3 ms·
"Freedom of speech is also freedom from compelled speech." Uh, aren't for example nutritional labels a form of compelled speech?
by inglor_cz 6y ago
"Freedom of speech is also freedom from compelled speech."
Uh, aren't for example nutritional labels a form of compelled speech?
- pavlov 6y agoYes, exactly. It's a very restricted and strictly formatted form of compelled speech on specific products. Like other limitations on free speech, it exists because lawmakers have judged the benefits to be greater than the downsides of limiting manufacturers' free speech. Now imagine a law that forces anyone with a website who ever had an unmoderated comment section to host and display those comments forever. That's the Polish law. Isn't that on a completely different level of compelled speech?
- hinkley 6y agoConsumer protection laws are written in blood. You can't leave arsenic out of your ingredients list any more than I can call myself a doctor and tell you to start eating roofing tar.
- inglor_cz 6y agoYes, I agree, I was only reacting to the OPs claim that the government cannot compel somebody to speak in a certain way.
- casefields 6y agoOur constitution and bill of rights were also written in blood. Which is why we don't have to bow to a king.
- nitwit005 6y agoAll warning or informational labels are forced speech. But, it's worth remembering that people used to do things like add morphine to products without labeling it. Most countries limit free speech when it can harm others directly.
- inglor_cz 6y agoYes, definitely. If the impression from my comment is that I disagree with this kind of obligation, I expressed myself in an unclear way.
- devwastaken 6y agoAs all laws there are limits to its use. Nutritional labels are comprised of factual content to the product. The government can't force political or other government opinion onto it. Or at the least politically fueled labelling should not be allowed. For example forcing a company to host images on their cigarette packs. This should be unconstitutional. General opinion especially political is protected, or at least is meant to be. People can make political products, but they have to be factual in their contents. This isn't very related to the issue of social media - the posts are from other people including the government. You can't compel a company to host your opinions. You could compel them to list factual information about its content/origin though.