3 ms·
The success of iMessage and the entire Apple ecosystem in the US proves that a walled garden is exactly what people trust and want and are willing to pay handso
by ChuckNorris89 6y ago
The success of iMessage and the entire Apple ecosystem in the US proves that a walled garden is exactly what people trust and want and are willing to pay handsomely for the privilege of being part of one.
Interoperability/Federation is something the average user doesn't understand and won't even bother too as long as their basic needs are already comfortably fulfilled.
Seriously, get out of the tech bubble for a while and see that most people have no idea what the brand of their computer is or what their OS is called and they don't even care. They just want to click the internet icon and start browsing memes, play candy crush or watch youtube.
Even my young friends who are mechanical/civil engineers and make good money don't see any issue in having personal information in the hands of Facebook and Google controlled services or any other free on-line services who make a living by monetizing your personal data. They either think people are over-reacting about this, as like, if they were truly evil, the gov. would shut them down or for them it's just too much friction to bother readjusting their lifestyle to something else and prefer the comfort provided by these companies.
- pseudalopex 6y agoYou think the average user doesn't understand email?
- kitkat_new 6y agoImagine only being able to - email to the same email provider - phone only to the same telco provider - access a website through a dedicated browser - ... Still don't understand and bother?
- rglullis 6y agoThis a false dichotomy. There is nothing about interoperable/federated systems that make it harder for people to fulfill their needs. Or have we already forgot how to make a phone call (interoperable) or send an email (federated) in less than a generation?
- legacynl 6y ago>The success of iMessage and the entire Apple ecosystem in the US proves that a walled garden is exactly what people trust and want and are willing to pay handsomely for the privilege of being part of one. People don't care about open, closed or whatever. They care about being able to send a message to others. If only 10 % of your friends are on signal, but 100% are on iMessage, most will just use iMessage. So the success of iMessage (and the apple stonewall) is arguably just the success of the iPhone. > Seriously, get out of the tech bubble for a while and see that most people have no idea what computer brand they have or what their OS is called and they don't even care. They just want to click the internet icon and start browsing memes, play candy crush or watch youtube. You're basically making exactly my point. They don't care, they want to be able to browse, message, play, watch stuff, etc. They also wouldn't care if their messaging app would support different protocols, as long as they're just able to easily message their friends. > Interoperability/Federation is something the average user doesn't understand and won't even bother too as long as their basic needs are already comfortably fulfilled. This is why it would be incredibly helpful for a big app to start supporting different protocols. If signal becomes THE app for connecting with friends (no matter if they use icq, irc, email, jabber, etc), it might come to a point where people rather use Signal, because that's the app that can reach ALL your friends. At this point, iMessage would either die, or also start to support open protocols. (Or more likely: Apple will ban messaging apps from the app-store)
- Ayesh 6y agoI think this is quite true. Even with federated/distributed architecture like web and email, many of the emails are on Google Apps (or whatever they call it these days), Office 365, or a few other services. Many web sites are on WordPress.com, GitHub pages, or platforms like AWS or GCP.