3 ms·
If you read Wigner's famous essay, you can make an argument that if not the mathematics itself, there is some kind of structure which is mathematical if not sym
by mhh__ 6y ago
If you read Wigner's famous essay, you can make an argument that if not the mathematics itself, there is some kind of structure which is mathematical if not symbolic.
- ukj 6y agoSure. Any argument for structuralism is countered by non-structuralist/post-structuralist.
- mhh__ 6y agoThat's sounds like philosophy, I'm out!
- ukj 6y agoAnd just one post back you recommended a Philosophical essay ;)
- mhh__ 6y agoIt was partly a tongue-in-cheek dogwhistle to the physics crowd, but I do sort of feel that even the essay I cite is useless - interesting, yes. I (and I have tried) really struggle to see what the point is in learning all these philosophy terms when it usually or always ends up being unfalsifiable or a overly proud euphemism for yet another concept. To take a specific example, I'm curious what post-structuralism actually means as applied to the structure I was trying to refer to - there are certain symmetry groups that seem to apply everywhere we look, but the actual structure is itself isn't a symbolic concept in the same way the standard model is.
- ukj 6y agoTo me, the value of Philosophy isn't in learning any particular jargon/terminology (any more than learning the jargon of "symmetry groups" is a useful activity) - the value is in the general understanding of the process of how to develop jargon/terminology from first principles. From a physicists' perspective: to develop the language needed to describe/express the physics you are experiencing. There is certainly an element of wheel re-invention in first principles thinking, but acquiring maker's knowledge seems like a more rewarding endeavour than acquiring only user's knowledge. This process of creating new languages/jargon has a name in Computer Science: Meta-linguistic abstraction [1], and so the value of Philosophy (to me) is in the first paragraph of the Wikipedia article: >metalinguistic abstraction is the process of solving complex problems by creating a new language or vocabulary to better understand the problem space. And so this I find it fascinating when you say that... >there are certain symmetry groups that seem to apply everywhere we look Because your meta-language for talking about your experiences is the language of symmetry groups. Post-structuralism (and all Philosophy, really) is merely an attempt to escape the reductionist nature of that sort of language-centric thinking - it's an attempt to drag us out of the cave of Logocentrism [2]. Mathematics is only up to isomorphism - there's nothing in the symbolic denotation without the human connotation, so if structuralism is about symmetry (equalities) , post-structuralism is about asymmetry (inequalities). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metalinguistic_abstraction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metalinguistic_abstraction [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logocentrism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logocentrism