3 ms·
Yes, but at least this turns the light off and the light is stuck off (and can't be turned back on by software even if they decide to stop listening).
by mlyle 6y ago
Yes, but at least this turns the light off and the light is stuck off (and can't be turned back on by software even if they decide to stop listening).
- aeternum 6y agoSure but it's still a bad design. If the device ever loses power, or restarts for any reason while the mute is engaged an informed user must accept a non-zero probability that their privacy was invaded. I have wireless headphones that work like this and it's a terrible design. If they go out of range temporarily, they unmute. It makes the 'hardware' mute functionality absolutely useless since it cannot be relied upon to stay muted.
- mlyle 6y agoShort of a switch that is sticky when powered off, or a design that comes up muted... or excessive wizardry to persist state, this is non-negotiable, though.
- aeternum 6y agoPhysical switches for mute are underrated, think of all the conference call time that could be saved (and embarrassing moments avoided) if laptops had physical mute switches.
- ashtonkem 6y agoSlider switch solves this problem. They're well known for maintaining their state between reboots.
- astura 6y ago>switch that is sticky when powered off This is a long solved problem, a lever switch. Laptops (usually enterprise laptops) sometimes have them to turn on/off wireless communication. https://ux.stackexchange.com/questions/34956/who-needs-an-external-on-off-wi-fi-button/34958 https://ux.stackexchange.com/questions/34956/who-needs-an-ex...