100 6y agoThe anti-230 sentiment is just a knee-jerk reaction from people that see an unfair situation and just want to punish the perpetrators. It's a guttural response to unfair treatment. I think that what should be sought is another "Section 231" that makes banning users from platforms must go through the justice system, just like if you wanted to ban someone from the town square. This gives platforms a scapegoat, "the government won't let me", but still allows the platform to do things like not list "bad" people in the "discover" feed and make better mute/ignore features Unilateral and permanent banning just creates more problems
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoMore problems for who? Not for the platform. Maybe for the folks who are banned, they lose their free megaphone and have to actually pay to get their opinions heard, which seems like a fine trade off to me. I’m slowly coming around to the idea that getting rid of section 230 would be a good thing overall. Social media platforms shouldn’t be amplifying ideas they think are odious. Why the heck would anybody do that? For money? Would you be willing to spread propaganda that you thought was terrible for money? I sure wouldn’t.
- intended 6y agoWhat I find missing from a lot of the conversations on HN is why the power was used, and an overfocus on tech. The people who marched on the capitol did it because their reality tells them that their country is being stolen, by Democrats. People will actively oppose the current administration, because they believe this is illegitimate. Trump and the info bubble he inflates, collectively believe that American elections were a farce. Trump holds a 40% approval rating, down from 42% on Jan 1st. His party, and media enablers repeated and enforce this idea. If the coup didn't happen, they would continue to argue the point. Parler? For all its claims to free speech, it enforced ideological conformity, as do a lot of conservative boards. Their reasoning is that you get banned for being a conservative. However they don't mention that they get banned for saying "COVID is a hoax", "Trump won" and the perennial "some communities just have problems". Death threats, hate speech are all too common. That is how far things had gotten, before tech firms acted. If anything, they acted late, after the costs of inaction are obvious, and Trump is leaving the stage. If you are uncomfortable with their power, know that research from 2016 shows that conspiracy content gets stronger the longer it is available and gets repeated. A fact absolutely not lost to tech firms. Tech firms kept material they knew was dangerous, up longer, because they did not know how to handle the repercussions of doing the scientific thing when people think its the wrong action.
- TYPE_FASTER 6y ago* Trump and former Senate Majority leader McConnell talk about rolling back Section 230 * Companies that could be held liable enforce Terms of Service after warning offenders * Senators draft legislation to "prohibit social media censorship." (https://www.miamiherald.com/news/politics-government/state-politics/article248452195.html https://www.miamiherald.com/news/politics-government/state-p...) Ironically, if legislation like that was passed, Parler would be facing the same issues as any online forum that moderates content: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200627/23551144803/as-predicted-parler-is-banning-users-it-doesnt-like.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200627/23551144803/as-pr...