3 ms·
Or I don't know, SBC vendors, you can get one AMD R1606G board and actually bother to make its 2x 10Gbps on-chip NICs usable? As opposed to everyone attaching 2
by pdimitar 6y ago
Or I don't know, SBC vendors, you can get one AMD R1606G board and actually bother to make its 2x 10Gbps on-chip NICs usable? As opposed to everyone attaching 2x 1Gbps to it for whatever reasons (really tempted to say its laziness but maybe there are legitimate reasons, although I don't think so; why would AMD make a board on which an on-chip dual NIC is unusable?).
Piling such addons on top of an otherwise single-board computer feels quite strange to me. What are the thermal implications of such a setup?
Not an expert by any stretch but I am very skeptical.
- rektide 6y agoI very very very much loath the lag in the market. The SBC market is a sham, as far as I'm concerned, with these stupid ARM toys they keep pushing. 100%, the real embedded market has much better equipment. I looked around some for R1606G offerings, and there's quite a number of boards around $350. Alas, none use the on-chip 10Gbe ports. I haven't found anything under $700 that offers 10Gbe. Even the $350 is questionable, when by compare one can get a 1L sized mini-pc with a 35W desktop chip that will rip it to shreads. Those systems will idle under 10w. Mine does. The R1606G chip you talk about, the R1606G, is 2 Zen cores running 2600-3500 Hz & uses 12-25W. That's a bit north of what something like this here Celeron kicks out, but it does match a lot of Chromebox style computers very closely, which is a little smaller than the typical business 1L mini-pc. There is also a R1305G and R1102G which have lower clocks & single-channel in the R1102G's case. They also have dual 10Gbe. I'd love to know what price chips like these come at. I suspect AMD plays the same game Intel does: even though you are getting 1/8th the physical chip size versus a desktop, the fact that it has competitive performance in it's price range means AMD/Intel are still going to try & charge you the same ~$300 they'd charge for a desktop chip.
- pdimitar 6y agoSame experience here with the R1606G. I got very hyped when I have seen the performance and power usage... and then NOBODY offered it with the stock dual 10Gbe NICs. Do you have a link to the full specs of your system that idles under 10W? Quite amazing. My OptiPlex 3060 (the micro form factor, no bigger than a book) is likely idling like that as well but haven't measured yet (hey, any recommendations for "smart" power monitors that can be aggregated in a central dashboard?). Also, do you have links to R1606G setups with 10Gbe somewhere? Your comment made it seem like you did eventually find such setups. Don't care much if they are $700 or more, it will be a one-time investment for at least 5 years in the future. The lower-clocked Ryzen 1000 boards I didn't have much interest in. I am looking to build a super low-power home NAS with the R1606G, plus some light VM and Docker activities. And yeah, pretty sure somebody recognized how valuable these boards are and are charging arm and leg for them. :(