3 ms·
Free speech is not the only virtue. We promote free speech to the head of the list because we believe that free speech helps us fix the other issues. (You can
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
Free speech is not the only virtue. We promote free speech to the head of the list because we believe that free speech helps us fix the other issues. (You can't address moral problem X if you can't even talk about X.)
But what if free speech isn't helping? What if free speech is spreading lies far more than truth? What if free speech is poisoning the discourse instead of enlightening it?
In current context, what if free speech is being used to spread lies that are causing violence? Do you take away the liars' megaphone, or let them keep it?
But, steelmanning a response to myself:
For every case where lies are being spread severely enough to cause harm that warrants censorship, there are some large number N of claims that some speech crosses the line and needs to be censored. Almost anything you say can get someone upset, and they can claim that you should be censored. And liars lie, and one of the things they lie about is whether their opponents are lying. When people decide that social media should censor, they're giving powerful, connected, and/or manipulative people a bigger gun to attack their opponents with. Don't think that gun won't be (mis)used. And that misuse will exactly harm the public discourse - which protecting that discourse was the rationale for the censorship.