5 ms·
the strange nazism aside which is bad enough I honestly think their programming philosophy sucks. Why is it sensible to configure a software in C and having to
by Barrin92 6y ago
the strange nazism aside which is bad enough I honestly think their programming philosophy sucks.
Why is it sensible to configure a software in C and having to recompile it every time I make a change? Patching software through diffs is error prone and you basically have to fiddle around with the order as to not accidentally mess up your entire program, it makes the software basically non-extensible in a sane way because there's no interface between extension and core code. The line number limits on code also incentivize spaghetti code. If you want software that sucks less you don't need fewer line numbers, you need good program structure and design.
- raspyberr 6y agoWell stuff like dwm and st should get reconfigured rarely so this doesn't matter. And it recompiles blazingly fast anyway.
- flukus 6y agoYep, my dwm re-compiles, installs and restarts faster than a theme change in gnome.
- tathougies 6y agoNazism?
- recursive 6y agoElsewhere in the thread, it's noted that they maintain a mail server that's named after some nazi stronghold or something.
- necrotic_comp 6y agoIt's probably just poor humor, but it doesn't reflect well on them.
- fossuser 6y agoI'm less likely to assume humor given what's going on in politics. You can think marxism sucks (I do) without torchlight marches and nazi naming schemes. The latter is something else.
- recursive 6y agoFWIW this was all several years ago. I don't know if the mail server still exists with the same name. And I still don't know what's wrong with a torchlight hike/march. (They call it a hike, you call it a march) It sounds like something I'd do.
- varjag 6y agoThey did Tiki torch march a couple weeks after Charlottesville, which am sure is just another unfortunate coincidence. Can happen to anyone!
- flukus 6y agoThey did it in Germany, where Charlottesville was likely a 30 second news clip that everyone forgot about. Stop with the cultural imperialism, race relations in the US are rather unique.
- varjag 6y agoI am in Europe, it was top news for many days.
- hobofan 6y agoEven unrelated to Charlottesville torch walks generally have right wing connotations, as it was a traditional show of force by the Nazis. In Germany these days you mostly see them done as right wing rallies. As one data point, here[0] you can see NPD members calling for protest holding torches (during broad daylight). [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4QUC0aXN8M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4QUC0aXN8M
- LukeShu 6y agoNot a mail server, an individual person's laptop. > these mails originate from a host called "wolfsschanze", which appears to be the laptop a certain Laslo Hunhold works from (their conf organizer?) -- the tweet in the thread that you're mentioning
- hobofan 6y agoThe same person has also given a talk on their conference with the title "OpenBSD supremacy", which seems like an oddly specific choice of words (though it could also be the result of English as a second language).
- Rotten194 6y agoI think they're referring to this?: https://twitter.com/kuschku/status/1156488420413362177 https://twitter.com/kuschku/status/1156488420413362177 disclaimer: found on Google, unsure of context / if these people are core developers, just sharing for those who like me were also confused
- arp242 6y agoIt's just a social event they did. Nothing to it. The conversation continued a bit with a discussion on what exactly what means with "cultural marxism", and it's not as bad as this snippet might make it appear. But can't add context lest people give the benefit of the doubt, ey?
- dijit 6y agoI actually like suckless software and I'm a little (lot) annoyed by the overwhelming "sides" of politics, especially the left because a lot of US tech comes from a left wing belief and sometimes people online beat me over the head with it and make me annoyed. But, to be clear, there are three things here: 1) They're doing a Tiki Torch walk, during a time when it was heavily politicised. 2) They're adapting Nazi slogans as hostnames 3) They're denigrating "Cultural Marxism". Any one of these alone I would probably defend, but 3 is a pattern and not a good one.
- arp242 6y ago> 1) They're doing a Tiki Torch walk, during a time when it was heavily politicised. No it wasn't; just in the US. Not everyone in the world is obsessed with the latest drama in the US. I've done many torchwalks with scouts. In fact, they're used to celebrate the end of the Nazi occupation in my home town every single year on Sept 18th. Should we stop doing this because some yahoos on the other side of the world used some torches in some far-right march? This is "Hitler has a moustache, you have a moustache, ergo you must be a Nazi"-kind of logic. > 2) They're adapting Nazi slogans as hostnames A private server belonging to a single person, not the project. I have asked him plainly and directly about that and he avoided the question. I am also not impressed by this, but that doesn't make him a Nazi, and it certainly doesn't make everyone involved in the project a Nazi. > 3) They're denigrating "Cultural Marxism". A single person is (same one as the hostname). And like I said, there is a lot more to that conversation than the screenshot makes it out to be as there was a lot of confusion about what's intended with "cultural marxism". I really recommend you read the entire conversation in full, and while I don't personally agree with their take, it's also really not that bad.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zarkov99 6y agoYou know, one day we might see real Nazis but we won’t have a word for them anymore.
- tathougies 6y agohttps://imgflip.com/memegenerator/Oprah-You-Get-A https://imgflip.com/memegenerator/Oprah-You-Get-A
- boogies 6y agoStrange arguable libel aside, you don’t have to compile your wm or terminal every time you make a change. There are awesomewm (and echinus and spectrwm and Qtile et al.), and xterm and GNOME Terminal and guake and konsole and xfce terminal and Terminator and Terminology and Tilda and Yakuake and rxvt et al., many al.: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/List_of_applications/Utilities#Terminal_emulators https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/List_of_applications/Ut.... Setting all those aside, you can configure any decent text editor to run `make` whenever you save, and I dare you to find any combination of patches for any single suckless software (except surf) that takes more than 1000 milliseconds to compile with tcc on a computer you use on a regular basis (should work for any normal desk/laptop from the past decade or two).
- Spivak 6y agoYeah, I'm not really sure if DRYing yourself to death is a good approach to software development. Ansible is really really easy to hack on and it's ~1.2mil LOC which probably horrifies the suckless devs.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoI suspect a good deal of that 1.2M lines is in modules, isn't it? Rather like how people remark on how many lines are in Linux and overlook that it's overwhelmingly in drivers and the actual core system is much smaller.
- alex_smart 6y agoHave you even taken a look at their source code? I have read plenty of open source projects and suckless's code is about as unspaghettilike as it gets. I find their approach to programming a beautiful contrast to the piles of garbage upon other piles of garbage style over-engineered approach I have seen elsewhere.
- drhastings 6y agoHave you tried it? I've not experienced any of those problems while using dwm for the past several years. Where I wasn't able to find an existing diff supporting my desired customizations I found the code easy to understand and extend myself. Find me some spaghetti code in the codebase and your point might be a little more convincing to me.
- passivate 6y agoI think you're pointing out procedural issues, but ultimately the proof is in the pudding. If what they're doing works for them, then its pretty hard to convince them otherwise. It would be easier to make your case if you could point out specifics.