4 ms·
If you want to also have a WiFi access point, besides an Ethernet switch/router, there are 2 choices. You can use an Intel NUC or similar, which has the perfec
by adrian_b 6y ago
If you want to also have a WiFi access point, besides an Ethernet switch/router, there are 2 choices.
You can use an Intel NUC or similar, which has the perfectly supported and high-speed Intel WiFi, together with several USB to Ethernet adapters, to have both a WiFi AP and multiple Ethernet ports. That is what I am currently using.
Or, for a cheaper device, you can use Odroid H2 or something similar, with an USB WiFi dongle, taking care to select a model that has WiFi drivers for whatever operating system you use.
- rektide 6y agoi should try a more modern intel wifi chip, yes, but in my experience these _client_ wifi chips make really limited access points, with not good range, and most noticably have critical/severe/cripplingly bad performance with multiple clients. many usb chipsets straight up refuse to allow more than a handful of clients. i think my Alfa wireless usb kit with realtek chipsets refuse more than 7 connections. other kit just has multi-second jitter creep in every now and then, in a relatively un-hostile wifi environment. it absolutely 100% _should_ be possible & easy & work well to do either of these options. perhaps with current gen modern chipsets things are better. here, alas, things fail again, because it seems many modern wifi chipsets don't have available linux drivers at all, much less competent ap mode drivers. "good silicon with bad drivers is just expensive sand" go to a reliable respected wifi vendor like rokland[1] and look around: how many of these devices are <2 years old? <3 years old? many of the best sellers are 5+ years old. good wifi is becoming frighteningly scarce. this is very common advice you've presented, but i've found it to be woefully critically unacceptable. just incredibly bad wifi. we are doing a mis-service to people telling them these are ok options. i've tried real hard to make these work, across years, bought dozens of devices, & it's been unbelievably unsatisfactory. i would strongly recommend against taking @adrian_b's listed options, in emphatic terms. do not do this to yourself. but please, make this a future we can do. as i begged for, please, we need some folks like Compex putting modern product on the market unbundled. we need some drivers. for modern wifi. that we can use. please. please. [1] https://store.rokland.com/ https://store.rokland.com/
- stragies 6y agoRealtek and Broadcom are both also in my "Don't even consider"-List for most uses because of the extremely bad driver situation with both of them. Intel Wifi joined this list for most use-cases. I'm quite happy with my atheros chips (various QCA9XXX) and the mediatek chips (in the modes, where the driver doesn't crash hard)
- adrian_b 6y agoIt depends on what kind of WiFi you need. You are probably right about the problems with many clients, I would not know. While I have a network with more than a dozen computers, most are wired and I seldom connect through WiFi more than a single laptop. In this use case, I did not have problems, and I much prefer to use as router a computer over which I have complete control instead of some appliance that does whatever it wants, but I have not tried to see what happens with many WiFi clients in this configuration, because I have not needed that.
- stragies 6y agoDoes Intel really have chips in 2021 that can finally support standards like 802.11s(mesh) (finalized 10+ years ago) and RSN-IBSS with SAE/WPA3 using encryption with MTU allowing encapsulating standard 1500 ethernet, on 5Ghz, along with the basic boring modes like AP/VLAN, station? Atheros and Mediatek do this out of the box, since years, on mainline kernels. Unfortunatelly, distributions usually compile wpa_supplicant without MESH support, at least Debian does (or did). So many people don't actually realize, how crippled these Intel Wifi cards are. Especially, now that kernel 5.5 removed the "disable_lar" (Used to enable AP-on-5GHz) module option. I'm expecting a lot of disappointed customers dumping their Intel cards on the second hand market soon.
- puzzlingcaptcha 6y agoLast time I checked, Intel consumer wi-fi cards would not even let you do AP on 5GHz (the entire spectrum was marked No-IR in firmware regardless of regulatory domain with no way to override it). But this was a while ago, I'd be also curious to know if they came to their senses. https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000030429/network-and-i-o/wireless.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000...
- stragies 6y agoThe "disable_lar" option enabled "iw reg set" to override what the eeprom stupidly forbids, until linux kernel-version 5.5, when the nice people @Intel removed the option without an alternative, that doesn't mark your kernel as tainted. (If I'm wrong, and you/somebody knows a way to re-enable AP-on-5GHz-on-Linux-5.5+ for iwlwifi on signed distribution kernels without Out-Of-Tree Taint, please comment) And on top it they refuse to release support for 802.11s mesh! Even for 2.4GHz!
- rektide 6y agoI'm curious how many of the new commercial home wifi mesh systems out there use 802.11s. A couple of years, I'd been under the impression that many folk in wifi mesh land were using BATMAN or Babel or one of the two dozen other routing protocols[1]. OLPC was the last big 802.11s user that I knew of, and I never heard glowing reviews, but that was a decade ago. I'm curious how things are shaping up these days. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_mesh_network#Routing_protocols https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_mesh_network#Routing_...