4 ms·
Well, it wasn't. It was about economic and political integration and competition with the South. Here's a very tame source: "The Civil War in the United States
by coldtea 6y ago
Well, it wasn't. It was about economic and political integration and competition with the South.
Here's a very tame source: "The Civil War in the United States began in 1861, after decades of simmering tensions between northern and southern states over slavery, states’ rights and westward expansion." [ https://www.history.com/topics/american-civil-war/american-civil-war-history https://www.history.com/topics/american-civil-war/american-c... ]
Which of those 3 items you think the North could not care less about (much less go to war for), if it wasn't for its economic impact?
Continuing from the same source:
"In the mid-19th century, while the United States was experiencing an era of tremendous growth, a fundamental economic difference existed between the country’s northern and southern regions. In the North, manufacturing and industry was well established, and agriculture was mostly limited to small-scale farms, while the South’s economy was based on a system of large-scale farming that depended on the labor of Black enslaved people to grow certain crops, especially cotton and tobacco."
The tie with slavery is all about the economy:
"Growing abolitionist sentiment in the North after the 1830s and northern opposition to slavery’s extension into the new western territories led many southerners to fear that the existence of slavery in America—and thus the backbone of their economy—was in danger."
And that's the general causes. The immediate causes for the declaration of war have even less to do with it, and it was all about the secession of several states - i.e. whether the federal state has control over them or not.
- breakyerself 6y agoWhat a shit take. It was about slavery. Of course the north wasnt interested in war over slavery. The south WAS and they started it. If you read the individual states declarations they also state slavery and white supremacy as the overriding cause. When discussing states rights they were primarily angry at the northern states exercising their rights by refusing to return runaway slaves and by refusing to allow slaves to be returned to bondage after slaveholders brought them north for travel. Of course you can abstract it all away by saying it was "economics" but the economics in question are the economics of slavery. The states rights are the rights as they pertain to slavery. It was slavery.
- coldtea 6y ago>What a shit take What a polite comment. >It was about slavery. Of course the north wasnt interested in war over slavery. That's kind of my whole point. The North wasn't interested in war over slavery, and the war wasn't about emancipating slaves rhetoric. It was about the North conflicting with the South over economic operation, interests, and state control. Slavery just happened to be the way that was expressed in the South, so it became the contentiuous issue, but as a second order effect.
- breakyerself 6y agoNobody argues that the north went to war with the south to end slavery. You're arguing against a strawman. The south went to war against the north to preserve slavery and white supremacy. Abstracting it away to be about them having dissimilar economies is just apologetics for an obscenity.
- JackFr 6y agoIt was slavery. It was slavery. It was slavery. (The states’ rights to maintain slavery.) It was slavery. (The expansion of slavery into new territory.) It was entirely about slavery.
- coldtea 6y agoThe consensus among European historians (that don't have to tow the party line and be "patriotic" about it) was that slavery was just a pretext. That is, if by "it was slavery" anybody means: - "the North cared for the welfare of blacks and wanted to save them from slavery and went to war for it" as opposed to: "the Northern interests wanted to take away that advantage/economic mode from the South and the westward expansion states". The rest are nice stories to tell to children to make them feel patriotic and proud. The US continued being racist and seggragated just fine, including the "all caring" North for another century (or more).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- simplemen 6y agoMy school had British coursework. History textbooks clearly said it was about slavery.
- JackFr 6y agoYou’ve been had. The American South was corrupted by a pervasive evil system from which it has still not fully recovered. You’re talking points echo “the Lost Cause” a 160+ year concerted effort to rehabilitate the history Of the antebellum South through obfuscation, misdirection and half-truths. I’d recommend https://www.amazon.com/Myth-Lost-Cause-South-Fought/dp/1621574547 https://www.amazon.com/Myth-Lost-Cause-South-Fought/dp/16215...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The consensus among European historians (that don't have to tow the party line and be "patriotic" about it) was that slavery was just a pretext. I see no evidence of this consensus; could you present some? > That is, if by "it was slavery" anybody means: > - "the North cared for the welfare of blacks and wanted to save them from slavery and went to war for it" > as opposed to: > "the Northern interests wanted to take away that advantage/economic mode from the South and the westward expansion states". Er, neither of those is the reason. It was about slavery in the sense of “The South issued articles of secession because of fears that the long-term arc of history in the Union was toward abolition.” The North was concerned with preserving the Union. The war was about slavery for the South, who started it, not the North.
- MartinCron 6y agoI get it. You feel special and smart being contrarian. You kind of proved my point.
- coldtea 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem much? >You kind of proved my point Yes, it's called confirmation bias.
- SkyMarshal 6y ago>The tie with slavery is all about the economy Yes except you're getting cause and effect reversed. The fundamental building block of the Southern economy was slavery, as your own quoted excerpts explain. Take that away and their economy would collapse, along with the extremely comfortable plantation lifestyles of the Southern elite. Their economy depended on slavery, not the other way around. When slavery was threatened, they went to war to preserve it. I'm from the South, we were taught in high-school that it was about economics, but later in life I realized that, for the South, slavery was the economy, and the root cause of the Civil War. Southerners have to be honest about that, or they'll never be able to fully move on.
- coldtea 6y ago>Their economy depended on slavery, not the other way around. When slavery was threatened, they went to war to preserve it. Of course. That doesn't make it a war about slavery, it makes a war about a threatened economic advantage. In fact, I agree further with you: the South did fight for slavery both as an economic advantage and as a racist ideology. My issue is with the notion that the Civil War cause as it comes to the North was about the emancipation of the slaves - which I consider cant. It was about economy and control from the Northern side.
- dontreact 6y agoI would advise you that this is not how you are coming off in this discussion. You sound like you are arguing that the civil war was not about slavery.
- dontreact 6y agoYeah you are trying to reframe from your original position “The civil war wasn’t about slavery” To “From the perspective of the north the primary motivation was not slavery” And it’s not convincing to me or to others. The big picture here: was the civil war about slavery? I think the answer is yes, what about you?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> My issue is with the notion that the Civil War cause as it comes to the North There's no serious dispute about that; preserving the Union was the overt aim, and there were slave states in the Union, who clearly weren't fighting against slavery.
- sp332 6y agoTry reading any of the confederate states' articles of secession. https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/declaration-causes-seceding-states https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/declarati... GA: The prohibition of slavery in the Territories, hostility to it everywhere, the equality of the black and white races, disregard of all constitutional guarantees in its favor, were boldly proclaimed by its leaders and applauded by its followers.... We refuse to submit to that judgment, and in vindication of our refusal we offer the Constitution of our country and point to the total absence of any express power to exclude us. MS: Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery SC: This sectional combination for the submersion of the Constitution, has been aided in some of the States by elevating to citizenship, persons who, by the supreme law of the land, are incapable of becoming citizens; and their votes have been used to inaugurate a new policy, hostile to the South, and destructive of its beliefs and safety. TX: We hold as undeniable truths that the governments of the various States, and of the confederacy itself, were established exclusively by the white race, for themselves and their posterity; that the African race had no agency in their establishment; that they were rightfully held and regarded as an inferior and dependent race, and in that condition only could their existence in this country be rendered beneficial or tolerable.
- coldtea 6y ago>Try reading any of the confederate states' articles of secession. https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/declarati https://www.battlefields.org/learn/primary-sources/declarati... Those are neither here, nor there. It's not a question about whether the South wanted to continue slavery, or the North wanted to end it. It's a question about whether the North's motive was slavery (as a moral/just cause), or other considerations (like state control, economic competition), to which slavery was a secondary effect they didn't want to leave to the South.
- selimthegrim 6y agoLysander Spooner is dead. There's no need to rehash his arguments.
- ashtonkem 6y agoYou know, this is exactly what I was warning you about.
- autocorr 6y agoI'm not sure how you conclude that from even your quoted source: slavery, states' rights to own humans as property, and the westward expansion of slavery and slave-holding into the territories are all about slavery. Slavery was a root tension from the founding of the Republic with an earlier Civil War in the 1820's only staved off by the Missouri compromise. Since you are one of the top HN posters, I encourage you to read the founding documents and speeches of the Confederate States, as well as reputable historical works such as McPherson's "Battle Cry of Freedom".