3 ms·
Exactly. And the most impactful solution is also one incompatible with growth-based consumer economy: buy less stuff. Recycling won't be an answer even if, thr
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
Exactly. And the most impactful solution is also one incompatible with growth-based consumer economy: buy less stuff.
Recycling won't be an answer even if, through some miracle, everything would became fully recyclable in practice. The reason is that most materials cannot be recycled indefinitely - they degrade. On top of that, turning trash into input material usually consumes some non-recoverable matter (e.g. chemicals to clean and process it). Then there's production waste that isn't recoverable too. All of this adds up into continuous churn.
So with recycling, instead of a Mine->Manufacture->Use->Trash pipeline, you have... Mine->Manufacture->Use->Trash pipeline where a fraction of matter makes a cycle from Trash to Manufacture. Two perhaps not immediately obvious facts: one, that fraction of matter that gets recycled becomes a fraction of a fraction on its next cycle - which is a series that converges to 0. Two, none of this matters as long the pipeline itself is going through exponential growth. You may slow it a little, but it's still exponential.
- narag 6y agoIsn't it sad that right to repair needs to be framed this way? I mean, it's fine to look after the environment. But... It seems impossible to ask for individual rights. This is after all an individual right. My right to repair something that I paid for. But... It's presented as a collective benefit, the abstract save the planet thing. We're nothing important unless we're a part of the collective. Or even worse, some abstract idea like the purity of our Precious Bodily Fluids. I'll go to sleep now.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWhy not push it on both fronts simultaneously? Right to repair has strong benefits for both individual freedoms and the environment.
- narag 6y agoIndeed, but you see, individual freedoms is not enough anymore.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoTwo is better than one, isn't it? Also, individual freedoms aren't the be-all and end-all. We're lucky that they align with environmental concerns in this case. Additionally, right to repair isn't really about individual freedoms. Most people aren't going to fix products that require complex repairs. The right to repair is, first and foremost, about allowing people to exercise that right through delegation to specialists. Unencumbered repairability allows for local markets of repair shops to form, that can offer repairs at reasonable price points.