3 ms·
Removing offensive content is the laziest possible solution and it's funny how quickly Facebook and Twitter reverted to it once this solution was again on the t
by scotty79 6y ago
Removing offensive content is the laziest possible solution and it's funny how quickly Facebook and Twitter reverted to it once this solution was again on the table.
Most interesting part of all of this was what they did before, when they couldn't just delete the content.
They had to properly fact-check it and educate the viewers. I think this should be the default mode for stupid (counter-factual) opinions. I know it's hard but you are not the richest companies for nothing. Figure it out.
I think letting platforms just delete whatever causes an outrage is delaying the moment when we will finally get these kinds of things presented with proper fact based context instead of surrounded by ads and links to similarly stupid speech.
- netsharc 6y agoThe defeatist in me wonders if education is possible. It seems a lot of people just refuse to accept things that disgree with their world view and dismiss the source as part of the conspiracy. I wondered if it'd be possible to make a honeypot website that would pretend to be some internal Pfizer website, or the Gates foundation, or the DNC, but fill it with content that would actually educate the conspiracy theorists, for example about how mRNA vaccine works, or how a Biden administration won't be forcing "fascism" down their throats. At least they'd be hopefully diligently reading stuff and learning while looking for smoking guns.
- scotty79 6y ago> It seems a lot of people just refuse to accept things that disgree with their world view and dismiss the source as part of the conspiracy. More educated people are less likely to do that. Also people who have no financial incentives to propagate such falsehoods are less likely to propagate it. Flat earther movement is a good example. Some members made a business out of it to advance their personal goals. Like the guy that launched himself in a rocket to "check if earth is flat", but actually just liked lunching himself in rockets and similar things (had history of that), and claimed to believe in flat earth so that gullible people pay his bill. We can't resign ourselves to defeatism and think that nothing can be done because people are stupid and ideas are toxic. Yes, some people are stupider and some ideas are more toxic then others but we shouldn't let that cloud the simple fact that we allow to exist the multitude of positive force feedbacks that promote more toxic ideas and more stupid people. We should work on those things first. > I wondered if it'd be possible to make a honeypot website ... Yes. We should forcibly mix those dumb ideas with solid education on the subject. Confront the two. Debunk one with the other in-place. At many different levels of complexity to reach as many people as possible. You want to post you antivaxxer theories on facebook? Sure but your readers will get solid science next to it by courtesy of Facebook algorithm instead of ads and crap similar to yours.
- codetrotter 6y ago> They had to properly fact-check it and educate the viewers. I think this should be the default mode for stupid (counter-factual) opinions. That’s unrealistic IMO. I can type out a hundred lies faster than you can fact check even one of them. Besides we’ve already seen that facts don’t matter to a lot of people. They don’t care if something is true or not anyways. All they care about is having their world views reaffirmed.
- ttt0 6y agoThere is a lot of critique that people don't read anything besides the headlines and sometimes it's suggested that this is one of the causes for the spread of misinformation. I think that Twitter even warns you before you can retweet something to make sure that you read the entire article, so you don't spread whatever they consider to be false. But there is the same problem with fact-checking. People just search for it, see the headline that it was "debunked" and assume it's not true, without reading through the actual article. Here are some of the examples of articles, that suggest the story is not true, but once you get past the headline, it basically says the opposite: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/25/trump-keeps-claiming-that-most-dangerous-cities-america-are-all-run-by-democrats-they-arent/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/06/25/trump-kee... (https://archive.md/EK0rq https://archive.md/EK0rq) https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/hillary-clinton-suppressed-haitis-minimum-wage/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/hillary-clinton-suppressed... (https://archive.md/hhWnv https://archive.md/hhWnv) https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/dems-impeach-gop-presidents/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/dems-impeach-gop-president... (http://archive.md/HNgc9 http://archive.md/HNgc9) I don't disagree that it doesn't happen, but it's not always that people just "don't care about the facts". Sometimes it's that these so-called fact-checks are - to put it bluntly - complete garbage. When there were claims about the voter fraud circulating throughout the social media and Facebook and Twitter was putting the warnings on such posts, I happened to actually read those fact-checks, and let me tell you - they weren't good. Most of the time it was either a straw man or it had nothing to do with the actual claim that was being made. People laugh at conspiracy theorists, but most of them are not any better.
- scotty79 6y ago> That’s unrealistic IMO. Just ambitious. We shouldn't let Facebook off the hook with just letting them delete inconvenient stuff. We should press them till they pay for their great power by picking up the responsibility of education. > I can type out a hundred lies faster than you can fact check even one of them. Yes, but you can't convince people of so many new different stupid things at this rate. Novel lies are rarely the problem. Most dangerous lies are not new. There's nothing new about antivaxxers for example. Trumpism works by the same rules that nazi propaganda worked. Snake oil. Flat earth. How many new lies of this level of impact can you invent and publish and can you really do it faster than people can correct you if their voices are properly amplified? > Besides we’ve already seen that facts don’t matter to a lot of people. They don’t care if something is true or not anyways. All they care about is having their world views reaffirmed. Facts don't matter to them unless they understand them. Truth matters to them immensely. That's why they hold the (wrong) beliefs they hold. They care about being right. What they lack is education in the form and on the level that could reach them. For some of them, providing them with it might be very hard. But you can't give up and just censor whatever. It doesn't work. It didn't work. What works is education.
- meragrin_ 6y ago> They had to properly fact-check it and educate the viewers. They weren't doing that. They were pushing an agenda. It was not rare to see a "false information" flag only to see the "fact-checking" article support the claim. One particular claim I saw marked false was China did not need a vaccine to keep covid under control. The article went on and on about everything other than vaccine. There were like three or four lines talking about vaccines. Those were mostly about how the Chinese weren't anti-vaccine. At the time of the "fact-checking" article, there were only about 1 million Chinese vaccinated which was still in testing. That is just a drop in the bucket compared to the total population. The source articles the "fact-checking" article linked to did not even mention vaccines. Sounds more like pushing an agenda rather than fact-checking and educating.
- scotty79 6y agoI'm not saying they were doing it perfectly. But at least they were trying to do something to address the root cause that people are gullible. You can't ban publishing lies because that's what more than half of human culture is. The thing you can and should do is put dangerous lies in factual context.