2 ms·
Software freedom requires the freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose. That includes the freedom and right to connect to Theo de Raat's private
by aidenn0 6y ago
Software freedom requires the freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose. That includes the freedom and right to connect to Theo de Raat's private SSH server. Theo de Raat restricts that freedom, violating the spirit of free software. End of story. My car analogy is irrelevant.
OpenSSH is open source, but not free software. That just shows how open source misses the point.
I can fill in the above template with GNU's CVS servers in the 90s, if you prefer GPL to BSD.
- anoncake 6y agoYou are not prohibited from connecting to Theo de Raat's private SSH server using OpenSSH. You are prohibited from connecting to Theo de Raat's private SSH server. The client has nothing to with it.
- aidenn0 6y agoBut if Theo were to grant me access, but disallow e.g. putty, that would be well within his rights, no?
- anoncake 6y agoNo, what software you use is none of his business.
- aidenn0 6y agoWhat software I use is none of his business right up until it starts affecting computers he owns. This isn't that complicated. If I decide that I don't want people wearing red shirts to enter my house, then that's stupid, but within my rights and does not meaningfully infringe upon your right to wear whatever color shirt you want. I don't see how restrictions on what is allowed to connect to privately run servers can magically cause software to become non-free. Nor do I see any way in which those restrictions existing (again on computers neither you nor I own) in any way violates the spirit of free software or in any way denies you and I the freedoms that free software is supposed to respect.
- anoncake 6y agoYour house, a personal area, is in no way comparable to a public messenger network. > What software I use is none of his business right up until it starts affecting computers he owns. Which client implementing the Signal protocol you use does not affect him, therefore it's none of his business.