3 ms·
> I very much doubt that that is true. I think the speech part should always be 100% free. Of course any crimes that derive from it are and will always been ful
by mlyle 6y ago
> I very much doubt that that is true. I think the speech part should always be 100% free. Of course any crimes that derive from it are and will always been fully enforceable. I just question whether or not the speech itself should be viewed as illegal,
So would you say, for instance, that we should be able to do an unlimited amount of discussion, planning, and coordination of an elected official's death. And it's only when one person takes a concrete action towards the plan that they should anyone be able to be arrested, and only that person? Because the rest is all protected speech?
- datahead 6y agoI found this [1] breakdown helpful to understand the legal position of this hypothetical. > unlimited [...] discussion, planning and coordination turns into evidence once "intent" and an "overt act" thresholds are crossed, for all involved. [1] https://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/conspiracy.html https://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-charges/conspiracy.htm...
- mlyle 6y agoYes, this would certainly be naughty under current law, but perhaps not in a legal regime where "all speech is OK!" Note that the overt act need not be committed by the speaker, too. There's even ambiguity about elements of this in current law. If one were to advocate for the violent overthrow of the government, and begin running training exercises to help people prepare to overthrow the government at some unspecified future date--- it is unclear whether this is protected by the First Amendment. SCOTUS mentioned -- but did not address -- this problem in Stewart v McCoy (2002): ... While the requirement that the consequence be “imminent” is justified with respect to mere advocacy, the same justification does not necessarily adhere to some speech that performs a teaching function. As our cases have long identified, the First Amendment does not prevent restrictions on speech that have “clear support in public danger.” Thomas v. Collins, 323 U.S. 516, 530 (1945). Long range planning of criminal enterprises–which may include oral advice, training exercises, and perhaps the preparation of written materials–involves speech that should not be glibly characterized as mere “advocacy” and certainly may create significant public danger. Our cases have not yet considered whether, and if so to what extent, the First Amendment protects such instructional speech. Our denial of certiorari in this case should not be taken as an endorsement of the reasoning of the Court of Appeals.... https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/02-20.ZA.html https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/02-20.ZA.html
- mlyle 6y agoAlso please note the overt act rule re: conspiracy isn't necessarily the law with respect to incitement or in all jurisdictions.
- dmitrygr 6y agoThere are already laws for the situation you describe. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/conspiracy https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/conspiracy