3 ms·
I really dislike this submission (flagged). It's facile humour, but only just barely funny. I found myself wishing people who upvoted it could be banished. But
by barrkel 16y ago
I really dislike this submission (flagged). It's facile humour, but only just barely funny. I found myself wishing people who upvoted it could be banished. But that thought gave me another.
What would a layering / segmentation of HN users look like? Imagine the voting history of HN users on certain types of articles was used to classify them, and each classification of user saw a version of HN customized to only users of their classification, including front page articles, comment and new submissions, in a transparent way similar to hell-banning?
Probably too elitist and conducive to groupthink, but worth an idle ponder.
- trotsky 16y agoOne of the things I like about HN is being exposed to ideas and projects outside of my usual circles of interest, things that don't show up in my RSS or twitter feeds. I'm pretty sure any segmentation system like that would just spit my narrow interests back at me. I didn't find the link to be worth much, but it also took almost no time to read. It is hard for me to imagine any aggregator not having some poor content for any given reader, even if a filter was employed.
- barrkel 16y agoI'm not so sure it would be the case, as it depends on what is being filtered for, but as I said, groupthink... At this point, one of HN's problems is simply scale; cities are qualitatively different to villages. Reddit has sub-reddits, but that just stages things explicitly. I wondered if something more subtle could work.
- jotto 16y agoTED talk on this. guy calls it a "filter bubble": http://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bubbles.html http://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bu... TL;DW: filter bubbles/group think might be bad for a functioning democracy because functioning democracies rely on good information
- Sandman 16y agoThe submission itself is probably not HN-worthy. But it spawned an interesting discussion.