3 ms·
>Their economy depended on slavery, not the other way around. When slavery was threatened, they went to war to preserve it. Of course. That doesn't make it a w
by coldtea 6y ago
>Their economy depended on slavery, not the other way around. When slavery was threatened, they went to war to preserve it.
Of course. That doesn't make it a war about slavery, it makes a war about a threatened economic advantage.
In fact, I agree further with you: the South did fight for slavery both as an economic advantage and as a racist ideology.
My issue is with the notion that the Civil War cause as it comes to the North was about the emancipation of the slaves - which I consider cant. It was about economy and control from the Northern side.
- dontreact 6y agoI would advise you that this is not how you are coming off in this discussion. You sound like you are arguing that the civil war was not about slavery.
- dontreact 6y agoYeah you are trying to reframe from your original position “The civil war wasn’t about slavery” To “From the perspective of the north the primary motivation was not slavery” And it’s not convincing to me or to others. The big picture here: was the civil war about slavery? I think the answer is yes, what about you?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> My issue is with the notion that the Civil War cause as it comes to the North There's no serious dispute about that; preserving the Union was the overt aim, and there were slave states in the Union, who clearly weren't fighting against slavery.
- goatinaboat 6y agoIn fact, I agree further with you: the South did fight for slavery both as an economic advantage and as a racist ideology. But slavery doesn’t have to be on racial grounds directly. For example in California they use the prison population as slave labour, Kamala Harris built her entire success on it. It just so happened that the majority of the prison population is black, and she was the state’s top cop. Nothing to see here, move along now.