5 ms·
Tell me how this is wrong: The US is de facto converting to the Chinese model for the internet: All communication must be monitored, damaging content must be e
by BurningFrog 6y ago
Tell me how this is wrong:
The US is de facto converting to the Chinese model for the internet: All communication must be monitored, damaging content must be erased, and in serious cases, those responsible must be punished.
If Parler gets a foreign data center, I expect a "Great Firewall of China" with American characteristics will soon follow.
- root_axis 6y agoFacebook is not a country, it's a website, trying to characterize Facebook's business decisions as U.S policy is a dishonest rhetorical tactic.
- dcolkitt 6y agoHonest question: Is Facebook doing this out of genuine business interest? Or because they're concerned about legal and/or regulatory backlash?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- grzm 6y agoWhat’s the difference? Business interests include mitigating legal and regulatory exposure.
- dcolkitt 6y agoBecause the latter would definitely be a form of government censorship. In fact it's essentially how most censorship in Russia, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey work. If you tell a newspaper that they'll be regulated out of existence if they publish a certain opinion, it doesn't matter that the private platform is the one doing the censoring.
- grzm 6y agoThere's always a risk of bad laws and bad regulations. And certainly we need to be vigilant and correct and improve them when they occur (and they most certainly do). Laws and regulation are not necessarily censorship. It's important to have transparency into how laws and regulations are developed and applied, but that's a separate issue.
- bun_at_work 6y agoHonest question: What happens to Facebook if the government that rules it collapses?
- dcolkitt 6y agoHonest question: What is your probability estimate that the government of the United States collapses or is overthrown? Keep in mind that the S&P 500 is near record highs, which would be a tad irrational if we're on the verge anarchy implosion. If you honestly believe there's even the slightest risk of that, why aren't you buying deep out-of-the-money put options like mad.
- bun_at_work 6y agoWhat is this question? First - I don't have a probability estimate. I simply recognize the fact that some significant part of the populating tried to overthrow the government. Second, you should be careful conflating Wall Street with the stability of the country. That's not how our monetary policy or economic system work.
- cambalache 6y ago> Facebook is not a country Facebook 2019 revenue was 71 billion or so, which would put it at number 70 worldwide if it were a country. Maybe we should start to treat it like one.
- root_axis 6y agoI don't follow your reasoning. Should we treat every billion dollar company as a country or just websites?
- cambalache 6y agoIf you are such a juggernaut maybe you cannot hide anymore behind the "we are a private company so we can do whatever we want" defense. At 70 billion revenue your impact in society is huge, you are effectively affecting millions of humans.
- root_axis 6y ago> maybe you cannot hide anymore behind the "we are a private company so we can do whatever we want" defense No such defense exists. Should we treat every billion dollar company as a country?
- cambalache 6y ago> No such defense exists No such defense exists? Have you read this site every time a new wave of social media cancellations happen? After every credit card processing company ban a group of polemical people? "They are a private company they can decide what to do" Well, maybe if you are extracting 70 billion a year from society it is not that simple as "I can decide who to do business with" I think the government would be very interested to initiate an investigation if Shell decided to not fill your tank because they discovered you are a neo-Keynesian, even if there is a Chevron station 3 miles away.
- root_axis 6y ago
- BurningFrog 6y agoThis is why I said "de facto". I'm not implying the US government was behind this. I'm suggesting that the end results in US and China are similar in some ways, though implemented by different actors.
- root_axis 6y agoNo, the result is not even remotely similar. This is an individual company removing content from their own website based on their own prerogatives, not a country-wide ban where citizens risk imprisonment or worse if they violate the rules. The differences are so incredibly vast that I'm struggling to believe you're actually making this argument in good faith.
- bun_at_work 6y agoIt's wrong because you're conflating the US private companies with the Chinese government.
- nip180 6y agoThe results on limiting discussions are largely the same if it’s done by the government or done by corporations.
- jrockway 6y agoI think there's quite a step from "don't use AWS to plot a violent overthrow of the United States Government" to all communication being monitored and a firewall blocking foreign sources. Why should Facebook and Amazon use their resources to help this cause?
- nip180 6y agoI think it’s quite a step to say all comments with the phrase Stop the steal want to overthrow the government. We, as a society, should be allowed to be very critical of our election process. Stifling discussions about the legitimacy of the election actually reduces my confidence in the election process. I’ve listen to their arguments and I didn’t believe them, but I feel good that people are allowed to do openly question election process and I trust the American people to make rational decisions about what constitutes a fair election.
- jrockway 6y agoI don't think anyone is stopping you from discussing the electoral process. What they are stopping is a specific campaign that transitioned from questioning to violence. The violence is the problem. You have to accept that there is a difference between questioning the results of an election and walking into the Capitol, killing a cop, and wrecking the place up. "The line" on what gets you deplatformed exists somewhere between those two points.
- benmmurphy 6y agoCan you explain how this rule is meant to work? So if someone supports an idea and then commits violence then discussion of this idea should be removed from the public square. I don't see any evidence that the 'stop the steal' campaign organized the violence in the Capitol. This just seems to be a game of association. A bunch of people who committed illegal violent acts believe X, people using the slogan Y also believe X so any use of slogan Y should be removed from the public square. It looks like the original reason the 'stop the steal' page was removed from Facebook was for 'misinformation' and now they are blacklisting the slogan because it's associated with 'misinformation' and they also believe that talking about such things causes violence.
- courtf 6y agoThis is bonkers, plainly so. You are really not expecting anyone to be able to demonstrate that? There's thousands of sites, readily accessible today, with incredible images and posts containing all the most heinous things you can imagine. No firewall yet, although they have been chased off the more polite sections of the web. This is no different. I'm confused by all the hyperventilating.
- logicslave 6y agoYup this is coming. The "slippery slope" is real and recent actions confirm it. This is scary and these actions are unprecedented. The USA has never seen such restrictions on free speech in its history
- lern_too_spel 6y agoNewspapers regularly decline to publish letters to the editor from loonies trying to organize a coup. What is unprecedented is giving these loonies a huge platform that helps them find like-minded loonies to organize while keeping them in an information bubble that shields them from corrections.
- istjohn 6y agoYet we never opened mail to protect society from loonies trying to organize a coup. We never censored phone calls. Social media is the modern mode of communication, and just because we can censor speech online doesn't mean we should. Free speech has always meant tolerating repelent speech.
- lern_too_spel 6y ago> Yet we never opened mail to protect society from loonies trying to organize a coup. We never censored phone calls. It would be prohibitively expensive to find enough like-minded loonies to organize a coup using telemarketing or physical mail marketing, and the act of doing so would annoy enough people that you would get shut down anyway. Deplatforming dangerous loonies on Facebook and Twitter is not a new thing. It already happened with ISIS.
- pfundstein 6y agoWhat's with all the loonies in here? A private company censoring content on its platform is well within its rights, especially when that content conflicts with the company's policies. This has literally nothing to do with freedom of speech.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- incrudible 6y agoYou're putting the cart before the horse. No government body ordered any of this. Trump approval remains at 40%, that's more than enough to build counter-platforms for literally everything. I would like to welcome this as an opportunity to break the power of major tech corporations and move towards open platforms. Unfortunately, the trend seems to be towards closed platforms that are simply echo chambers of a different persuasion.
- subsubzero 6y agoI think you are heading in the right direction here. I think the difference is that today large US tech companies have a complete stranglehold over online speech and large parts of the internet infrastructure(email, web services, consumer electronics). So instead of the CCP saying a site is transmitting harmful lies(and is shut down), its now a close knit group of tech oligarchies deeming what speech is and is not permissible. If Parler were to try and get a foreign data center expect Goog, FB and the others to try to bully that country (we will remove offices in your country if you do not shut it down) or pressuring internet providers to block that countries traffic.
- CodeArtisan 6y agoHong-Kong rioters and Capitol rioters both protested against a democratically elected government (or soon to be) but the former were called dissidents and got the support of USA tech corps[1] while the latter are called terrorists and are heavily censored. These tech corps are full of bullshit and shall not be trusted when it come to democracy or free internet. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/07/business/hong-kong-security-law-tech.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/07/business/hong-kong-securi...
- n00bsaretheb3st 6y agoDon't worry daddy zucc decides who is a good government and who is a bad one and facebook can be used to facilitate violent protests against.
- noahtallen 6y agoI would offer two counter examples: 1. It is individuals and individual companies making these decisions, it is not federally required. (And if it was federally mandated, I’m sure impropriety could be handled by the courts.) 2. Companies are censoring the president, one of the main actors of the federal government. This is hugely different from the Chinese model, where the Chinese government restricts things which are negative towards the government among other things. At any rate, I’m sure many of the technical reasons are legitimate. For example, does AWS permit you to host bounty-hunting sites, where you could be paid to kill others? I doubt it, and I imagine many people support that stance, even if they do not support kicking Parler. So we admit that some censorship is ok and even beneficial. Therefore, what’s the line? Is it content which is promoting literal illegal activity? Content that likely will lead to illegal actions? If that’s the case, then perhaps we should be advocating that these rules ought to be applied more evenly to even more types of sites and content. Or, perhaps the rules are applied evenly, and there have simply not been many other similar cases regarding AWS which have gained popularity. Or, maybe AWS should enforce no rules whatsoever. Then they could become a haven for criminal sites, thus loosing their brand. At any rate, this seems very different from China, and I’m yet to be convinced that we have started some sort of slippery slope.
- perl4ever 6y agoThe US is becoming like China? Billionaire tech magnate Jack Ma vs. Xi Jinping: who got to censor who? <lots of American counterparts> vs. Donald Trump: same question... Seems like the precise opposite.