5 ms·
Gallows are a time-honoured protest prop (eg, [0]), one being present isn't really the manifestation of gross negligence that this post wants to make it out to
by roenxi 6y ago
Gallows are a time-honoured protest prop (eg, [0]), one being present isn't really the manifestation of gross negligence that this post wants to make it out to be [1].
This is not a very interesting post. Yeah you could predict that there was going to be a protest from Parler. There would have been people saying "hey, there is a rally on the 6th, lets go there and show our support".
[0] https://www.victoriabuzz.com/2019/11/climate-activists-plan-to-erect-gallows-outside-victoria-times-colonist-building-tomorrow/ https://www.victoriabuzz.com/2019/11/climate-activists-plan-...
[1] Refering to "Parler allowed the idea of attacking and hanging politicians ... through gross negligence or willing ignorance. This idea manifested itself in the gallows erected outside the US Capitol on January 6th.
- 99_00 6y agoExactly. It's nothing. Just as this is nothing: ‘OFF WITH HIS HEAD’ Black Lives Matter protesters put Trump effigy in a GUILLOTINE outside White House https://www.the-sun.com/news/1384275/protesters-trump-effigy-guillotine-white-house/ https://www.the-sun.com/news/1384275/protesters-trump-effigy... Both sides do it. Both sides fein outrage and disgust at the other side doing it.
- zaq1 6y agoTabloids are not credible.
- coffexx 6y agohttps://twitter.com/ShelbyTalcott/status/1299168966255017984 https://twitter.com/ShelbyTalcott/status/1299168966255017984 Here, from someone on the ground that night, you can clearly see St. John's Episcopal Church in the videos. The tabloid was reporting correctly. The fact these sorts of things, including all the other violence and destruction going on at the time, were either ignored wholesale or played down by mainstream news sources, while also being actively encouraged in the next breath ought to be a source of shame for them. The country spent the last year being gas-lit. Its no surprise at all why many people on the right distrust them.
- zaq1 6y agoWow, there really was a fake Trump model under a guillotine. I agree that major news outlets have become very polarized and lack critical reflection of their own reporting / party they support. Still, Trump supporters have become quite removed from reality, and "liberal" outlets at least recognized Trump's insane hubris.
- 99_00 6y agoThe article is factually correct. The reason it's in a tabloid is because reporting it is sensationalistic. It's sensationalistic because how one person, or several people, or even dozens or hundreds express themselves in a large crowd doesn't say anything about the other people "standing with them", or politics, or political leaders. This applies to the right and left.
- 3pt14159 6y agoIt's a disgusting practice. I don't care how time-honoured it is. Real people are involved here. Real violence. Real death. Showing someone a guillotine or a gallows or making threats to use deadly violence as part of a political protest is just plain wrong.
- the8472 6y agoI don't disagree that it's a threat. But that threat is always there anyway. We prefer the democratic process because it's less destructive than regular, bloody power transitions. A guillotine can be seen as a reminder for why we have democracy. So in a way it's a pro-democratic symbol as the threat is there to enforce democratic norms. The threat only becomes misguided if you're wrongly under the impression that democratic norms have been violated and thus you're threatening legitimately elected officials. Think of it as a prisoner's dilemma. Perfectly rational or virtuous prisoners might cooperate out of their own volition. But even very selfish prisoners might be convinced to cooperate if they repeatedly get reminded of the grisly outcomes that happen to defectors. We might prefer the former (virtuous actors) but if we can't rely on everyone being like that then encouraging good behavior through threats is the next best option which is still far more preferable than the worst possible equilibrium.
- 3pt14159 6y agoThis is the same kind of thinking that leads to western states that support black propaganda. No. We do not need this. The grisly outcome that they who would defect should not be death. Economic hardship after months long protests which shut down the economy are a much better tool. Or even mass emigration to a safer or more just state. Gandhi was plenty effective enough. We do not need spirals of threats and violence and arms races.
- rvn1045 6y agoBack in the summer protestors stood outside Jeff Bezos's house with a guillotine: https://twitter.com/dcexaminer/status/1299022885231538176 https://twitter.com/dcexaminer/status/1299022885231538176
- formalsystems 6y agoI personally spent many hours on Parler reading the discourse. The Turner Diaries were openly discussed and gave rise to various gallow-related hashtags which proliferated on it. I don't presume to predict anything as was correctly pointed out. I could not and did not imagine the events that transpired.
- roenxi 6y ago> The Turner Diaries were openly discussed and gave rise to various gallow-related hashtags which proliferated on it. This looks to me like a classic correlation-causation mistake. * Discussion a book with mass hangings can lead people to talk about gallows. * Going to a political protest can traditionally involve bringing a gallows. They are not linked, even though both things involve a gallows. Political protest commonly involves nooses (here is a really good one [0]). That is totally normal symbolism after a US president is voted in. [0] https://www.cbs17.com/news/kentucky-man-hangs-effigy-of-donald-trump-by-noose-neighbors-upset/ https://www.cbs17.com/news/kentucky-man-hangs-effigy-of-dona...
- formalsystems 6y agoHello, after further research and contacting an academic source about this, I believe I made a mistake in making a definitive statement about the gallows- it was pointed out to me that gallows as a protest symbol are not tied to any specific group, and I was given enough examples of their use in other protests that it cannot be definitely stated as the original commenter mentioned. I've updated my writing to clarify it as an opinion, and I'm taking a step back to improve my research and tone of writing. The truth is I have never written anything for the Internet before and the constructive criticism of HN users has helped me tremendously. I want to make neutral statements/analysis of facts and rarely if ever provide my personal opinion. Thank you both for taking the time to provide your feedback.
- _delibash_ 6y ago[1] Absolutely. The insinuation is the "wrong people" are not supposed to use it.