3 ms·
The point about the rain example is that it's meant to be something on which there's a clear truth, a demonstrable truth. In this sense it differs dramatically
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
The point about the rain example is that it's meant to be something on which there's a clear truth, a demonstrable truth. In this sense it differs dramatically from most of the important issues before us as a society. But it's precisely because of this that it gets raised as one end of a spectrum:
what does/should journalism do when there's a clear demonstrable truth but "some people" dispute it?
That doesn't provide a guide for how to handle cases where the truth is not clear, where there is obviously legitimate grounds for disagreement.
But it's supposed to mark one of the spectrum. Many people would say that journalism has failed badly at the end of the spectrum, by taking things that are clearly true ("it's raining") and behaving as if the skeptics deserve to be heard.
Obviously, the skeptics feel otherwise, but is that relevant and if so, how much attention should we pay it?
- donw 6y agoJournalists are in the business of providing narratives, which may or may not be loosely based on an objective truth they met somewhere a few years ago at a cafe. I'm pretty sure this has always been so. > Obviously, the skeptics feel otherwise, but is that relevant and if so, how much attention should we pay it? Again, this depends on your goals.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoTo be honest, my goals used to be to convince other people. As I get closer to 60, I'm swinging more towards simply acquiring and exercising power on behalf of things I believe in. I say this despite an ironic awareness of how much I despise a movement with opposite ideals to my own for appearing to do the same thing over the last 3-4 decades.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI appreciate your honesty and sincerity, genuinely.
- throwaway894345 6y agoWhy fixate on this extreme when there are plenty of subjective issues where journalists could present multiple interpretations? And why do journalists so rarely call left wing denialism (e.g., blank slatism) or even something a little murkier like the propensity to impute discrimination on every disparity? No one is asking you to argue that the Trump position is equally meritorious to the left wing position, but if you want to bring Trump supporters back into the fold or at least reduce the rate that you’re creating them, then giving them some courtesy representation here and there in the media if only to explain why their points of view are misinformed might not be a bad approach. In general, respect consistently and earnestly applied can be a pretty potent thing.